Book of Heroes

Guild Loyalty- Decaying Loyalty

When Guild Loyalty was first announced, it was said to be meant as a prize for active guild-players and a way for the guild to see the most meritorious contributors in a clear and simple way - or, at least, so I understood ;)

From the guild's point of view, though, As a matter of fact, it has been such an instrument till all (or so) guildmates got to level5.. then all were equal again, and once gotten their bonuses many went back to farming portals or dungeons, helping on guild raids on spare time... After The last update ,Now, even a New recruit coming from another guild where she/he had GL5 would show Up already on GL4...

I think that to improve guild play and keep ppl doing raids (with all The well-known issues from 1.6.1..) with and for their home-guild, Guild Loyalty should work like Guild Power... It should decrease a little bit everyday, so players have to keep 'helping' The guild if they want to keep their bonuses..

What do you think?
I'd be ok with a decaying Guild Loyalty idea. It would have to be delayed by a day or two of non participation in guild raids though or people would be fighting an uphill battle to make it to GL5 at all, especially casual players.
Great idea to keep member active. Maybe can add decay rate in guild management so different guild can have different setting.
I would be fine with decay so long as it did not drop you down a level until the entire bar expired.

Aka, if you are at level 5, the entire 2,500 loyalty would have to decay before dropping you to level 4. If it drops you to level 4 at 2,499 that would just be annoying.

In addition, if this was implemented - the game would need a vacation mode.
Nabren wrote:I would be fine with decay so long as it did not drop you down a level until the entire bar expired.

Aka, if you are at level 5, the entire 2,500 loyalty would have to decay before dropping you to level 4. If it drops you to level 4 at 2,499 that would just be annoying.

In addition, if this was implemented - the game would need a vacation mode.
Well I wouldn't think it should drop you a level for one point off loyalty, but the vacation mode is interesting. Maybe have it up to an officer/GM to bypass it for your loyalty. This would give guild management the ability to encourage guild activity if you know going MIA for 2 weeks without notifying them would end up dropping you a couple of levels. Maybe they could make it drop you 10% each day after an initial 3 day absence. Or like someone else said, the GM/Officers can set a decay rate for the absent members. Maybe based on your Daily quest bar being reduced to Chaos status?

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Jun 5, 2013 5:35 pm
I think the idea is actually quite good. I would say though that dropping a level 5-4 after one week of no activity is too fast.

I would argue for 2 weeks no activity to go from L5 to L4 and so on.... Or something where a 2 week vacation wouldnt hurt you.
Nabren wrote:I would be fine with decay so long as it did not drop you down a level until the entire bar expired.


Aka, if you are at level 5, the entire 2,500 loyalty would have to decay before dropping you to level 4. If it drops you to level 4 at 2,499 that would just be annoying.

In addition, if this was implemented - the game would need a vacation mode.

I like these thoughts... Why waste so much time I ask?.. Simply "weed out" the guild if inactivity is an issue. Truth be told, I'm actually speechless about the idea of GL decay. It could go either way. Good or bad for the game? In short, I will leave no opinion!..
As a player who is forced to take frequent time of from the game, I would find decaying loyalty to be a significant problem. Unless the following:

Vacation mode can be toggled, and can remain on even if player is active. This is because I know I personally will forget to turn it on sometimes.

Guild Masters have no active control over decay, other than setting the guild decay rate. I would hate my GM to have arbitrary control over my loyalty rank that I fought for.

Loyalty can be re earned quickly if I am only on vacation for a short time. Double loyalty when returning after only a 1 week break would benefit, as I should not be penalised for real life taking priority.

I this was implemented properly, with silk gloves, it could be a tremendous benefit for guilds looking to monitor activity. However, as real life takes me out of BoH frequently, I would probably uninstall the game if I was constantly losing loyalty due to having a life.