Book of Heroes

Update 1.6.1 - May 23, 2013 · page 13

JohnJSal wrote:

First off, no one is going to be happy with finishing bronze. If Venan wants silver to be the new standard, then I suppose that's just a paradigm shift we'll have to adjust to (or leave the game), but simply talking about "finishing" the raid at all (as opposed to failing it) tells me that we still aren't where we need to be with the numbers.

Secondly, I don't know where you got the idea to finish it with 10 people. I didn't suggest it needed to be that easy, so please don't try to simplify my argument.

Maybe you don't understand the point I'm making. It's just this: You seem to be using the 100 person raid cap to justify how long the raids are now, by suggesting that guilds can simply bring in more people to finish a raid if they're struggling. But this line of thought makes no sense to me if Venan is designing the raids around a certain number of people. Like I said before, if 30 is the target amount, then you shouldn't have to expect 40-50 people to participate in the raid to finish it, or even to get silver. I would argue that you should also be able to get gold with 30 people too, but perhaps Venan doesn't want that anymore without spending money.

You're not supposed to be happy finishing bronze...

We're talking about finishing because you said small guilds are failing raids. If you have a small guild then you'll have trouble transitioning between levels of valor. Risen from the Depths, Cursed Keep, and Goblin King are always difficult transitions because guilds never have enough attendance at first. Even large ones. It just so happens that many newer guilds have to recruit lower Might players and they are more likely to be the type that log in once a week. So yes, mercs are pretty important to low end guilds since most of the players who log in at least once daily have out leveled those raids. I understand that and perhaps Venan should notice that and make the cap they are balance around reflect that lower Might guilds get hit with a double whammy of not having enough members yet and more of their members not logging in to hit in almost any raid.

The other thing to keep in mind is that in the current form of balancing, guilds must necessarily fall apart for it to work. As players level up they'll be facing raids that require higher attendance. Guilds then need to absorb more members, but the only place to get characters with high enough might is from other existing guilds from the most part. Basically, in order to advance, you have to try and pull from other guilds and weaken another guild. Not saying it should be that way, but it seems to be the case.

That isn't my point. My point is that raids seem long to you because you are in a lot of raids with not enough hitters. Therefore Venan should balance low end raids around less people to account for more casual players. Not cut raids down all over.
AoW_McLovin wrote:
You're not supposed to be happy finishing bronze...

We're talking about finishing because you said small guilds are failing raids. If you have a small guild then you'll have trouble transitioning between levels of valor. Risen from the Depths, Cursed Keep, and Goblin King are always difficult transitions because guilds never have enough attendance at first. Even large ones. It just so happens that many newer guilds have to recruit lower Might players and they are more likely to be the type that log in once a week. So yes, mercs are pretty important to low end guilds since most of the players who log in at least once daily have out leveled those raids. I understand that and perhaps Venan should notice that and make the cap they are balance around reflect that lower Might guilds get hit with a double whammy of not having enough members yet and more of their members not logging in to hit in almost any raid.

The other thing to keep in mind is that in the current form of balancing, guilds must necessarily fall apart for it to work. As players level up they'll be facing raids that require higher attendance. Guilds then need to absorb more members, but the only place to get characters with high enough might is from other existing guilds from the most part. Basically, in order to advance, you have to try and pull from other guilds and weaken another guild. Not saying it should be that way, but it seems to be the case.

That isn't my point. My point is that raids seem long to you because you are in a lot of raids with not enough hitters. Therefore Venan should balance low end raids around less people to account for more casual players. Not cut raids down all over.

You, Sir, have clearly outlined my frustrations with this game for the last couple months - update or no. We were once a pretty good guild with older (25-40 year olds) players that could log in around our daily lives. We made our way through Goblins, Plaguerider, Lockbolts, Overseer and even Kraken having a good time. Suddenly, Attack at Dawn stalled us. We could never coordinate enough players to get through it. To make matters worse, mercs that we asked to come help would poach some of our better players back to their 'home guilds'. We would recruit more members, but they would have lower might and less experience, so we were still not going any higher on the raid chain.

I was really hoping that with 1.6 we would be able to get through these raids finally, but the restrictions are just too stiff. We were running Goblins and Plaguerider nonstop just to get members to guild loyalty 2 (and their benefits back). It hasn't helped. We are still stuck, and losing members every day to other guilds that get better raid results. Long story short, Book of Heroes requires a lot of coordination from a lot of people to get to end game. It is simply not for the casual player. I am hanging on long enough to see if PvP adds anything back for us casual players.
Austineze wrote:You, Sir, have clearly outlined my frustrations with this game for the last couple months - update or no. We were once a pretty good guild with older (25-40 year olds) players that could log in around our daily lives. We made our way through Goblins, Plaguerider, Lockbolts, Overseer and even Kraken having a good time. Suddenly, Attack at Dawn stalled us. We could never coordinate enough players to get through it. To make matters worse, mercs that we asked to come help would poach some of our better players back to their 'home guilds'. We would recruit more members, but they would have lower might and less experience, so we were still not going any higher on the raid chain.

I was really hoping that with 1.6 we would be able to get through these raids finally, but the restrictions are just too stiff. We were running Goblins and Plaguerider nonstop just to get members to guild loyalty 2 (and their benefits back). It hasn't helped. We are still stuck, and losing members every day to other guilds that get better raid results. Long story short, Book of Heroes requires a lot of coordination from a lot of people to get to end game. It is simply not for the casual player. I am hanging on long enough to see if PvP adds anything back for us casual players.
To respond to your last few statements, no game has its highest tier rewards set up for casual players. Or at the very least, no game worth playing. It's supposed to get harder and harder as the game progresses. Some games have a steeper progression rate than others. My guild is also struggleing with Attack at Dawn as some of our members dont raid soldier tier raids as mercs to gain valor and replace gear or gems, they raid gobblins or plaguerider for loyalty, which wont progress their might at all. :(
AoW_McLovin wrote:We're talking about finishing because you said small guilds are failing raids.

I never specified small guilds specifically, although I'm sure this is a big problem for them in particular. Even my own guild (with 90+ people) and large guilds I've merced for sometimes only finish silver, WITH burning, and other raids I've merced sometimes end up with bronze.

I guess the overall point I'm trying to make is simply that a larger guild cap (100) really doesn't solve the problem, because even a 100-member guild will only have 20-40 people on at one time to do a raid. Yet, despite Venan's assurance that they are "balancing" (whatever that means to them) the raids around 30-40 people, they still seem to be taking too long if you have anything less than the maximum number of members using the maximum amount of energy. And it's just not fun for this type of demand to be made just to get gold or silver without immense GS burn.
Spartanmerc wrote:
To respond to your last few statements, no game has its highest tier rewards set up for casual players. Or at the very least, no game worth playing. It's supposed to get harder and harder as the game progresses. Some games have a steeper progression rate than others. My guild is also struggleing with Attack at Dawn as some of our members dont raid soldier tier raids as mercs to gain valor and replace gear or gems, they raid gobblins or plaguerider for loyalty, which wont progress their might at all. :(

Yes, I completely understand the concept of getting harder as the game progresses. I am just saying that the level of commitment, here, on a mobile game should not be as demanding as a WoW.
Spartanmerc wrote:
To respond to your last few statements, no game has its highest tier rewards set up for casual players. Or at the very least, no game worth playing. It's supposed to get harder and harder as the game progresses.

But this is simply an artificial difficulty. To be authentically "harder," the encounters themselves should require some thought on how we use our abilities, rather than one or two shot everything until our energy is out.

"Harder" in my opinion shouldn't just mean LONGER. We all can only do so much with the energy we have, so the difficulty should come from skill, not money spent.
JohnJSal wrote:
Spartanmerc wrote:
To respond to your last few statements, no game has its highest tier rewards set up for casual players. Or at the very least, no game worth playing. It's supposed to get harder and harder as the game progresses.

But this is simply an artificial difficulty. To be authentically "harder," the encounters themselves should require some thought on how we use our abilities, rather than one or two shot everything until our energy is out.

"Harder" in my opinion shouldn't just mean LONGER. We all can only do so much with the energy we have, so the difficulty should come from skill, not money spent.
True, and I too wish there was more thought and strategy involved in the game play, but as with any online game, someone will always find the cheapest, easiest way to beat a game. The game developers have to work with what they have, and a large gaming console with a multi core CPU is not available. It's a simple, very cut down version of WoW. And just like WoW, the only way to progress is a long grind up the gear ladder.
Austineze wrote: Long story short, Book of Heroes requires a lot of coordination from a lot of people to get to end game. It is simply not for the casual player.

A patient (or cash heavy) casual player can get to the end game. However, GMing a guild is not casual and requires a lot of coordination to get the end game.

If any of you are casually GMing a guild, my advice is to immediately merge with another guild with a serious GM if you plan on the guild ever progressing beyond the SV raids.
Oda_Jetras_Sensei wrote:Any date nailed down yet for the release?

Was wondering the same thing. Twas supposed to happen sometime this week right? Would be nice to know if it'll be postponed :p