Just had Karnak drop a second nature dmg bonus, which seems a bit odd. And, mildly annoying since it's the physical dmg bonus that I'd prefer:)
Karnak is not a mob, he's a boss.
If your luck enchant kicks in on the boss you'll get a second drop of something from his drop pool. That might end up being the same recipe just dropped on the first drop, unfortunately. This is something Venan might consider fixing if you raise it as a bug issue.
I got two of Karnak's broken rings for one of my toons, because I happened to get a double drop on the end of quest kill.
It was not a luck enchant proc - and it just happened a third time. He dropped the nature recipe again zzz.
And I did just post it on the bug forum - hopefully it will be addressed.
This has always been like that. I've received Initiative I think it is from Direhorn about 4 times now but still no sign of the Block Enchant.
You just have to get lucky and hope you get the one you want!
While I appreciate the answer BrettvG, that news makes Baby Jesus cry

I've received countless 1h enchants from LoB and no 2h yet. The drops are random, they don't consider what you've already gotten.