Book of Heroes

Update 1.6.1 - May 23, 2013 · page 4

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu May 16, 2013 2:55 pm
Darkskye wrote:Now, for FS and SC, I am a bit surprised. I know it is not popular, but if FS does not affect your servers, and isn't hard to maintain.... And if on the players side, it does not affect our gameplay, why remove it?

Right now, KV raids are our weakest raiding tier. We wanted to address this issue by consolidating the raids and make it more focused. We still have FS and SC in the back of our pockets, so you may see them come back in the future as a different type of raid.
Swanstar wrote:
I can't force people to show up, raid, or merc. Helion to ck gap is hard to do too.

That gap has always been a hard one for guilds to jump and many guilds die there. That's been true ever since the guild system was introduced. Don't worry, the CK to Vallus and then Vallus to WoF will offer similar challenges.
Little_Mike wrote:Without going into too much detail, each raid is balanced in such a way that we take into account a player's expected max energy counts. Simply, the raiders in The Plaguerider have less energy than raiders in the Battle of Vile Gate in our balancing equations. In 1.6, we miscalculated how much expected energy players would have from guild loyalty. In 1.6.1, we have addressed this.

Yet PLaguerider and Lockbolt are equal?

Comparing PLaguerider and Vile Gate is like comparing go-carts with NASCAR...

My point is 'expected max energy counts' etc. used for balancing equations means that 20 PR raiders will complete a raid in the same time as 45 raiders will complete Vile Gate? Presuming appropriate leveled players for each raid? I think historical data will poke holes in that balancing act....

Darkhorse

Site AdminThu May 16, 2013 3:08 pm
Amoron wrote:
Little_Mike wrote:Without going into too much detail, each raid is balanced in such a way that we take into account a player's expected max energy counts. Simply, the raiders in The Plaguerider have less energy than raiders in the Battle of Vile Gate in our balancing equations. In 1.6, we miscalculated how much expected energy players would have from guild loyalty. In 1.6.1, we have addressed this.

Yet PLaguerider and Lockbolt are equal?

Comparing PLaguerider and Vile Gate is like comparing go-carts with NASCAR...

My point is 'expected max energy counts' etc. used for balancing equations means that 20 PR raiders will complete a raid in the same time as 45 raiders will complete Vile Gate? Presuming appropriate leveled players for each raid? I think historical data will poke holes in that balancing act....

We take into account expected energy. These numbers came straight from our metrics of how much appropriate might and level raiders actually have for energy availability.

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu May 16, 2013 3:13 pm
I was comparing Skar and VG as an exaggeration. There is a difference with the balancing even between Skar and Lockbolt. By the way, this is nothing new, we have always been doing this when calculating raid balance.
Thanks Darkhorse for the reply...based on how 1.6 rolled out, the metrics must have been tweaked to require energy burning from other sources that cost gs...I have no doubt about that...

Thanks Mike for the reply...I still feel the mistakes made in 1.6 are haunting if same calculations are used...

PS: Thanks both for replies...I'm trying to be constructive with my comments....

I want to add this comment...a college professor came up with a great idea to disprove socialism. The professor stated all the students would get the same grade. He would average all scores scores for everyone's shared grade. The first test yielded a B. The next test D, and the final test F - they all failed. Basically, students thought they didn't have to study figuring the ones that did would carry the load....

It's very similar to raiding in BoH...there are players that will purchase gs and burn to finish raids...then the rest just e dump and go, or just check out the raid - play a little - then leave..the balancing formula has an oversight by presuming all raiders are equally invested in the raids... With the wave increases it forces burners now just to finish... I was one of those burners...but not anymore... You've made the raids too difficult for even the few that can carry the load...adding insult to injury - the waves were lengthened making it an absolute chore on top of it. Kraken is a perfect example! It's not just me that noticed, all long time players (12k might plus) are making the same observations...
So only 50% of guild loyalty is lost if changing guilds... So you can leave a guild and still be "half loyal" - that makes sense?!
So gold becomes standard, raids become longer and mercs are screwed over because some couldn't adapt. You never bothered checking with players just listened to whiners. Of course the people happy aren't going to post on forums you need find them.
If this comes in I done with Venan and BoH, knee jerk reactions without bothering to get feedback from both sides is pure and utter stupidity.
I agree with the raid changes being made in 1.61 i thought it ridiculous to spend 200+ shields in a raid and not get gold for it with the increased cap the casual raiders can dump e on their time however the 100 cap seems a bit high if the guild can have 100 players and all can raid whats to stop 100 ppl fromflying through raids nonstop for a couple hours on a saturday and yes its a lower reward but lower reward at faster raids with the proposed 30 minute cooldown means alternate gk vg and /win it wouldnt be hard for a player or guild to startup with the idea oh im gonna get all the raids unlocked boot everyone from guild then have a merc only guild mercs required to join guild(since they only lose 50% not a bad request) and say everysaturday run gk/vg alternating everytime they are off cd with 100 players who are essentially farming valor and hero score leaderboards for elixir of commerse
For what it's worth, I liked FS. It was a good well balanced raid. Vallus was easier though and more could join it so it was perhaps run more often for those reasons. I'd say WoF was less popular. It was usually hard to get Mercs for it. In our guild, as soon as the guild challenge was done, it wasn't run again. In the past, when I tried finding guilds that ran it, I found one and that was for challenge. FS hasn't been a problem to find... SC I didnt like for the most part. It was kind of nice to occasionally do for varieties sake but CoC works better for that I think