If you want a Casual Guild, you will lose players. Some players will Merc a lot and move on to higher Guilds. Some players will grow bored. Some players will have life changes. If you cannot deal with players leaving your Guild, do not start a Casual Guild.
I understand the perspective here, but as a member of a casual guild I don't fully agree with it. Guild chat is definitely a component of it, if comparing to a strict raiding schedule, but it's not a comprehensive answer.
As a casual guild, I can pretty much tell the members that join that will depart quickly. They never say anything, and stay in the background when on. Chances are that most will move on within a couple of weeks. What keeps the core though is the fact that we all have other lives. No one in my guild can devote the time needed to be a solid member of a guild like HJ (and I say that with all respect, you guys run an amazing guild). What we do want is a guild that will allow us to still grow as fast as we are able, and to DWR's point, bring a social aspect in. The social aspect remains game related, helping each other grow, finding times to raid when we can get the people we need, etc. So will we ever be at the top rankings? No. Are we building a stable group of people who can't commit to a raid heavy guild? Yes. My attrition I would bet is quite similar to a raid heavy guild, but for different reasons.
As to other thoughts around being a good GM, I agree with most of the posts here. Adaptability is key. I think the biggest strengths however are identifying the vision for your guild and surrounding yourself with people that share that vision.
I think there are three types of guilds which can be successful.
- Own the rankings
- Pure Social (The Girl Genius Online reference in previous post)
- Want to grow as much as I can, but cannot commit to the demands of a guild in group 1.
As to the second, our GM has identified the vision. We are a group 3 guild, and once we recognized that, we started attracting a lot of people that fit that mentality. They love the game, they want to grow themselves, but they want to be part of something larger, the guild. The people that have found us are for the most part remarkable. The officers all share the GM's vision, and our number 1 rule is that if you want to be part of us, you have to have fun. If the game becomes work, then we are failing.