Book of Heroes

Mega Topic: Low RPP Mercs/ Mercs Trapped in Raids · page 4

How come I can't find a danged like button for this post?!?!

Like like like like like!!!!
Hello all, I've never posted on the forums before, but I do lurk sometimes lol.
Lately there has been a few people on global chat complaining* of mercenaries who join the raid, but only hit one or two times for the entirety of the raid. This causes annoyance and blocks a spot for someone who may have wanted to actually help out the hosting guild's raid.
I am proposing a Mercenary Blacklist- a list that the GM (Or Officers) can ban people from merc'ing in their guild's raids. It would only ban that person from that guild's raids, and not other guilds. If relations change with the player, the GM/Officers can pardon the player off of the list, and they can continue raiding with the guild.
I feel like this work better then an automatic raid kick based on RPP or activity because everyone has things to do other then BoH (sometimes. :P)

* I don't mean complaining in a negative way, I just couldn't find a better haha.

Didn't realize it was this long, sorry if it's a book haha.
Mocah wrote:
I feel like this work better then an automatic raid kick based on RPP or activity because everyone has things to do other then BoH (sometimes. :P)

Other things to do? I don't understand....?:p

Seriously, I'd like to see belt and braces.
1. Blacklist by player.
2. Auto-boot after 5 mins if RPP stays at <=100*
3. Manual boot option by GM / Officers.

The reason I say by player is that if a player skunks with one toon, he's probably gonna skunk with another if you block that one and you can end up chasing your tail, esp at low-mid range raids where new toons can be created and reach the required might for the raid by the skunking player quite easily. The block would not just be by player name, but linked to the player's primary ID record, so if they change their name, the block stays. It's up to the GM and officers to track their blocked list and remember why a given player is banned, if they change their name, I'm sure most of our GMs can figure it out.

The autoboot I like. Fine, everyone can suffer interruptions and/or suddenly not be available to play for a period. But in doing so, they're taking up a slot that could be used by someone who is available, and penalising the hosting guild. It's not their fault that your dog decided to eat your table at the point you pressed Enter.

Giving the hosting GM /officers the power to boot would be welcome. I'm not currently aware of any method by which a hosting guild can silence a player who joins as a merc and proceeds to be... "unsavoury", esp in younger guilds.

Whether auto or manually booted, a booted merc should not gain any rewards from the raid. It would also be sensible to restore any hits they have made. So if a toons joins, makes 2 hits and goes inactive in Phase 1, then is booted in phase 4, those 2 hits should be added to the phase 4 baddie so that the "rolling merc slot" tactic couldn't be used - ie have a slot where a succession of toons join, make a few hits, then get booted to make room for the next.

* Boot trigger point could be set by the guild, or be predetermined by raid. It would have to be visible to mercs before entry - no merc would want to see a 5kRPP req on a raid they join in phase 4 AFTER joining!
Setting a low trigger point increases the risk of being skunked and/or having multiple low-scoring mercs. Setting a high trigger point increases the risk of suddenly losing a bunch of hits during the raid as players get booted for not having reached that point, and putting mercs off joining - that could be another strategic decision for the guild to make as part of the raid.
Numbers 1 and 2 I like. I see what could be a challenge with 3 though (Although I doubt most people would do this).
Say a merc'ing toon has one of the top RPP in the raid. If GM's or Officers have the option to manually kick mercs out of the raid, they could 'free up RPP', so that actual guild mates could gain RPP or become 1st/2nd3rd place.*
*While I don't think most people would do that, it is a possibility

Right now, I can't think of a replacement for GM/Officer manual kicks though. I agree with you that rude attitudes and language shouldn't be in a guild chat that doesn't allow it, so perhaps the ban/blacklist button should silence people as well as ban?
(I had an idea right as I gave up thinking haha)

For example, a merc is top RPP, but is a complete jerk on your guild's chat. You can blacklist his ID* from any raids you have After the raid you're currently in. This would silence him for the remainder of the raid, then ban him from raiding with you after the current raid is completed. This would stop guilds from 'Freeing up RPP' from innocent mercs. Sure, the guild could ban the innocent guy from raiding with them after that for I don't know what reason, but he's not dumping his energy in vain. The rude merc would be the same, he keeps his reward but cannot raid with the guild while he's on the blacklist.

*I'm sorry, I meant the entire ID from the beginning. No matter the toon, it's still the same person and his attitude.

That was just me brainstorming kind of fast. If anyone has anymore ideas, throw them here!
So finally this subject comes up.

Guilds should definitely have the ability to blacklist and kick mercs from raid. But kicking from raid makes a lot of problems, the problems u guys have talked about already.
So to avoid that I am thinking of a freeze-function: if merc is somehow ignoring guilds rules or being a jerk, GM/off can freeze the merc, making him paralyzed. When paralyzed the player cant do anything in raid and cant get in to the guildchat. The player will keep his rpp and position in raid, and will also get the rewards from it.

So blacklist AND a freeze function please oh almighty Venan!
I'd be ok if only gm cld boot mercs under a certain rpp. That way if there's a question, everyone knows the boot came directly from the gm. Banning a player shld def be allowed.

Or, an idea from Ninjavitis, mercing shld automatically cost 12 e...
This is our concern:

We are a guild with rules against burning epots and gs, cuz we like to raid in a fair environment, tie at the end of raids and dislikes the idea with spending reAl money on a game thats supposed to be free.
Now what happens when 15 raiders are sharing no1 pos in raid? Merc-jerk svallows pots and snitches all valor from 15 raiders, and dork-merc is leaching in the bottom.

Venan HAVE to give hosting guilds more power in raids. Without the guilds it wouldnt be any mercs, but without mercs there would still be guilds.

Im talking for approx 300 players inside the Red Star Alliance btw.

Cheers!
//Nek
Start a thread with the names of the skunk mercs. That way players can give them hell when they see them. :)
Kuroi_Kishi_Hime_Kazehana wrote:Yeah I Want Blacklist KRONAZ
A Merc Blacklist in an amazing idea!!!


I second this. He jumps in on our guild a lot and its rare when he breaks into the 300 RPP range!