Book of Heroes

The Weekly SW Question · page 2

Denrael wrote:That's why I built up Caltrops. With CB, it gives me a good fast chance to lay in a poison as the first thing on an attack run. Usually I follow that with AS/SB/PC, or if needed based on timing, PC/SB/AS.
I'd lead off with Acid Cloud, its not as fast as Caltrops, but it always gives you at least 1 application of Poisoned, which is all you need for the crit chance buff off Neurotoxin. If you gain a second stack, all the better for TB or PC (depending on if its a crowd or single target). Neurotoxin is great, its basicly a substitute for Critcal Eye for the poison build (without the nifty crit dmg increase). Caltrops for me is mostly a debuff to their speed for longer fights, sacrificing 1 point from it wont hurt you, and if it gains you a point in another talent that does help, well worth the trade.
If you are using caltrops to poison enemies, 1-2 points would be sufficient. 3 points for a poison build is a waste.
I have an almost exclusively poison build. Nothing in melee except tokens. The benefit of this build is that it is very effective in clearing mobs - usually two hit - PS and AC. On VG, I make sure to drain my SW during P1. Then use my Mage and Justicar against P2/3 more although with its speed, the SW is good against the Behemoth.

Tiffy's advice is good. However, given my slightly different build, I differ on Caltrops.

I have caltrops and honestly outside of maybe (and just maybe) Karnak I found caltrops 100% useless once you get to a certain point. I'd rather wait the extra .15s (with my haste) for Acid Spray to give me 100% chance of poisoned over caltrops 50% chance. I really need to spec it out though I'm giving Venan one more chance to fix Karnak to be a raid many guilds can run before doing my respecs. At lower mights, Caltrops is more helpful I will admit.

On Urgency, it is a critical skill if you are doing onslaught.

I do have PS and a point in RS (every build needs RS). I currently don't have Crit Eye, but given the recent crit power change to it, when I respec, it will get added to my build.
So I notice you didn't mention PC Bbbb, does that mean you aren't speccing it, and using AC as your only group attack other than runes?
Denrael wrote:So I notice you didn't mention PC Bbbb, does that mean you aren't speccing it, and using AC as your only group attack other than runes?
He did
Bbbb wrote:I have an almost exclusively poison build. Nothing in melee except tokens. The benefit of this build is that it is very effective in clearing mobs - usually two hit - PS and AC.
Though I suspect he meant PC and AS (Poison Cloud and Acid Spray) as he was mentioning clearing groups of targets.
I run a similar strategy, Acid Spray, then Poison Cloud, that way the AS grants the extra crit chance due to Neurotoxin and an extra 15% (or 30% if CB procs) nature damage for the larger attack of Poison cloud. Clatrops is seeming like a bit of a hastle to keep reapplying it mid combat and I'm thinking of ditching it soon, just wondering where to put those 2 points I have in it to make good use, maybe Assassinate...
Ok, if he meant PC not PS it makes sense. I was reading it as Piercing Strike which seems to be the one everyone says to get. I've got PC and AS, and my biggest issue now is the delay time in throwing PC. Guess I just need to keep working on my haste to get that down. Right now if I get 3 28's, chances are I'm taking some damage.
My question is if PS and especially RS start to fall behind in damage once you're lv 18 Nature dmg and all red gems dedicated to Magic and the enemy has already been Poisoned. Is it really worth investment in CE just to boost abilities that have no other support in your build except for passive stats?
Personaly, I feel that if you are going to play a toon like the SW, you should pick either all Melee with maybe one AOE poison spell to help with groups and go for crits, or all Poison and go for speed speed speed. I started off a full melee, but as I gained might and levels, I realized I need more AOE, so I went all poison and am gearing for haste. I wouldn't pick up PS or RS at all as it would pretty much require me to get CE to help them out, dumping a few gems for melee into my gear and weakening my AoE isn't going to help their damage enough to make them worth losing points elsewhere. My suggestion is to decide if you want fast AoE, or constant crits. You might be able to get away with having PS without CE due to the bonus crit chance the spell itself provides, but I haven't tried that, someone else can do it and let me know how it works out :D .
AoW_McLovin wrote:My question is if PS and especially RS start to fall behind in damage once you're lv 18 Nature dmg and all red gems dedicated to Magic and the enemy has already been Poisoned. Is it really worth investment in CE just to boost abilities that have no other support in your build except for passive stats?

I'm at 12% physical, 14% nature, 10000+ magic (nearly maxed), 1500 melee-ish with the exact scenario you mentioned above.

PS still solidly hits 8-9k on crits (which is like almost always w/40% crit), Toxic Blade hits slightly less than that when it doesn't crit. Fully poisoned, Toxic Blade hits closer to 18k on crits, but bosses rarely last to the point of being fully poisoned (vg/gk, can't speak for karnak).

PS might not be comparable to a fully poison-stacked toxic blade crit, but it more than holds its own for now.
I don't have RS so I can't speak for it however.

Though alot can change when my magic is maxed and I have the extra 4% nature damage, but I haven't had too many problems yet.
I just threw one point into PS to see what effect it might have as an alternative to PC, at least until I get my haste to the point that throwing PC doesn't mean I take damage from the world. For the moment, it seems to be helping against those at my level and above. I'm still taking some damage from 28-30, (just turned lvl 28), but the Caltrops/AS/TB/PS sequence, tossing in Ensnare and Cloud when they make the most sense seems to be giving less damage than doing that with PC.