Book of Heroes

So you wanna be a GM?

What does it take to be a good Guild Master? If you have ever held the reigns of a guild, please weigh in with your opinion.

What traits does a good GM have to have in order to build and keep a thriving guild: patience, creativity, networking ease, obstinacy, strict authoritarian control, the gift of gab, an obsession with time zones and scheduling, an undying need for power, an unflagging need for pain? How much of a commitment is it in terms of time and emotional energy?

What advice would you give the would-be GM with a few GS burning a hole in his/her pocket?
Don't do it. :D

There is no one path. If you look at four of the top guilds (HJ, NBW, KOTOR, and Kingdom), you will find completely different GM strategies. Heck, at KOTOR, the GM does relatively little and the officers make most of the decisions - Matty is more of a tie breaker than anything.
I agree that there are many different styles if being a GM. I will speak from my perspective. That perspective includes the fact that I don't do this alone and can't do it alone. I have an outstanding partner in Queen Amy. It truly takes both of us to lead Helmsmen's Jacuzzi. We also have several fine officers who are crucial.

Perhaps the most important attribute of a successful GM is adaptability. The game keeps changing and interest in the game ebbs and flows. Venan keeps announcing events and updates with very little advance notice. Server problems (while not nearly as bad as they once were) are as much a fact of life in this game as bad calls from the refs are in sports. A successful GM must be able to change and adapt to deal with it, an must frequently do so quickly, on the fly.

The next attribute is dedication. Amy and I to some extent are playing a different game from most other players. The object of our game is to build and maintain and guild that will attract excellent players who will want to come back day after day to spend time with us, and where mercs will enjoy coming and spending their energy when we make that available. We have a format that works for us, but it takes a great deal of time from us both.

Next I would list friendliness and helpfulness. We genuinely like the people who raid with us, which is a really good thing because we spend a lot of time together. We are frequently players' first choice for advice on problems or questions about the game, and that has grown in several situations to giving counsel and encouragement about real life.

Finally, I should mention the importance of a thick skin. This is a game and one should not be surprised that players are competitive, sometimes overly so. I once had one GM spend 6 hours insulting me and talking smack. Yesterday I, almost unbelievably, had people blaming me for the server crash. There are irresponsible whiners and haters galore willing to spread untruths and half truths. And you cannot let it get to you. Go about your business. Take care of your people. Have fun. And let them say what they will.

And if you still want the job, power to you. Good luck. I have found it very rewarding. I enjoy the game Amy and I are playing, as well as the game our members play.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Jun 24, 2013 12:48 pm
If you want a Casual Guild, you will lose players. Some players will Merc a lot and move on to higher Guilds. Some players will grow bored. Some players will have life changes. If you cannot deal with players leaving your Guild, do not start a Casual Guild.

What holds a Casual Guild together? Guild Chat. If you like Girl Genius http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/ then start a Girl Genius Guild. If you play BoH with your co-workers, start a Company Guild. If you build BBQs and Smokers each weekend, start a BBQ Guild to keep you company while you smoke a pork loin. Something besides BoH has to hold a Casual Guild together during 3 hour Raids.

Trick: If you like running a Casual Guild, you can boot alternate characters, as long as you remind them to rejoin your Guild to keep their Guild Loyalty. This allows players to participate in weekends they have free, but still have room for other people's alternates when players are busy.
If you want a Casual Guild, you will lose players. Some players will Merc a lot and move on to higher Guilds. Some players will grow bored. Some players will have life changes. If you cannot deal with players leaving your Guild, do not start a Casual Guild.

I understand the perspective here, but as a member of a casual guild I don't fully agree with it. Guild chat is definitely a component of it, if comparing to a strict raiding schedule, but it's not a comprehensive answer.

As a casual guild, I can pretty much tell the members that join that will depart quickly. They never say anything, and stay in the background when on. Chances are that most will move on within a couple of weeks. What keeps the core though is the fact that we all have other lives. No one in my guild can devote the time needed to be a solid member of a guild like HJ (and I say that with all respect, you guys run an amazing guild). What we do want is a guild that will allow us to still grow as fast as we are able, and to DWR's point, bring a social aspect in. The social aspect remains game related, helping each other grow, finding times to raid when we can get the people we need, etc. So will we ever be at the top rankings? No. Are we building a stable group of people who can't commit to a raid heavy guild? Yes. My attrition I would bet is quite similar to a raid heavy guild, but for different reasons.

As to other thoughts around being a good GM, I agree with most of the posts here. Adaptability is key. I think the biggest strengths however are identifying the vision for your guild and surrounding yourself with people that share that vision.

I think there are three types of guilds which can be successful.

- Own the rankings
- Pure Social (The Girl Genius Online reference in previous post)
- Want to grow as much as I can, but cannot commit to the demands of a guild in group 1.

As to the second, our GM has identified the vision. We are a group 3 guild, and once we recognized that, we started attracting a lot of people that fit that mentality. They love the game, they want to grow themselves, but they want to be part of something larger, the guild. The people that have found us are for the most part remarkable. The officers all share the GM's vision, and our number 1 rule is that if you want to be part of us, you have to have fun. If the game becomes work, then we are failing.
Denrael wrote: My attrition I would bet is quite similar to a raid heavy guild, but for different reasons.

All guilds have attrition. In fact, if you check the Might Leaderboard, 3 of the top 10 players have quit playing completely.
Denrael wrote:And that is how I plan to get on the leader board; out wait everybody

That was my strategy. :D ....and then an influx of new cash players ruined that.... :cry:
Thanks for the thoughtful and well-considered responses. I really appreciate them. I agree with much of what was shared, based on what I've seen.

Denrael's comment about vision was striking to me, but made a lot of sense when I thought about it. The successful guilds in which I have taken part have had a GM that communicated a unifying vision: we grow fast and all together, we love to riff off one another's hilarious antics, or we enjoy sharing bits of our lives with a safe group of friends. The GM either broadcast the vision regularly, whispered it individually, or just plain exemplified it in a way that was hard to miss.

Again, thanks for the comments, and I welcome more opinions.