Book of Heroes

1.6.1 Raid caps and balance

Darkhorse

Site AdminTue May 14, 2013 1:09 pm
Heroes!

Many players are still concerned about raiding in 1.6. Specifically, there is concern about raid caps and the effect this has had on "casual" raiders. We have not stopped listening to your feedback! We will be increasing the raid caps in 1.6.1. Whether this means just increasing the caps slightly, by a large amount, or removing them entirely is still being determined. We are also still determining the effect this will have on subsequent raid parameters such as the mercenary cap, length, number of waves, etc. We will have more specific information to provide about 1.6.1 at the end of this week. Stay tuned!

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue May 14, 2013 2:18 pm
I feel bad for you guys Venan, you have been putting out a great product as a whole, and I think that the, sometimes violent, responses you get are indicative of how much people love this game. (Hell, I'm sitting at a client desk right now typing this shizzz instead of working! :D )

I also believe that game play, merc finder, guild loyalty, hero score fix and the new raid and quest line you guys put together in 1.6 has really been superb as a whole!!! You gave the community what many have been asking for and I am certain its frustrating to know you tried and then have to deal with the backlash as a few negatives have over-shadowed many positives.

But you have hurt a few key aspect of the game that have made it popular, as you are well aware.
To summarize them simply:

1. Social interaction has been nerfed. Guilds are becoming inherently more isolated. I miss casually visiting various guilds and friends.
2. Raids have become very tedious and feel more like work than fun. (silver and bronze even...Gold should be work!)
3. Mercy Merc'ing is dead.

I have proposed several solutions to these in various threads but I am going to succinctly summarize them here, simply because I am fixated on reading my own message posts. :)

Let us start with the big one...raid cap issues.
We need raids to not be as time intensive so casual raiding, which is the majority of the game can be restored.
Your raid cap idea in theory though is very good and prevents a lot of abuses...so I dont think you should lose it all together. I also do not think Gold should be made easy again. I am going to use a specific VG example with the concept of dynamic caps. The idea that caps can be adjusted per phase.

VG gold needs to be tough. But it shouldnt take 2:20 minutes...thats too long for most players to sit down and consistently tap or time their returns after dumping initial e, as RL does happen, even for hardcore gamers.

Phase 1 gold VG: Cap: keep it at 40.
Should finish within an hour (this is easier to manage in rl for most gamers....lunch breaks etc).
Should require atleast 50% members at Lvl 5 loyalty, and all others atleast at 42e
Everyone should dedicate full E for the full hour.
40 members starting at max e, 50% at L5 loyalty is a total of 1840
40 member regenerate 960e
total e then in an hour is 2800 or 1400 waves..similar to the 1471 from 1.5.

Its a bit of work to nail 1400 waves in an hour with 40 toons, but thats the challenge of gold.
Note too that even though the raid time for gold is much shorter than current 1.6, it would still require the same rate of "Kills per minute" as current 1.6, so burners still need to maintian the same rate of effort...only now over a 1hr period instead of 2.33 hr period which frankly is just too long for gaming.
After Gold passes, this is where I am open to exact suggestions, but something like lift the member/merc cap to 50 and make silver 30 mins later...if silver passes I would recommend lifting the cap/merc another 10 and setting the time 60 minutes later..only now in bronze "allow" players/mercs to "leave" and thus allow a mercy Mercing ability where players can come in, help save bronze and then leave to allow other players to keep bronze valor awards.

The idea here is to return to shorter raids, allow for tough gold...but also allow for a casual guilds to hit silver and eventually allow for a guild to open up to mercs to come in a save bronze and even mercy merc the raid for others as a good will gesture. This would allow global "emergency save our raid ads" to return as well! :)

The idea here is to allow for a competitive gold standard, but also allow for casual raiding to return and be enjoyable as well as mercy mercing to return as a social phenomena within the game. I am also not promoting this as the only solution...I merely like the example of dyanmic raid caps as it highlights the problems with the current system.


As for social interaction...their really needs to be a means of allowing our toons to travel outside their guilds to visit regardless of whether or not they are merc'ing in a raid. Here I really do like the idea of allowing Guilds to setup up a visitor chat channel where they can open 0-10 spots in their guild simply for people in other guilds to stop by and visit chat. You should probably change chat colors as well to allow people within guilds to easily recognize mercs/visitors within the guild (same as its now easy to recgonize mods/devs in chat)
This wouldn't impact raids at all, but really would allow a lot more social interaction between guilds and within the BoH community as a whole. It could even create opporunity for guilds to do interesting things such as a recuitiment parties...etc.

--geesh...now I need to get back to work...the 20 minutes on this post is more than this casual-hardcore gamer could really afford right now. 8-)
Venan,

PLEASE do not reduce the gold time any further. It used to be relatively challenging getting Gold for 1470 waves in 3 hours. To cut it to 1 hour would be suicidal, crazy.

Yesterday in KFS, 20 of us struggled through 3 hrs and barely made bronze with 3 minutes to spare, having burnt pots, runes, ...

Thank you for planning to raise the cap limit. At KOTOR, we are doing GK tonight with many toons unable to help including our GM with his GS wagon. It is extremely frustrating seeing your toon colleagues struggling to get silver and not able to help, with energy going down the drain. Just increase the cap by 10 or get rid of it altogether please. Thank you for a great game until v1.6 !

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue May 14, 2013 3:15 pm
Mystic18 wrote:Venan,
PLEASE do not reduce the gold time any further. It used to be relatively challenging getting Gold for 1470 waves in 3 hours. To cut it to 1 hour would be suicidal, crazy.

Mystic, I did not suggest 1hr for 1471..I was suggesting 1hr for 1400 which (ok so maybe thats not much of a difference! :D ), which admitedly is faster rate of kills than 1.6 is now (roughly 2010 waves in 140 minutes), only the guild needs to maintain it for 1hr and not 2:20hr. Also this rate is feasible without buring just requires a solid guild effort.

That being said, using the same gold rate of kills from 1.6 is equivalent to completing Gold 1.5 in about 1 hr and 41 minutes.
I think I have a great idea... but I will let the community decide if it has merit.

The mechanic at work is that a raid is a fixed number of waves, and faster completion determines higher rewards. What if...

Each raid was a fixed length of time, but reward level is based on completing "bonus phases". Kraken raid would have 3 phases for completion; if a 4th "bonus" phase is completed before the time limit, rewards go silver; if a 5th extra-hard phase is completed (imagine two krakens per wave!) reward is gold.

This allows altering gold level difficulty without messing with bronze or silver... and raids are completed in a more timely fashion, regardless of difficulty level.

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue May 14, 2013 7:51 pm
I think Niko's Idea is another great alternative that has potential.

Curious what other ideas people have.
I thought I made Niko's suggestion somewhere or am I dreaming about this now? Note; either is possible.

Either way, I like the possibility.
I only played a few raids since 1.6 and I feel like silver now is harder than gold before :? .
I have no issue with raising the bar so that gold isn't the default anymore but, as it's been mentioned, the combination of lower participant limit + much lower times + much higher number of waves killed casual gaming. Dumping your energy whenever you can will now handicap your guild rather than help it since you're taking a valuable slot.
Let's say in a VG, anyone below 6/7k rpp is slowing their guild down rather then helping it. It's pretty tough if you're not sure you can dedicate two hours to the game (and I wouldn't expect many people to be able to for a mobile game).

If you increase raid caps you'll avoid the frustration of people sitting outside of the raid being unable to help. It'll still be much harder than before to get gold due to higher number of waves and shorter times, but at least everybody can participate. As much as limiting mercs makes sense, a guild that can manage to get tons of members online at the same time should be allowed to use them.

Apart from that, nice patch. :D
Ill share my experience the last few days
since the raid caps and befoe the raid caps.

Before raid caps:

1st scenario
Got off work at 6pm on monday.
Saw spoons were doing a vg at 630pm. Prepped my toons for it.

2nd scenario
Got off at 530pm on tuesday. Saw that HJ had a gk at 90%. Thats about 1/3 into phase 4. Decided to dump a full e bar

With raid caps

Today, got off work around 630pm. Saw that there was a vg in progress at 95%, 3/4 way into phase 4. Saw that it was 40/40 and twiddled my thumbs with a full e bar.

Bottom line:
I used to be able to dump a full e bar at any given point when i had time available. With raid caps, i feel guilty for not being able to return or that i missed out because i couldnt participate.

If i wanted to commit my time to a 2-3hr raid, i would be playing a real mmo on my pc at the comfort of my home.

I feel the advantage this game had was it catered to the casual players. It is moving away from that.