Book of Heroes

So.... Shadow Walker

I have been playing this game for some while now and I have 3 different chars, SW, Justicar and Mage.

I have more or less got hold of Justicar and Mage build and rotations but SW is still bugging me. I hope I will get some help by writing this post.

So I'm full T12 and 85% gems is T2 and time for me to change gems or higher lvl so that is also one of the reasons for me to ask for help here before I start spending Valor. So I have been focusing to use HT for Haste for now.

I feel like I always have to use to much potions compared to my other 2 tons. so this is how my char looks like:

Build:
0303
3033
3033
0303

Stats:
Melee: 2169
Magic: 479
Crit: 776 (21,07%)
Crit P: 1712 (177,545)
Defense: 1751 (19,09%)
Dodge: 1672 (44,53% in green)
Haste: 2420 (35,38 in green)

NO ENCHANTS SO FAR.

So can anyone tell me what I'm doing wrong/right and come with some tips? Someone told me to go for Poison build and change gems out with magic for now with silver :)

Thanks for all help :)
First, why don't you have 1 pt in Ensnare and maybe smoke bomb? Ensnare at 1 is a MUST HAVE for all SWs.

Well, you do have to decide if you are a poison or a melee SW. You have a melee build.

Some people love the melee build. Unfortunately, I am not one of them. I have a level 22 melee SW and I completely hate it. I am on the brink of giving up on it. My (much higher level) poison SW I like a lot better.

If it was me, I would switch to a poison build because it is so much more effective at mobs. But hopefully a pro-melee person will speak up and give you the other side.
TSA_mirnes wrote:I have been playing this game for some while now and I have 3 different chars, SW, Justicar and Mage.

I have more or less got hold of Justicar and Mage build and rotations but SW is still bugging me. I hope I will get some help by writing this post.

So I'm full T12 and 85% gems is T2 and time for me to change gems or higher lvl so that is also one of the reasons for me to ask for help here before I start spending Valor. So I have been focusing to use HT for Haste for now.

I feel like I always have to use to much potions compared to my other 2 tons. so this is how my char looks like:

Build:
0303
3033
3033
0303

Stats:
Melee: 2169
Magic: 479
Crit: 776 (21,07%)
Crit P: 1712 (177,545)
Defense: 1751 (19,09%)
Dodge: 1672 (44,53% in green)
Haste: 2420 (35,38 in green)

NO ENCHANTS SO FAR.

So can anyone tell me what I'm doing wrong/right and come with some tips? Someone told me to go for Poison build and change gems out with magic for now with silver :)

Thanks for all help :)

Good news is you're at a good place to make the melee vs. magic decision. Personally, I chose a pure melee build up through about ~16-18k might (all t4s, t14 armor, no enchants). It was great against bosses, okay against mobs. But all in all, I didn't like the lack of aoe all that well, nor did I like the fact that my runes did nothing. So I switched to a heavily magic focused hybrid. However, this update really boosts melee SWer's potential.

It tends to work significantly better vs. mobs (potential to nearly one-hit once enchants are all done), and okay against bosses. Downside of the build is that I really miss having a quick clearer like reflexive strike, but that's an issue that'll theoretically go away once this is fully enchanted.

Regarding abilities... really depends what you're aiming for.

Pure Melee... you almost definitely want Piercing Stike, Reflexive Strike, Critical Eye, Dual Wield.
Hybrid Melee... you almost definitely want Piercing Strike, Toxic Blade, Acid Spray, Reflexive Strike, Dual Wield.
Hybrid Magic... you almost definitely want Piercing Strike, Toxic Blade, Acid Spray, Poison Cloud, Caltrops.
Pure Magic... you almost definitely want Acid Spray, Poison Cloud, Toxic Blade, Caltrops + Ensnare and/or Smoke Bomb.
For every SW, regardless of build... you want Assassinate, Corrosive blades, Neurotoxin.

Optional Fun bits to add if room: Manuever, Riposte, Urgency

Hybrid Melee tended to be my preferred build for onslaught. Nowadays, I use Hybrid Magic for CV raids.

I disagree with Bbbb regarding ensnare/smoke bomb. They're undoubtedly useful, and definitely have their place, but I get more use spending the spare points on Piercing Strike + Critical Eye. Now, yes, I know I said I was full magic, but just passive melee bonuses (450 from level 30, 1200 from melee ht, +0.05% from guild favor) already result in a +700 or so damage bonus, which is significant enough to take Piercing Stirke (which is a 100% crit at high crit values).

My issue is that the only enemies I'd ever use ensnare on are high level bosses... who stat resist so often that it isn't worth the time. I'd love to incorporate smoke bomb if I had room, but I don't ;)
I don't have the skill tree in front of me since the game is down but I think that means you have...

3 Caltrops
3 Dual Wield
3 Piercing Strike
3 Maneuver... or whatever
3 Assassinate
3 Reflexive Strike
3 Critical Eye
3 Riposte
3 Umm poison crit thing lol
3 Corrosive Blades

So basically my exact build before I respecced.

Okay, so here's my suggestion since I had your build before and Trask was kicking my hiney about a month ago then after respecced he couldn't touch this (and no one has ever since unless I'm falling asleep in a portal against a behemoth x_X).

1) Take all points out of Riposte and put them into Smoke Bomb. I know it looks bad on paper but Smoke Bomb is an AOE knock back that refreshes your best damage-per-second moves and basically locks your opponents into doing nothing while you kill them. It's very fast and it literally sets your opponent back in time and puts you into the future. Yeah, we're that fast :D I say take out Riposte because Riposte forces you into using the regular melee attack sometimes due to cool downs not being reset.

2) Take 1 point out of Maneuver and put it into Ensnare. Ensnare is particular useful when you need to stop the enemy's bar but Smoke Bomb is down or it hasn't been long enough into the fight to Smoke Bomb them.


The way I kill things is generally:

Reflexive Strike
Piercing Strike
Reflexive Strike
Smoke Bomb
[Repeat]
When all else fails melee


That's a VERY LOOSE rotation. Sometimes if they're going to hit me I'd rather just RS-Smoke Bomb or if I have time RS-PS-Smokebomb then RS-PS-RS.

By the way, the amount of time Smoke Bomb sets back an enemy is sufficient to pull off RS-PS-RS with a moderate amount of Haste.

The reason I say RS-PS-RS as the core rotation is because RS is the best DPS we have at high crit/crit power level (yes, even stronger than PS per second). PS is obviously amazing as well and using it resets the cooldown of RS.

Regular melee is useful for when an enemy has low enough health that a MH swing will kill it then the OH hits the second opponent who is hopefully finished off or further weakened by Assassinate. It also resets the cooldowns of RS and PS.

Use Caltrops as needed. I use it on most fights when enemies that aren't grey because I hate misses.

So don't be discouraged just yet. Physical build also has the advantage of being able to invest all red gems into melee and with Assassinate we don't really need a dedicated AOE ability beyond Caltrops.

Replace the Dodge gems with crit. You won't get hit much here and Riposte will be gone. Riposte builds basically like leaving themselves open to get beat up just so they can proc a gimmick. Between SB and Ensnare you won't get hit much. Against single targets you can literally Ensare > Caltrops > PS > RS > SB > RS > PS > RS... it'll be dead by then and you'll be untouched.
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Pure Magic... you almost definitely want Acid Spray, Poison Cloud, Toxic Blade, Caltrops + Ensnare and/or Smoke Bomb.

I say no to Caltrops on magic builds. I've barely used it in months and in fact though I'm a 99% magic build, I am removing it to take Crit Eye instead (yes, I am aware it is a melee skill as I use PS and RS a little).
I am wondering, with the change to critcal eye (adding a crit damage bonus to it) does that mean ALL crits or just physical crits? cuz if its all crits I might be respecing after the patch...

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu May 23, 2013 3:58 pm
Spartanmerc wrote:I am wondering, with the change to critcal eye (adding a crit damage bonus to it) does that mean ALL crits or just physical crits? cuz if its all crits I might be respecing after the patch...

Physical crits only.
Hi and tnx again

It is helpful to get it down like you did here. This will help me to decide what to do further on.

I will try, before changing out red gems, to go for a small change on melee, as suggested here, and see how it works. Like you are discussing here I feel there is not much AOE in pure melee spec, and sometimes I miss that.

So for now small change and definitely I will try out poison, never played it :) Gems will come and go but it will take time :)

Thank you again and BIG TNX too:

Fizz_Eric
AoW_McLovin
Bbbb (yes I have asked my self the same question :D)

This is what makes Venan a great community: Great Ppl!!!

Thanks again

TSA_mirnes
If you have 2-3 points in corrosive bade, it's very likely you can use caltrop to stack poison to your enemies which is faster than acid spray tho caltrop doesn't do initial damage . I rarely have caltrop in my magic sw build, but I put it in my build because of karnak.
That's an interesting point Tiffy. Since I haven't used the SW on the Karnak raid yet, I may try that out before respecing.