Book of Heroes

Raid Style: Challenge (or Action)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Jun 3, 2013 2:11 pm
Subject
Raid Style: Challenge (or Action)

Challenge Raids would be similar to Onslaught Raid but instead of Onslaught Timer, it would have a Challenge Counter. Challenge Counter is an X counter that decreases by 1 each time you press a button. Ex: Challenge Counter equals 50 drops to 49 when you use a Minor Break Rune. Then drop to 48 when you use Brutal Strike.

When the Challenge Counter reaches 0, your energy is spent and you receive your Loot Drop just like the Onslaught Timer.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
v1.6.1 rewards Melee/ Magic, Crit/ Haste, and Crit Power (MMCHCp). The Challenge Counter Raid or Phase would reward Justicar's with Chain Armor and characters that choose defensive Gems like Max Health, Dodge, Physical Resist and Magic Resist.
Why would this reward characters that choose defensive Gems like Max Health, Dodge, Physical Resist and Magic Resist?

Sounds like onslaught with a twist to me. Still rewards those who can do the most dps in as little clicks as possible.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed Jun 5, 2013 3:26 pm
Fizz_Eric wrote:Why would this reward characters that choose defensive Gems like Max Health, Dodge, Physical Resist and Magic Resist?

Sounds like onslaught with a twist to me. Still rewards those who can do the most dps in as little clicks as possible.

Challenge Raids would reward Damage Per Attack and Damage Over Time versus Onslaught Raids rewarding Attacks Per Second and Damage Per Second. One of the consequences of Onslaught is the overwhelming importance of Haste. Haste 75% siginificantly cuts down on Monster attack opportunies. Attacks like Reflexive Strike also cuts down on Monster attack opportunities. Slower attacks would have less of a penalty in Challenge Raids, since they tend to do more Damage Per Attack. Slower attacks also allow more Damage Over Time to proc. Two Handed Attacks tend to be slower, but do significantly more Damage Per Attack. All of these would increase the amount of time before the Loot Drop and the reseting of cool down timers in a Challenge Raid. This will increase the important of surviving until your next Healing Potion cool down. Which would increase the role of Defense options such as Potion 20% Magic Resist or Potion 20% Dodge.

Challenge Raids and Phases cannot replace Onslaught Raids and Phases since they tilt the balance from Shadow Walker (fast attacks)- War Mage(no Melee Attacks)- Justicar (slower attacks and Melee Attacks) to the other direction of Justicar(Chain Armor and Axe 1.4 Speed)- War Mage (Staff 1.3 Speed)- Shadow Walker (Caltrop, Poison Cloud and Corrosive Blades). However, just like Justicars are not totally useless in Onslaught Mode (especially since 1.6.1 tweaks), a Haste Monster Shadow Walker would not be totally useless in Challenge Mode.

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Jun 5, 2013 5:30 pm
I'd have to think about this more before I form an opinion, but something I really like is BJ's effort at creating a new raid style that can put more emphasis on other stats beside haste/Dmg/crit.

I've commented on this in several threads but as the game stands, health stat, resists, and do a lesser degree Dogde, are not important at all and can be ignored completely.

Though this may change in PvP (I'm holding no illusions at guessing how that might work), it would be nice to see a standard raid style that could utilize these stats over haste/Dmg/crit.

Though Venan if you do that I really really need more inventory slots!!!! ;)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed Jun 5, 2013 5:52 pm
Spartanmerc wrote:
If they were going to make a Challenge raid type of thing

Challenge is a reference to puzzle games. You could call it:
Action
Button
Counter
Defense
Economy
Final Count Down
Gesture
Hit
Intense

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed Jun 12, 2013 9:25 am
Subject
Faster Real World Speed, Less Energy per Raid, More Defense and More Damage Over Time
Mithrid wrote:There is no need to create a raid for justicars to excel at. As it stands high level justicars are unmatched in their ability to beat the other classes for RPP in regular raids.

Mithrid has a valid point. If unlimited Gold Shield spending, characters with Two Handed Weapons have an advantage due to higher Damage Per Attack (DPA) or Least Button Presses, which helps them get Bonus Rewards from Top 3. Justicars have two choices when it comes to Two Handed Weapons.

However, many players like Free Energy Raids (no Energy Potions used, no Gold Shields spent on energy). All three classes are balanced when in comes to Regular Style Free Energy Raids. The deciding factor is usually how long a character has been in a Raid (energy regen), what Sigils the character has (starting Free Energy) and if they are using Energy Regen Enchant on at least one item.

Onslaught Style is popular due to better rewards per 2 Free energy than Regular Style Raid and faster Real World Speed (more Combat Encounters per 5 minutes of energy regeneration, less waiting for characters to regenerate energy).
Gold Finish is popular due to faster Real World Speed and better rewards per 2 Free energy(more characters in the Raid means less time regenerating energy and more rewards per 2 Free energy spent).
Haste 75% is popular (less Monster Attacks and shorter Combat Encounters) which makes Defense and Damage Over Time less popular.

Challenge (or Action) Style is designed to deliver better rewards per 2 Free energy, faster Real World Speed, and make Defense and Damage Over Time more useful.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
Regular Style Phases and Raids are never going away. BoH is a casual game, Regular Style is very resilient to user choices. It is very difficult to create a character that cannot complete a Regular Style Combat Encounter/ Wave. The Regular Style of Raid favors GMs with the ability to find 40 people who will show up when the other 39 people do.

However, with a Bronze Finish Free Energy Raid, you must run Cursed Keep for 176 hours, to earn all Tier 12 items then another 1,088 hours to earn 40 Tier 4 Gems. Some players are happy running Knight Valor Raids for 1,000+ hours while other players would like some reward for skill in buying gear, choosing abilities and fighting combats.