Book of Heroes

Valor for all raids

There are alot of thoughts I have about 1.6.1..
1. Why can't all raid have valor awarded, assuming that the raid is actually finished? Gold would have a high payout, but be difficult (possible but with a good guild turnout). Frankly some guilds just don't have enough people to commit to the larger raids, and players either have to leave the guild or merc (a painfully slow way of getting what you need). If the point of these changes was to increase guild loyalty, making it impossible for a guild to advance isn't helpful.

2.For new players, goblins should not need the support of so many other players. And plague is way too difficult for the payout that it gives. With the low might requirements, these should be able to complete by small toons that need to advance so that they can be helpful in the larger raids. Instead, the whole guild has to jump in and support them, draining energy that could be used in better ways. These 2 raids need to be rebalanced.

3. Raising the guild cap to 100 isn't really helpful. There have definitely been times when a toon couldn't get in, so it should be raised. However, as a member of a smaller squire guild, we simply don't have enough members for that to be helpful in the long run. Allowing enough mercs in would be more helpful. Alliances would also be an option for guilds to complete larger raids together. (Though taggers who only do 100 are not helpful). Perhaps you should be able to boot them, but then there has to be a control mechanism in place to manage that. Perhaps valor is distributed based on rounds, and you have to reclaim your spot - so a tagger that joins in round 1 would get points for his 100rpp, but then get booted for phase 2.

4. The raids also don't seem to be balanced in a way that the average amount of energy for that level of player is accounted for.

5. Casual players want to experience "end game" too. We get that it will take longer to get there, but it should be possible. Otherwise there is no point in continuing to play. Since money is made through playing (and not purchasing the game) one would assume that casual players would be able to reasonably advance.

6. I'm also disappointed that the raids have been removed - since I am not a high enough might to try them. Not sure why more raids ins't better - it already seems like there is too much of a jump between the might and power needed to do raids, as well as the difficulty of the raids as it is. It would be nice to have some raids that are geared towards a small number of people, yet challenging & provides decent valor for t10 stuff or above.

7. lastly the cool down on goblins is way too long, it would be helpful for newer characters to be able to run it more frequently.
RH_Alanna wrote:1. Why can't all raid have valor awarded, assuming that the raid is actually finished?

2.For new players, goblins should not need the support of so many other players. And plague is way too difficult for the payout that it gives. With the low might requirements, these should be able to complete by small toons that need to advance so that they can be helpful in the larger raids. Instead, the whole guild has to jump in and support them, draining energy that could be used in better ways. These 2 raids need to be rebalanced.

3. Raising the guild cap to 100 isn't really helpful. There have definitely been times when a toon couldn't get in, so it should be raised. However, as a member of a smaller squire guild, we simply don't have enough members for that to be helpful in the long run. Allowing enough mercs in would be more helpful. Alliances would also be an option for guilds to complete larger raids together.

5. Casual players want to experience "end game" too. We get that it will take longer to get there, but it should be possible. Otherwise there is no point in continuing to play. Since money is made through playing (and not purchasing the game) one would assume that casual players would be able to reasonably advance.

6. I'm also disappointed that the raids have been removed - since I am not a high enough might to try them. Not sure why more raids ins't better - it already seems like there is too much of a jump between the might and power needed to do raids, as well as the difficulty of the raids as it is. It would be nice to have some raids that are geared towards a small number of people, yet challenging & provides decent valor for t10 stuff or above.

7. lastly the cool down on goblins is way too long, it would be helpful for newer characters to be able to run it more frequently.
I'll address your points in sequence:

1. All raids reward valor when finished.

2. Gobblins requires very little support from guildies, its the smallest raid, but it IS still a raid, and by nature requires SOME teamwork. Plaguerider is the second smallest raid and as such SHOULD give a similarly small payout, else why would your guild try harder raids...

3. The guild cap wasn't raised to accomodate small guilds, as they were never at the cap anyway, that much should be plain as day. The guilds that were regularly at max capacity were having trouble with having to boot people for mercs to join, and with the addition of guild loyalty, that would penalize guildmates for no reason other than they were offline at the moment of a raid.

5. Casual gamers are very much capable of achieving end game content, and as you said, it will take longer for them to reach it. This might mean that instead of waiting for your guild to slowly grind its way into captains valor raids, you might try mercing periodicaly to advance your own might, thats what I do when there are too few guildies to raid a location the guild needs to beat.

6. You never got to play those raids, why would you be disappointed, no one played them apparently. So all you are missing out on is some wasted energy and failed raids in places no one wanted to go to. There is a large jump from one tier of valor to the next, but thats why you have to farm out that tier of valor and earn the gear piece by piece. It isnt just "beat this raid 5 times and you are ready for the next one". They might bring them back later on or put in new, more fun raids in their place.

7. The cooldowns are going to be 30min in the next patch, that allows you to regain 12 energy. If you have more than 12 energy in your e-pool, you should at least be raiding in Plaguerider or Lockbolt periodicaly and not so worried about Goblins, which as you know, gives you crap payouts...

I hope this helps.
PS: I didnt address number 4 on purpose because there are some things that should be altered a bit, but it would be too long to delve into in a single post, not to mention its not really my place to tell the game developers they need to make it easier for people to be done with their game.
I whole-heartedly agree that all raids should give valor and I've suggested it in the past as well.

Casual players should be able to advance via the merc system, but lower raids are a bit much considering they're still on the leveling curve and players in that might range don't play as often most likely.

The raids were removed because no one ever did them and now everyone is complaining that those are the only raids they ever liked. They already said those raids may come back in the future. For now they seem to be streamlining the game in a lot of ways.
1. The point of giving valor for all raids (assuming they finish) is that I was in raids that were unable to finish because of time restrictions. Thus a group of players gained experience playing, and silver or other payouts, but did not receive any payout in valor because they were unable to finish. With the newest patch, I haven't seen this as a problem.

Maybe no one did do the raids that were removed, but from these boards it seemed like people built their toons to play in SC as that was the best "test" for the build. Assuming that this is true, then I am disappointed not to see what that was like.

Cool downs were not changed... fine for larger raids, but not helpful for smaller raids. my point about goblins is that when you are "training" a bunch of new players, running frequent low raids is helpful. Since running these raid takes guild support often players with significantly higher might and energy also do goblins and plague. Goblins currently has 105 waves, requiring 210 energy, requiring 17.5 toons with 12 energy to pull it off in a half hour (without regen, just to simplify). Obviously this realistically requires help from people that have larger energy pools to pull from.

in terms of the guild cap, as I said it should be raised. It sucked to be "helpless' to help the guild because a merc joined, swung once and left. However, I think that the merc cap should still be a little higher. I like the password feature, and we often use that so that people who are aligned to the guild can merc in, but it would be nice if that cap was larger. And actually, this is from the point of view of both a merc and a guildie looking for a merc...

and I really don't know what your issue is with "not to mention its not really my place to tell the game developers they need to make it easier for people to be done with their game." I am doing nothing more or less than many people on here who are expressing opinions. I made that comment because I had heard on global that all raids were calculated based on each character having 40 energy. Since obviously few people in the squire tier have that much energy, and are likely to also be in smaller guilds, I think this makes it challenging, though playing after the patch the raids do seem to be better balanced then I was expecting. Also, balancing the raid to be done with people who are at same level as the raid has nothing to do with helping people be done with their game, so I don't get what your saying.

I would go on, Spartanmerc, but you seem to have not gotten the point of anything that I discussed, and I am not sure what you were "helping" with.
SC was unique. Most people hated it though a few loved it. The major loss there IMHO is just variety.

FS and GK are more or less the same raid with the order of phases 2 and 3 swapped. Back when I was at KV level (late last year), it was my favorite KV raid.