I'm playing a Shadow Walker right now. I don't seem to recall that the Justicar has a similar problem, and I've never played a Mage enough to be able to talk about it, but this still should get looked into.
The problem is that with 3 skill points in the respective abilities, the Shadow Walker can self-buff himself with bonuses of +50% Dodge Chance, +50% Crit Chance and +20% Haste.
However, all these three abilities are hard effect capped at 50%. Haste has some slight benefit for being above the cap, as I've explained in another thread (thanks to the player who made that observation and relayed it to the rest of us in ingame chat!), but for Dodge Chance and Crit Chance, the self-buffs makes the pre-buff stats of the character completely irrelevant.
I gain no benefit from Hero Token trainig, nor from gem bonuses, to my Dodge Chance, if I routinely use the +50% Dodge Chance self-buff. And I do use it routinely. That's why I put 3 points into it. Furthermore it lasts almost long enough to give full coverage throughout a fight against an equivalent-level triple-mob, so I really have extremely little benefit from Dodge gems, nor from Dodge training.
Same goes for Crit Chance gems and training. The self-buff adds +50%, so that it makes no difference if my pre-buff value was 5% or 12%. I hit the cap hard, at 50%, and feel stupid for having wasted silver on gems, and wasted Hero Tokens on training.
Haste has a bit of the same problem, in that t's fairly doable to reach a non-buffed Haste of 30%, on top of which goes the +20% self-buff ability, which hits the cap.
I suggest that for Dodge Chance and Crit Chance, the cap be raised very slightly, to perhaps 62.5%. That way, pre-buff values are not ignored, unless they are very high (anything above 12.5% native qualifying as "very high").
There are other, more complex solutions to this, but they reduce the transparency of the game mechanics, and that is already a problem in several places in BoH, and it is not good to reduce transparency further.
For Haste I don't think a raised cap is good at all. I think the only solution is to accept the necessity of increasing the complexity of the game mechanics, so that there is a diminishing returns effect for Haste. Possibly the problem can be solved by making the self-buff effect multiplicative instead of additive, so that instead of adding 20% to the Haste percentage, the self-buff multiplies the Haste percentage by 1.35 or 1.4 (1.2 for the first level of skill, 1.3 for he 2nd, 1.4 for the 3rd). That way, a 3 point self-buff improves a Haste of 30% to 42%.
The only alternative is to tell Shadow Walker players that if the focus much on Haste (as I have), then they should pay for a re-spec and not put any points into the Haste-self-buffing skill. And I am considering doing that.
The problem is that with 3 skill points in the respective abilities, the Shadow Walker can self-buff himself with bonuses of +50% Dodge Chance, +50% Crit Chance and +20% Haste.
However, all these three abilities are hard effect capped at 50%. Haste has some slight benefit for being above the cap, as I've explained in another thread (thanks to the player who made that observation and relayed it to the rest of us in ingame chat!), but for Dodge Chance and Crit Chance, the self-buffs makes the pre-buff stats of the character completely irrelevant.
I gain no benefit from Hero Token trainig, nor from gem bonuses, to my Dodge Chance, if I routinely use the +50% Dodge Chance self-buff. And I do use it routinely. That's why I put 3 points into it. Furthermore it lasts almost long enough to give full coverage throughout a fight against an equivalent-level triple-mob, so I really have extremely little benefit from Dodge gems, nor from Dodge training.
Same goes for Crit Chance gems and training. The self-buff adds +50%, so that it makes no difference if my pre-buff value was 5% or 12%. I hit the cap hard, at 50%, and feel stupid for having wasted silver on gems, and wasted Hero Tokens on training.
Haste has a bit of the same problem, in that t's fairly doable to reach a non-buffed Haste of 30%, on top of which goes the +20% self-buff ability, which hits the cap.
I suggest that for Dodge Chance and Crit Chance, the cap be raised very slightly, to perhaps 62.5%. That way, pre-buff values are not ignored, unless they are very high (anything above 12.5% native qualifying as "very high").
There are other, more complex solutions to this, but they reduce the transparency of the game mechanics, and that is already a problem in several places in BoH, and it is not good to reduce transparency further.
For Haste I don't think a raised cap is good at all. I think the only solution is to accept the necessity of increasing the complexity of the game mechanics, so that there is a diminishing returns effect for Haste. Possibly the problem can be solved by making the self-buff effect multiplicative instead of additive, so that instead of adding 20% to the Haste percentage, the self-buff multiplies the Haste percentage by 1.35 or 1.4 (1.2 for the first level of skill, 1.3 for he 2nd, 1.4 for the 3rd). That way, a 3 point self-buff improves a Haste of 30% to 42%.
The only alternative is to tell Shadow Walker players that if the focus much on Haste (as I have), then they should pay for a re-spec and not put any points into the Haste-self-buffing skill. And I am considering doing that.