Book of Heroes

Inadequate game-mechanical transparency

Book of Heroes suffers from insufficiently transparent game mechanics in several areas:

1. Gems don't have the same effect in all items. Some item types, such as Chest Armour, Rings, Amulets and 2-Handed weapons, have a x4 gem effect multiplier. Some have a x3 gem effect multiplier. Most have a x2 multiplier.

Why isn't this clearly visible in the in-game interface?

I know I can figure out which item type has which multiplier if I slot gems in and out and do the arithmetic, but it's just stupid that I have to perform that kind of work. The game ought to tell it to me directly, via the interface.

2. It is not at all clear which of the various abilities available to the classes are Melee-based, benefitting from a trained or gem-boosted Melee stat, and which one are Spell-based, benefitting instead from a trained or gem-boosted Spell stat.

Presumably most of the Justicar's abilities are Melee-based. But I'd be greatly surprised if it is all of them. Likewise, it seems safe to assume that much more than half the abilities of the Mage are Spell-based. But which ones?

And currently I'm playing a Shadow Walker. My hunch is that roughly half of the abilities I can use or learn are Spell-based and the other half Melee-based, but which ones? I haven't got a clue.

I could perform tedious and repetetive in-game work to figure this out, painstakingly taking notes with a pencil and paper, but it's silly that I have to do it. The game interface should tell me, if nothing else then on the Ability Training screen in Daedalus house.

3. I never really use Ruines, the only exception being when my previous character (Justicar) fought the ice dragon Vallus (grinding for silver and drops, since I had already slain him much more than 5 times to get the Achie - I mean the Feat), where I'd use a Fire Rune against him, since presumably an Ice Dragon is not resistant to fire.

But my reluctance to use these elementally-flavoured Runes is that I'm not at all sure which foes they are useful against. Presumably they are useful against many foes, but with a subset of foes being resistant towards one or two specfic elements, taking reduced damage from these. How can I know this? Those few times I've used Runes, the game interface has never given me any clear feedback to indicate that one or more targets took reduced damage or suffered a limited rather than full debuff effect.

Keeping the game mechanics secret does not make the game better. It makes the game worse. It discourages thoughtful players from using all the options available to them.

I'd really appreciate it if Venan took steps towards increasing the level of game mechanical transparency.
This is just great what you said. I completely agree with those things you wrote, there are still other things which should/could be changed. Hopefully Venan will think about those.
I would say you use whichever rune benefits your game plan. I use runes rather frequently. Currently, I use the Arcane damage rune that applies an armor debuff (though I would REALLY like to know how much of one or the math behind it) that does increase my melee damage since I am not poison based. My fire mage uses the fire one right after resolving Fire Fracture for added aoe because Mage aoe has been beaten with the nerf bat. My rogu^H^H^H^Hshadow walker also uses the ice rune from time to time if I get a good smoke bomb, post caltrops (I've had bosses need 4 seconds+ to get an ability off that just gets stunned out of anyways).

That said, I would LOVE to see the scaling information on my abilities so I know which stats I want to play with. Venan could stand to observe a mistake the Blizzard made early with World of Warcraft. If there's dirty laundry in the equations, eventually your players will reverse engineer them. Might as well make sure it's all straight and put the data out for public domain. For example, the current scaling for Toxic Strike is this:

TS% (MH roll + OH roll + MAG). How do I know this? Well, lets put in the numbers.

TS% = 120%
MH roll = 168-186
OH roll = 67-74
MAG = 67

1.2 (168 + 67 + 67) = 362.4
1.2 (186 +74 + 67) = 392.4

So, we have a projected damage range of 362-392 after rounding down. When I look at the in combat tool tip.... Dun dun dun, 362-392.

Toxic Strike is not very clear in regards to it's tooltip however and the implied statement is that it scales only off of your MH. "A Nature attack that coats your weapon in poison, dealing 120% weapon damage and an additional 30%..." Note the lack of plurality. Oh, what a difference "weapon" vs "weapons" makes.

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu May 31, 2012 10:28 pm
You found us out! One of the biggest reasons why some of those short tooltips are a little confusing is because we only have room for 2 lines of text. The actual abilities menu in the character management screen has a more detailed description of the abilities. Although we probably can still do better in providing the necessary information. We will revisit all of these things again once we have more of the higher priority issues out of the way.