All or nothing loyalty may be a big problem in a month or two. Building a large amount of loyalty in a guild makes it difficult to switch guilds. I have been an end-game player, so I'm in a CV raiding guild, but I could see that a character at an SV level who is progressing faster than their guild may want to move to a more powerful guild, and a character who is progressing slower than their guild will be pressured to leave the guild. But building loyalty from the ground up in a new home is tedious.
Perhaps you could allow a character who switches guilds to only lose one level. So a character with level 4 loyalty (say... half way to level 5), that chooses to switch a guild would lose one loyalty level, and begin in the new guild at the beginning of level 3. This would make sense in the game world, as a highly respected fighter from a friendly neighboring guild who wants to join would not ordinarily be forced to prove his worth like a new recruit, but would only lose a little ground.
Note that characters who hop guilds frequently would see their loyalty drop to zero after a few jumps.
The freedom to switch guilds without too much penalty could really improve the quality of the game for some, especially if there is a guild where two personalities seem to grate on each other. Neither wants to leave for lost loyalty, but the other 98 members are forced to put up with the problems, and in some cases, players might rather leave the game rather than start over in a new guild.
Perhaps you could allow a character who switches guilds to only lose one level. So a character with level 4 loyalty (say... half way to level 5), that chooses to switch a guild would lose one loyalty level, and begin in the new guild at the beginning of level 3. This would make sense in the game world, as a highly respected fighter from a friendly neighboring guild who wants to join would not ordinarily be forced to prove his worth like a new recruit, but would only lose a little ground.
Note that characters who hop guilds frequently would see their loyalty drop to zero after a few jumps.
The freedom to switch guilds without too much penalty could really improve the quality of the game for some, especially if there is a guild where two personalities seem to grate on each other. Neither wants to leave for lost loyalty, but the other 98 members are forced to put up with the problems, and in some cases, players might rather leave the game rather than start over in a new guild.