Book of Heroes

Don't raise caps add boot inactive

Please don't raise caps. Gold should not be standard and all raising caps will do is make it harder for a lot of guilds on low raids to start raids. It is not rocket science that if you have more members active than cap you split across two raids.
Instead add a feature that you can kick a set number of inactives under 3000 RPP but they keep valor. This will allow busy members to help, prevent slack mercs from tying up raid without shifting overall balance of raid significantly.
The main issue is to many players expect gold to be handed to them on silver platter and in long run is better for game if you break them of this destructive expectation.
It's not an issue for my guild about Gold at all.

- It's when a guild member is at work and can't get to the raid exactly on time and locked out
- It's the guild member that loves to raid, but cannot guarantee he's got the couple of hours to dedicate and sits out so as to not be a hindrance just in case
- It's watching a raid fail while you've got 42 energy and not being able to help

Do not make this just an issue of "The guilds want easy gold", this cap is killing the casual raider, killing the uber dedicated player that has so many toons he has to sit one or more of them out, and killing the comradery between guilds and within when assistance cannot be rendered due to cap.
Oda_Sadaar wrote:It's not an issue for my guild about Gold at all.

- It's when a guild member is at work and can't get to the raid exactly on time and locked out
- It's the guild member that loves to raid, but cannot guarantee he's got the couple of hours to dedicate and sits out so as to not be a hindrance just in case
- It's watching a raid fail while you've got 42 energy and not being able to help

Do not make this just an issue of "The guilds want easy gold", this cap is killing the casual raider, killing the uber dedicated player that has so many toons he has to sit one or more of them out, and killing the comradery between guilds and within when assistance cannot be rendered due to cap.

Which will all be fixed if you can drop sandbagging mercs, or let your toilet raider burn then drop him out. I have 5 toons and we run dual raids on half hour delay, we have no problems seating everyone including on line, use mercs to fill holes and having seats left in overflow CK for latecomers. We have not failed any raids with mostly silver and gold running FS/CK or Vallus/CK.
Instead of seeing it as an obstacle see the opportunity to run a raid for your lowbies at every raid time on top of your standard raid for your top players. This means your high mighters get more raids their level and lowbies get a raid every single time. And two silvers is better than 1 gold anyway.
Sinphil wrote:Instead add a feature that you can kick a set number of inactives under 3000 RPP but they keep valor.
I can see that system being manipulated very easily. And I woudlnt say boot anyone under X number of RPP, it should be the rate of RPP gain, I could pound out 3000 RPP and then sit there and not help the rest of the raid, and for longer raids, that is the same as doing 100 rpp and then sitting there. It should be RPP gained / Time in raid. A rate at which should be the expected minimum from a consistantly raiding individual, or perhaps an Idle Time counter at which the officers are permitted to remove an inactive player.