Book of Heroes

Mages: Armor Penetration, Stacking Enchants · page 2

Possessed_Mithrid

Fri Nov 15, 2013 4:34 pm
Semimadscientist wrote:Ok, so a couple of us in a Mage heavy guild have bandied this about: for Mages you tend to use a 2H staff for a lot of PvE (except maybe Sarkisians) then switch to a 1H weapon for PvP. Ok, so I have the 1H Damage Bonus on my 1H weapon, and 2H Damage Bonus on my 2H staff. What Skill enchant to put on bracers and helmet? I have Armor Penetration on some now (did that before I landed the other two recipes). Do I switch (to which one?) or keep with AP? I don't do much PvP now (Mages still get the overall shaft) but I'm curious.
-Madsci

MadSci,
I've run the numbers on AP...and in theory they only make sense over 1H dmg IF your opponent is a fully magic resisted Justi..and even then the trade off is weak... AP may be of help against Ice Shield too but I have yet to read comments on it anywhere (go aheda BJ, I bet you have it somewhere in your archive. ;) )

Anyway...I am still curious myself as to whether or not I should give AP a serious try; it is possible that there are game mechanics with how it is applied under the hood making it much more useful...but I cant say.....I tested it out once and it didn't seem to help, but that was an unscientific anecdotal test...however I am now out of inventory spots to be building new pieces of gear for setup testing, without selling off some of my other high value high use pieces...

So I am hoping someone else will have noted a difference with full AP versus 1H in PvP.... :(
I believe ap does actually have big impact I have 10 percent ap. Against mages ice sheild I can c a near 65 percent reduction as aposeds 2 the 75 damage reducation thoe best way 2 b one 100 percent sure ivwould need there armor total.but as far as I could discern from rough estimate s of normal consitant damage vs ice sheild damge. I do belive that u can in thery do more damge over all. U incress ur att 1 percent of 1000 is 10 same with one percent ap reduced from a 1000 but at 30percent armor reducez ur att 2 700 from a 1000 but subtract ap and it changes 2 29 armor or 710 damage but if u did add 1010 for two hand one hand bounse u would only do 707 damge base off a 30 percent armor reduction.but cause armor p is only .8 it actually comes out 2 708 so onepoint more damage ap does over one handor two hand at same levels this just a base theory crunching numbers cause I canonly assume it affects base armor it self and dont know if it affects damge mitageiton or other res any one of theose factor s could change it for better or worse me personally I use it but all so use onehanded bounses in a combo. Though I could b wrong....

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Nov 21, 2013 1:06 pm
Subject
1H & 2H Enchants
Semimadscientist wrote:
What Skill enchant to put on bracers and helmet? I have Armor Penetration on some now (did that before I landed the other two recipes). Do I switch (to which one?) or keep with AP? I don't do much PvP now (Mages still get the overall shaft) but I'm curious.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
Enchant Rank 3 is 50% as effective as Rank 6 but only costs 9% of the Enchant Materials.

Until we see what Venan does with Enchants in v2.0, I would get a set of Rank 3 1H Damage and a set of Rank 3 2H Damage for a War Mage or a Justicar. Which only costs you 18% of the Enchant Materials for a set of Rank 6 for either 1H or 2H.

You do not even need Spec 2, as swapping 3 items everytime you enter PvP, or the Shattered Plane, is not that much of a burden.

Extensive testing, by several Forum members, has shown that AP is not worth it in PvE. I would get rid of the AP. CJ on the other hand has AP 12.8% and Spirit 12%. Her Smite 3 is insane vs Lord of Blades.