Nor would a merger be fair to at least one of the groups. That's why I said I'd like to see guilds fleshed out more with alliances and the like rather than just a quick fix of merging.
Alliances generally don't work. I can't think of one long lasting alliance in the game. Alliances were all the rage back in the early fall last year. All those died out.
Mergers don't have a great success rate but have done better than alliances so far. Alliances require two (or more) leaderships to get along over the long haul when their goals tend to drift over time. A successful merger requires one leadership willing to give up control. (Note: I am aware HJ does not follow that pattern but every rule needs its one exception).
PS I am not calling Feeder guilds under a single management an alliance.