Book of Heroes

Loyalty Transfer

Is there any consideration to allowing maybe a one time transfer of some or part of guild loyalty? Cant see where its a players fault when their guild starts becoming inactive.
They made a concession already. They started with guild loyalty being reset to ZERO, now it's just halved. This means if you are maxed guild level 5 and you move, you will still be level 4 in your new guild. I think this is a fair compromise.
I think maybe after hitting loyalty level 5 you should be able to still earn loyalty up to 2x the current cap with no level gain.

This would allow you to switch guilds while remaining at loyalty level 5 if you had earned enough loyalty and it still prevents guild hopping which is what the system was trying to fix.
Because to me it still fixes guild hopping while not penalizing players who are stuck in a dead guild or that get kicked from the guild when it wasn't their choice.
We're just going to have to agree to disagree on this point. I think the loyalty system is just about perfect as it is and Venan did the right thing by making the loss 50% instead of 100%. Any system (like the one you propose) that allows someone to jump guilds and still remain level 5 loyalty is preposterous in my mind. How can you be the new person in the guild and be level 5 loyal, when there are members that have been with that guild longer than you with less loyalty? Because you were loyal to another guild and got your level up? I'll never understand this.
Well I agree with the points you are making for sure. However, if you got kicked out of your guild it doesn't seem fair to lose 50% loyalty either but if they fixed that then people would just kick themselves to avoid losing loyalty.

Thinking about it more, it probably is fine the way it is and we just have to accept a few minor cons for the vast amount of pros the system offers.
Agreed. And I can certainly see how you are upset with your guild situation.

Wait a second...

Did we just have differing opinions, remained respectful of each other and came to see each other's point and didn't devolve into a flame war?

I don't think this has happened in the history of the internet ;)


You sound like a good player and you deserve a good guild that will support you. There are several excellent guilds out there, but may I suggest Oda? I don't want to turn this into a recruitment post, but we do have over 700 members across 9 guilds. There is a place for every might player, and we believe in loyalty, honor and respect.

Darkhorse

Site AdminThu May 30, 2013 7:24 pm
Hi guys and gals,

We're pretty happy with the way it is now, but we'll continue to evaluate into the future.
Perhaps... transferring guilds lets you keep half your loyalty... UNLESS you spend X gold shields, in which case, you keep 90% of your loyalty. I'm thinking of X in the 20 to 50 range.

The problem here, of course, is that big spending players get the freedom to guild hop while casual players must choose their guilds carefully. I'm not sure that will improve the game atmosphere.