One of my guild members said that he believed that guild master should automatically get full loyalty, which I agree with. This got me thinking that guild officers should be granted loyalty lv 2 or 3, if not full, as well. Just a thought
Secondly, gaining loyalty is pretty well balanced in terms of difficulty.
It's what? 250+500+750+1000+2500 = 5000 = Fully loyal.
If you log in 1x daily, dump all your energy, you'll gain Level 4 in 60 days, Level 5 in 114 days.
If you log in 3x daily, dump all your energy, you'll gain Level 4 in 20 days, Level 5 in 38 days.
If you log in 5x daily, dump all your energy, you'll gain Level 4 in 12 days, Level 5 in 23 days.
Or if you're a GM like me, running 12 raids a day, and dumping full e in all of them, you'll max out in 9 days
But either way, thats... without burning. And honestly, that sounds pretty balanced to me.