Book of Heroes

SMH ... Katy and Venan - so disappointed

Can I say that while I can understand the need for silencing or banning permanently or temporarily or whatever for certain things, I think that in this situation you've made an error, and I have a suggestion that I'll get to in a moment.

I'm a rational person and I understand that there are three sides to every story, the aggrieved persons, the aggrieving persons and then the truth somewhere in the middle. From a somewhat external perspective I see blame at both ends of this issue. There has been clear examples of favoritism and nepotism and just plain bad moderation on one side, and antagonizing and almost harassing on the other. They are kind of cause and effect and tend to bounce off each other.

I actually would have no problem if LadyKaty was also perma banned, but that's about as likely as a reasoned response to this thread from Venan, or consistent and good moderation from LadyKaty.

So, on to my suggestion. Why don't you include another layer in your banning toolset that includes the channels a person is banned from (if you do not already have it)? Perma ban from global and whisper if needed but leave guild chat alone. I assure you that 100% of the guild masters and officers back this person in guild chat and most likely 100% of the guild does too. Why would you care if he can only talk in guild chat? You solve the other problems by locking down whisper and global and we have a significantly different and less problematic issue.

Reflect on it. The GM's of any guild can clearly request guild chat bans for people if they want, and if they provide screenshot proof of abuse etc, so it can still be locked down if there are people who abuse the guild chat channel.

And as a parting shot, to be seen to be fair and equitable, it'd be nice, IMO, if LadyKaty could have her mod rights revoked.

Helmsman_Egomaniac

Thu May 30, 2013 10:08 pm
Asandir wrote:Can I say that while I can understand the need for silencing or banning permanently or temporarily or whatever for certain things, I think that in this situation you've made an error, and I have a suggestion that I'll get to in a moment.

I'm a rational person and I understand that there are three sides to every story, the aggrieved persons, the aggrieving persons and then the truth somewhere in the middle. From a somewhat external perspective I see blame at both ends of this issue. There has been clear examples of favoritism and nepotism and just plain bad moderation on one side, and antagonizing and almost harassing on the other. They are kind of cause and effect and tend to bounce off each other.

I actually would have no problem if LadyKaty was also perma banned, but that's about as likely as a reasoned response to this thread from Venan, or consistent and good moderation from LadyKaty.

So, on to my suggestion. Why don't you include another layer in your banning toolset that includes the channels a person is banned from (if you do not already have it)? Perma ban from global and whisper if needed but leave guild chat alone. I assure you that 100% of the guild masters and officers back this person in guild chat and most likely 100% of the guild does too. Why would you care if he can only talk in guild chat? You solve the other problems by locking down whisper and global and we have a significantly different and less problematic issue.

Reflect on it. The GM's of any guild can clearly request guild chat bans for people if they want, and if they provide screenshot proof of abuse etc, so it can still be locked down if there are people who abuse the guild chat channel.

And as a parting shot, to be seen to be fair and equitable, it'd be nice, IMO, if LadyKaty could have her mod rights revoked.

Exceptionally well written and well thought out response to the atrocious event that transpired earlier today Asandir!

You have said what has been on many minds, and I hope that your reasonable and diplomatic proposal doesn't fall on deaf ears.

~ Ego
I am not a fan of Lady Katy's favoritism however she is not the only bad apple of the bunch. LK does tend to take heat off the greenies and claim some doings when it was a different mod. These mods know who they are and all I ask is that you cowards take ownership of your warnings and silencing.

You don't want to be the bad guy so then why are you a mod? I was a victim of favoritism. The mod M** (I won't use the name to avoid backlash but it's not hard to figure out) was tested. You failed the favoritism test. There are others as well.

Seems a bit one sided. Lets warn the one that wasn't a friend and not warn the friend who did the same only more.

My suggestion: wipe all mods clean of the green and start over. Don't let Lady Katy or another Dev take the heat for what a mod has done. Punish the mods that don't play fair. Time to clean house.

**Free Beener**
CrzyHopper wrote:I am not a fan of Lady Katy's favoritism however she is not the only bad apple of the bunch. LK does tend to take heat off the greenies and claim some doings when it was a different mod. These mods know who they are and all I ask is that you cowards take ownership of your warnings and silencing.

You don't want to be the bad guy so then why are you a mod? I was a victim of favoritism. The mod M** (I won't use the name to avoid backlash but it's not hard to figure out) was tested. You failed the favoritism test. There are others as well.

Seems a bit one sided. Lets warn the one that wasn't a friend and not warn the friend who did the same only more.

My suggestion: wipe all mods clean of the green and start over. Don't let Lady Katy or another Dev take the heat for what a mod has done. Punish the mods that don't play fair. Time to clean house.

**Free Beener**

HURRAY CRZY!!
Down with unfair modding on a bad mood day!!
Just because there are good days; bad days; players who Mods are friendly with and players who are not, the yardstick for silencing suddenly becomes flexible?
I applaud Mods who do not abuse this authority just because they are having a bad day... Keep that up!!
As for the others... You should resign

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri May 31, 2013 7:59 am
I'm sure there is a complaints procedure that can be followed (like any company should have) if anyone feels they have a genuine complaint. Anything you post here can be read by the entire BoH community and may cast you in bad light, as well as adding fuel to the fire.

Darkhorse

Site AdminFri May 31, 2013 2:00 pm
Hi Everyone.

I'm going to put a few things to rest right away. Beener has historically had over 140 moderation reports or actions against his account. This is almost 4x as many as the next person who wasn’t just silenced, they were permanently banned. This was not simply a result of any particular singular incident. This account has been in review for some time and this decision was made completely independently by the senior leadership of our studio without any input from Lady_Katy.

The decisions were made on the following criteria:

-A pattern of behavior over a long period of time specifically centered on harassment, bullying, and abuse.
-Specific comments made toward devs or mods that were completely inappropriate (for example, commenting on a mod's genital cleanliness habits is generally not a topic one needs to discuss in public forums or conveyed privately to a mod or dev).

While no comments were personally made toward me, if some of the comments that I saw pulled from the logs were made to me in private, I would not have hesitated to institute a permanent silence.

That being said, there are some other things I would like to comment on:

-The general sentiment that mods/devs “abuse their power” or that mods/devs act inconsistently or with personal intent: This is something we are going to be looking at more closely in the future. We’ve been working to get our moderation policy as consistent as possible and will continue to do so in the future.

-Silences shouldn’t affect guild chat, only global and whispers to those outside of one’s guild: I think this is a fair point, and actually tend to agree on a personal level. That being said, this is something we’ve been considering for some time, but it’s not going to happen overnight. It requires development time, changes to the server, and changes to the client. We will continue to evaluate this option as we move forward.

-The sentiment that “other people have done worse” and gotten away with it: While it’s entirely possible that certain comments have slipped through the cracks, this idea is frankly unfounded. As I mentioned above, players with less infractions by a factor of four have come off with full bans. If anything, our tolerance toward Beener has been more lax than most circumstances. This leads me to my last point…

We will be working in the future to make sure that there is a more consistent level of reprimands taken against players who consistently abuse chat privileges. Moving forward, we will work to make this more streamlined across our moderation process, and make sure that everyone is being treated with the same levels of consideration.

Now that that has been said, I’m locking this topic. It’s time that the people involved in this from the Venan development side step away from this issue and get back to doing what is important: Working on future content and continuing to build a game that everyone can enjoy.