Book of Heroes

Official PvP Beta Feedback Thread- ARCHIVED · page 23

No. There isn't much excuse. There are many other games with balanced pvp. The problem is, Venan has introduced an equipment system that makes it very difficult to balance for. There are no level requirements on gems. Gear comes with no inherent bonuses, and in some cases, no level requirements. Someone with more real world money, then, can purchase enough gold and silver to outfit their character the best for their given level. When real world money can give you significant advantages over poorer players, then something is very, very wrong.

A game like WoW, has level requirements on gear and enchants and socketing/gems. And pvp is broken up by level, so you never face someone too much higher than you. So, there is a lot of even matchmaking that goes on, even on lower levels. Talents themselves are much less important in a fight; good skill can easily override talent choices.

What Venan needs to do:

#1. Significantly depower gems. At least cut the potential in half. This helps tone down the gem factor in determining a fight. Gems should be a slight power boost, to tailor your character.

#2. Add level requirements to gems and all the other gear. Everything. Even enchants.

#3. Introduce different gear that has inherent bonuses, and that you can only get via drops. This helps to cut out someone borrowing daddy's credit card to purchase the good stuff.

#4. Allow characters to learn their active skills naturally as they level. Sure, you can use talents to enhance them, but at least give them level 1 of all active abilities (ie, Incinerate, Brutal Strike, Piercing Strike).

#5. Depower the horribly overpowered talents(Riposte, Heroic Will, etc.), and treat them like gems: gives slight bonuses, but nothing major. Snap Cast and Neurotoxin are good examples

These last two changes help mitigate builds, and let pvp be determined mainly by skill. That is Venan's biggest pvp problem: characters are inherently vastly uneven, which turns most pvp contests into one-sided fights. I eventually grew tired of WoW for other reasons, but one of the biggest things they did right, was make pvp largely even. With the exception of early paladin and shaman (which they left weak because they were afraid to give exclusive advantages to Horde or the Alliance), the classes and level brackets were fairly well-balanced.

The strength of your character should largely be determined by the time you invest in the game... not on how much gold you can buy. This will also boost BoH's playerbase, because every game that has introduced the ability to buy your way to the best stuff, has inevitably driven away the good players. And they also attract the alternate gold sellers, diverting cash into a third party's account rather than Venan's. Nearly every game like this has become a ghost town of gold farmers/sellers, and very few actual players. Even Farmville, which was largely popular, has been bleeding most of it's playerbase for awhile now. There is an inverse relationship between how much they offered to buy with real world cash, and the size of their playerbase.

Might, while an interesting and unique way to try and gauge a player's battle potential, is inherently unusable due to the wide disparity between gems, talents, abilities, and enchants. Not all bonuses are created equal, but they are scored equally. This allows people to game the system, ending up with a low might score, but superior battle power. Witness the naked fighters who destroy lower might players.

Venan tried to set up an interesting and different system, and I do give them respect for that. But there are reasons that RPG systems have evolved to the point they are at. Ever since pen & paper D&D, there are has emerged a consensus about how best to bring about balance, and it has been honed over the years. It's something you ignore at your peril.
Saint_Kai wrote:No. There isn't much excuse. There are many other games with balanced pvp. The problem is, Venan has introduced an equipment system that makes it very difficult to balance for. There are no level requirements on gems. Gear comes with no inherent bonuses, and in some cases, no level requirements. Someone with more real world money, then, can purchase enough gold and silver to outfit their character the best for their given level. When real world money can give you significant advantages over poorer players, then something is very, very wrong.

A game like WoW, has level requirements on gear and enchants and socketing/gems. And pvp is broken up by level, so you never face someone too much higher than you. So, there is a lot of even matchmaking that goes on, even on lower levels. Talents themselves are much less important in a fight; good skill can easily override talent choices.

What Venan needs to do:

#1. Significantly depower gems. At least cut the potential in half. This helps tone down the gem factor in determining a fight. Gems should be a slight power boost, to tailor your character.

#2. Add level requirements to gems and all the other gear. Everything. Even enchants.

#3. Introduce different gear that has inherent bonuses, and that you can only get via drops. This helps to cut out someone borrowing daddy's credit card to purchase the good stuff.

#4. Allow characters to learn their active skills naturally as they level. Sure, you can use talents to enhance them, but at least give them level 1 of all active abilities (ie, Incinerate, Brutal Strike, Piercing Strike).

#5. Depower the horribly overpowered talents(Riposte, Heroic Will, etc.), and treat them like gems: gives slight bonuses, but nothing major. Snap Cast and Neurotoxin are good examples

These last two changes help mitigate builds, and let pvp be determined mainly by skill. That is Venan's biggest pvp problem: characters are inherently vastly uneven, which turns most pvp contests into one-sided fights. I eventually grew tired of WoW for other reasons, but one of the biggest things they did right, was make pvp largely even. With the exception of early paladin and shaman (which they left weak because they were afraid to give exclusive advantages to Horde or the Alliance), the classes and level brackets were fairly well-balanced.

The strength of your character should largely be determined by the time you invest in the game... not on how much gold you can buy. This will also boost BoH's playerbase, because every game that has introduced the ability to buy your way to the best stuff, has inevitably driven away the good players. And they also attract the alternate gold sellers, diverting cash into a third party's account rather than Venan's. Nearly every game like this has become a ghost town of gold farmers/sellers, and very few actual players. Even Farmville, which was largely popular, has been bleeding most of it's playerbase for awhile now. There is an inverse relationship between how much they offered to buy with real world cash, and the size of their playerbase.

Might, while an interesting and unique way to try and gauge a player's battle potential, is inherently unusable due to the wide disparity between gems, talents, abilities, and enchants. Not all bonuses are created equal, but they are scored equally. This allows people to game the system, ending up with a low might score, but superior battle power. Witness the naked fighters who destroy lower might players.

Venan tried to set up an interesting and different system, and I do give them respect for that. But there are reasons that RPG systems have evolved to the point they are at. Ever since pen & paper D&D, there are has emerged a consensus about how best to bring about balance, and it has been honed over the years. It's something you ignore at your peril.


I think the inherent disconnect with this and the problem at hand is that the solutions you provide impact the game in a way that would greatly diminish the pve aspects - which were what the game was built for and on. I see PVP beta as nothing more than a mini-game with some aesthetic rewards in this game. Atleast in its' current state. I don't think comparing BoH to WoW is fair seeing as WoW matchmaking works for the reason I mentioned in my last post - the sheer number of players. How do you solve a matchmaking issue in BoH when there just isn't enough players of your might/level pvping at that moment? It isn't a poor formula or poor matchmaking parameters - its lack of a huge pool or players to draw upon - or so it seems.

I'm glad you are taking the time to make suggestions Kai, so forgive me in advance if I respectfully disagree with some of them :p

But lets see... #1 - depowering gems. I feel like with diminishing returns, gems have very little purpose in pvp past a certain point. Health is the only gem that I feel really unbalances pvp, or rather the lack of a diminishing return on health really wrecks havoc. But outside health, gems are no more than a slightly boost. For example, at maxed magic ht, i have a 878 weapon damage +660 magic boost for a total of 1538 damage. If I add 4 T5 magic gems in the best slots of my equip (2 karnak ring, 2 chest), my damage boost increases to 878+ 845 magic boost for a total of ~12% increase to my magic damage. At the cost of 12k CV to get those 4 gems, I'd say that's a reasonable boost. Any less, and it's not even worth upgrading from T4 to T5... I think for all that is said, the gem/equip system is very unique and works well.

#2 - Adding level reqs to gems and gear. Here, I find myself agreeing with you, but I feel like its already been done. Every piece of equipment buyable with silver has a level limit. The only way to get level-less equipment is through raiding. Even equipment buyable with gold shields has a level limit. Likewise with gems. T5 gems are only purchasable through valor or twice a week at random from the black market. Enchants... don't need a level limit. Getting them is hard enough. Anyone who does get one, should be able to use it.

#3 - Introducing different gear with inherent bonuses - here, I completely agree. Definitely something I really enjoyed back in v1 that was replaced by the gem/equip system. Hopefully, something similar can come back in another form.

#4 - This i completely disagree. Allowing every character to have all the abilities as the level will only make pvp even more similar than it already is. If everyone has the same build, where's the strategy? Unless ability points enhance skills exponentially, it won't make a significant difference if everyone automatically gains everything as they level. The real solution I think, should be to add a fourth and fifth tier of support/active abilities to balance out the classes. With only 16 abilites, 2 builds (fire/ice, melee/poison) per class, and 30 points to invest, there's very limited variety at level 30.

#5 - Maybe this is my bias as a Shadow Walker coming out, but I honestly don't think Riposte and Heroic Will are overpowered. For the most part, despite all the complaints, SWers and Justis both perform very well in high might pvp. Even wm's that are specced and know what they're doing only do slightly worse vs. a SW. That said, I think snapcast could use a bit of a boost, as well as WMs in general, but the balance isn't as skewed as people seem to think it is. Unfortunately, the vast majority of those that post on the pvp forums are those that are 1) not specced for pvp, use a pve build, and get demolished (and yes, this could be due to the cost of the second spec - but however outrageous the cost seems, I don't see how its any different than getting the sigils. No one ever complained this much about the 180 gs sigil... but we all saved up for it one way or another) or 2) those whose might are too low to be pvping properly in the first place. The real issue might be that pvp opens up at such a low level, but much like the Karnak raid, isn't properly survivable until a much higher might.


I know you also brought up the idea of naked pvping - I'm all for a fix for that. Though how that would happen - I'm not completely sure.

;)
I think pvp is the most ridiculous thing ever introduced im completelydone playing in the matches ill go back to my quests now

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Sep 9, 2013 1:42 am
Just a couple comments to your post:
Saint_Kai wrote:No. There isn't much excuse. There are many other games with balanced pvp. The problem is, Venan has introduced an equipment system that makes it very difficult to balance for. There are no level requirements on gems. Gear comes with no inherent bonuses, and in some cases, no level requirements. Someone with more real world money, then, can purchase enough gold and silver to outfit their character the best for their given level. When real world money can give you significant advantages over poorer players, then something is very, very wrong.

I think what your missing here Kai is that BoH started out as a PvE, single player long before it even had raids. This game was never initially intended as a pvp type game as far as I can tell...rather the developers have catered to the playing community base, by first adding social raids and then expanding from there. They have a done an excellent job turning what was originally a single player game into a PvP game per the player communities demands. What your failing to give Venan credit for is the fact that they do strongly catered to their player community, more so than other game developers. In this regard I feel your criticism is unjustified. Ill get to your point about money later...
Saint_Kai wrote:
A game like WoW, has level requirements on gear and enchants and socketing/gems. And pvp is broken up by level, so you never face someone too much higher than you. So, there is a lot of even matchmaking that goes on, even on lower levels. Talents themselves are much less important in a fight; good skill can easily override talent choices.

I don't think you have notice but all pieces of gear and gems have inherent level requirements...besides the obvious level requirements attached to armor/gear, it is built into the way you can earn gems and higher tier gear as well...you have to be certain levels to open up the quests that allow you the opportunity to earn the different valor, and ergo the different shards and gems. So yes, just like WoW...all gear and gems have level requirements.

As far as talents go, that is half the strategy, being able to pick and choose the talents that give the best performance...it is what is highly discussed on both this forum as well as in-game chat. This pushes the strategy to much more of a thinking mans game then just the practiced button mashing of wow. I think for you to say talents shouldn't matter implies that you want a simpler game to play.

Incidentally, half the skill in BoH PvP is not only choosing the right talents but also knowing very well how to play with them in game as well as picking up quickly what talents your opponent has chosen and how to counteract them.
Saint_Kai wrote:
What Venan needs to do:

#1. Significantly depower gems. At least cut the potential in half. This helps tone down the gem factor in determining a fight. Gems should be a slight power boost, to tailor your character.

#2. Add level requirements to gems and all the other gear. Everything. Even enchants.

#3. Introduce different gear that has inherent bonuses, and that you can only get via drops. This helps to cut out someone borrowing daddy's credit card to purchase the good stuff.

#4. Allow characters to learn their active skills naturally as they level. Sure, you can use talents to enhance them, but at least give them level 1 of all active abilities (ie, Incinerate, Brutal Strike, Piercing Strike).

#5. Depower the horribly overpowered talents(Riposte, Heroic Will, etc.), and treat them like gems: gives slight bonuses, but nothing major. Snap Cast and Neurotoxin are good examples

1: Gems do not make a huge different from tier to tier to tier...yes there is between T3 and T5 but not between T2 and T3 or T4 and T5...gem improvements are very incremental and never monumental...the real skill and strategy is in choosing the right gems...to remove this again would make the game much more boring....what you perceive as overpowered gems in my mind is actually a bad gem selection against a good selection for PvP.

2: I already pointed out that this is currently the case.

3: So lets discuss daddy credit card... contrary to popular belief you really can't buy your way to the top in BoH...you can only buy yourself to Tier11 gear and T4 gems, but you want T12,T13 or T14 gear and T5 gems and enchants, you have to earn it...end of story...and playing up to and earning T10 gear...is easy enough that their is no point buying T11 gear anyway... buying T4 germs, yes that may make it easier, but its not a huge gap between GS spenders and non-spenders. The ONLY thing where spending GS helps, is that you can buy E/E-pots...this however doesn't give you an easy way to earn gear or gems, it just allows you to do it faster...however you still have to earn JUST as much RPP/valor/essence in raids as the non-GS spenders which means just as much button mashing...spending GS on E doesn't reduce at all the work load required to earn top gear..it just makes it easier to do it faster then normal E regen.
So understand, GS spenders have no inherent advantages other than not needing to wait for E to regen for raids as well as the 100GS spec for PvP (which is a bit of a screw-up on Venans part in my opinion...but I explained that elsewhere...and is unrelated to your misconception of daddy's credit card)...incidentally I use my own credit when I have bought GS...you could always get a job then you wouldn't be upset about someone spending Daddys money, you could just spend your own.
Note too, there is no easy way to buy your enchants...they are earned by GS and non-GS spenders alike with the same number of button mashes...with maybe the exception of burning to L4 portals saving some time for GS spenders.

Incidentally, BoH is a hell of a LOT cheaper than WoW for the vast majority of the players in-game...

4. This is already the case...you get to add 1 point per level...and if you want to play with them more either respec or just make new toons. (OK so you don't get 1 point in every ability...but it is easy enough to test them out).

5. Your request here is simply about balancing changes...and while I think there are several balance adjustments that need to be made...this post is long enough already to discuss this further right now.
Saint_Kai wrote:
The strength of your character should largely be determined by the time you invest in the game... not on how much gold you can buy. This will also boost BoH's playerbase, because every game that has introduced the ability to buy your way to the best stuff, has inevitably driven away the good players. And they also attract the alternate gold sellers, diverting cash into a third party's account rather than Venan's. Nearly every game like this has become a ghost town of gold farmers/sellers, and very few actual players. Even Farmville, which was largely popular, has been bleeding most of it's playerbase for awhile now. There is an inverse relationship between how much they offered to buy with real world cash, and the size of their playerbase.

Read my point to #3 above.... you cant buy your way to the top...it just allows you to earn your way there faster. But you still have to grind to earn gear/gems and enchants and know how to play better then the next person.
Saint_Kai wrote:
Venan tried to set up an interesting and different system, and I do give them respect for that. But there are reasons that RPG systems have evolved to the point they are at. Ever since pen & paper D&D, there are has emerged a consensus about how best to bring about balance, and it has been honed over the years. It's something you ignore at your peril.

The one point here I would like to point out is that Venan is breaking new ground in a Cell phone mobile MMORPG type game. One that doesn't require me to sit at a computer or console for hours on ead and play...but one where I can play for a bit/minute here and there between meetings, on the plane, in the taxi, waiting at the grocery store line, etc... in this regard you really can not always compare BoH to games on other platform (like WoW)...and if you compare it to the mobile space...there is very little competition in my opinion... apples to apples and oranges to oranges...

EDIT: I started this and came back to finish it an hour later not realizing Eric had responded with some of my same points. Apologize for the repeated points but Ill leave the post as is.
In order to not make a long post, I'll respond in a general sense to a few concerns posted about what I suggested.

I played WoW, but got tired of it for a number of reasons. I don't want BoH to be WoW, but anyone who has played WoW, can see all the influences BoH got from it (right down to yellow exclamation mark for quest, and green mark for quest complete). I won't address why there are all these similarities, but let me state that I honestly do NOT want BoH to completely be WoW. I left WoW for a reason. That said, there are some good things about WoW that can be incorporated (and Mith, BoH isn't the only MMORPG web game; many other games have social aspects, and Venan is already inviting comparisons to WoW with what they borrowed from it).

PvP may be considered a mini-game, but it is part of the game. In every MMO I have played, and in fact every MMO ever, I've seen it is incredibly difficult to balance pvp with pve. Ultimately, a game has to decide what it wants to be: PvP or PvE. FFXI was PvE, although it had some PvP for fun with no real practical rewards. And that is ultimately what a game has to decide; treat one aspect as the lesser one and go accordingly. This would mean removing the ability to buy gems with pvp tokens, if BoH is going to be a PvE game. All you should get with pvp are cosmetic stuff. This means no one feels compelled to PvP, as they do currently, in order to get T5 gems.

There are level limits to some gear... but not the ones buyable with gold shields. Thus, someone can really buy the better gear and dominate in early pvp. Keep in mind, a lot of my suggestions were geared toward making pvp more even and fun for the lower levels. It was designed to smooth out the rough edges and make things more even. To make skill the bigger aspect in determining a winner... not the fact that you can buy gear, enchants, and gems and demolish players who cannot afford the time or money to be stellar in pvp. And you CAN buy enchants in the black market with Gold Shields. You can buy the transfer plates. You can buy the fluxes and essences. With enough real world money, you can give your character Lv6 enchants all the way around. You can't tell me that is balanced on the lower levels.

One option is to simply turn off pvp for players under 30, if it is so unbalanced and there are no balancing aspects planned for the lower levels. I've often heard people here say that PvP is supposed to be for end-game players... well, let's make it that way officially, then. That way, lower levels aren't demoralized early on.

As far as talents, I don't mean to diminish them totally. Talent choices would still come into play, but they wouldn't be the overpowering factor they are now. Can you imagine trying to pvp without Icy Grasp, Heroic Will, or Smoke Bomb? You can't, which is the problem. Letting players acquire the active abilities naturally as they level, teaches them how to use each skill. Talent choices, then, become more about tuning your character. There is still room for variety... in fact, more variety then you get now. Think about the (PvP) opponent syou come up against now... is there any real variety to them? No, everyone (at least the good players) has gravitated to the same set of skills. There is no variety now, except for the pve folks who can't afford a second spec, and thus show up in pvp just to get demolished.

So we have lack of variety, and we do have easy ways to buy yourself a much more powerful toon and manipulate the might rankings to smash other players in PvP. Believe me when I say that, unbalanced pvp at any levels, is a surefire way to drive players away from the game. There are tried and true methods of balancing that. The ones I have suggested are ones that devs at WoW and every other MMO have used and explained why they used.

For the simple matter that they work.

Edit: And let me add that I am in no way diminishing the work and effort the BoH Devs have put into their game. It is an achievement. But nothing is perfect, and suggestions can be made. All that remains, is what the devs of BoH want to achieve: a PvE game, or a PvP game. That should dictate where they focus their efforts.
Couple of minor points regds buying progress -

* The t11 gear that can be bought with GS can't be equipped until level 15. I've seen a couple people buy it at game start and be quite upset they can't then use it!
* Although recipes can be bought with GS, as can flux and essence, you can't enchant past lvl3 until you're nearly finished the Vile Gate questline as lvl 4+ requires Refined Essence, a recipe which is only available as a quest reward. Transfer plates in Black Market also only go to lvl 3. This effectively prevents anyone buying high level enchants early. No player can apply enchants at all until the Workshop opens, which I think happens about lvl 16ish.
Saint_Kai wrote:

And you CAN buy enchants in the black market with Gold Shields. You can buy the transfer plates. You can buy the fluxes and essences. With enough real world money, you can give your character Lv6 enchants all the way around.

All that remains, is what the devs of BoH want to achieve: a PvE game, or a PvP game. That should dictate where they focus their efforts.

Firstly, excellently written post. Very insightful. Couple points I would like to point out. No one buys ess/flux in the black market... its cheaper just to jump into a portal. With enough money, you can get lv. 6 enchants, but you're still clicking as many button presses as the person who isn't spending money - only difference being you can use gs to replace energy.

I agree though, its impossible to excel at creating both an excellent pve and pvp game. Really enjoy where the pve portion has gone. Hope that doesn't get diminished by too much focus on pvp.
Eh, you can get flux and essence faster in the black market, if you can keep buying gold shields. And remember, lower level players can't get into the gates, so they are at a disadvantage to someone who can buy whatever they want on the black market.

I will take back what I said about gear, as it has been a long time since I leveled up and it no longer shows me level requirements. I could have sworn the GS gear had no level limit. But I'd still do level limits on gems and enchants. If I had plenty of money, I'd do level 6 enchants on all my low-level gear and demolish lower level players.

The thing is, you have to determine how much of a fight you want to depend on each factor. Let's say you have a system where 50% of the outcome is dependent upon gear, and 50% is dependent upon skill. In order to raise the skill factor as an influence, you have to reduce the gear aspect. In this case, tho, it is more 40% talents, 40% gear, and 20% skill. We can bicker about the percentages if you want, but a large part of pvp combat is dependent upon gear and talents. I simply aim to lower those two, in order to raise how much of the fight is dependent upon skill. Note that this largely applies to lower level fights, around 10k might and below. Higher might fights have their own issues, but it evens out more once everyone has the top gear and gems.
I am very new to this game. I made a WM about a month ago, and have had a blast leveling her up mostly via PvP. I hope when the real version goes live, they keep the ability to level this way in. However, because I chose to level this way, my might is lacking and so is my gear. Hopefully armor choices will become available from the coliseum vendor. This game reminds me of DAoC in that speccing is so unique, I get to play with various armor set ups etc.

Some folks in this thread suggested group fights. I love this idea, and hope WM may become group healers some day, maybe via specializations. Just my two cents :D
Some more thoughts
  • It seems weird that there is no disadvantage at all for using a heavy shield, especially considering only one class has access to it (and this class gets a huge bonus for blocking an attack, with stagger).
  • The description for ice shield is a bit unclear: “absorbs 75% of the next attack”. Does that mean it brings 75% status and knockback resist too, or only 75% damage reduction? And, in the latter, why would it be triggered (or cancelled), by attacks that do not do any damage such as caltrops or smoke bomb?
  • Please add a way to define the default attack, and maybe even a second one if cool down prevents from using the first one. It happens quite often that either me or my opponent times out for an attack and, while the default attack isn’t that bad for a justicar (especially with bleeds), launching it as a mage is suicide.
  • Please link the background to the spec. This way I could quickly see which spec I’m using.
  • It is not very interesting to get destroyed by someone with 50% more might than you (although the rewards are not bad). It is even less interesting when it happens two or three times in a row. Please tweak the algorithm so that it tries to avoid your previous opponent at all cost.
  • On the other hand, when it’s balanced I may want to be able to call for a second fight. It’d be good to have a “re-match” button in the victory/defeat screen that asks the opponent if they want to replay, assuming they aren’t already in another fight.
  • An easy way to whisper the opponent is needed during the fight and in the victory/defeat screen.
  • We’re getting more and more chat channels. I would suggest that PvP chat flashes in yellow (like guild and officer) when we are in a fight, and that whispers flash in red so we can know when there’s a message definitely targeted to us.
  • The most important right now: Please do something about the timing uncertainty. If I see 0.3 sec before my opponents finishes his attack, I should know whether my 0.3 sec stun will land before or after. Right now the only thing I can do is try. If you don’t want to add more precision to the figure, since it doesn’t fully fix the issue anyway, you could use some hint in the interface: display in red the timing for attacks that will finish after my opponent’s (not taking into account the slower or faster finish due to urgency or chill/caltrops ending).