Book of Heroes

PvP suggestions

Some suggestions for the new PvP beta, and as someone who has played PvP in many RPGs I can tell what's lacking here.

First of all, if you're going to put people in against people with higher levels you need to either increase the lower levels health pool or lower the higher levels down to where it would be for that level and so forth.

Second, you need higher diminishing returns on stacking a single stat in PvP like say Physical/Magical defense and Dodge.

Third, take RNG further out of the game for PvP. The match shouldn't come down to a lucky dodge, or resist. People do not want 'luck' to be the winning factor in a match, they want it to be skill. This also counts to skills like Deep Freeze that can proc and also stun a person, so forth.

Fourth, Justicars Seismic toss takes back cast times too far AND does damage at the same time let alone how quick the cast for it is especially using heroic will. They have a stun, and two abilities that knockback cast times but do good damage as well. Either Shadow walkers/Mages need the same or this needs to change.

Fifth, Justicars bleeds tick for too much for a bleed that lasts for so long for how often it ticks, especially when they have a talent that applies the bleed for them on random from attacks.

Sixth, make all abilities do different things/dmg in PvP compared to PvE, that way when you're changing something for one it doesn't effect the other. If you don't do this, you will have an unhappy playerbase of both sides because it's impossible to balance it out without doing it like this as much as I know a system like that is harder to implement. However you have shown it's possible by doing so with the Health pools in PvP.

Seven, Stagger spec in PvP, the 1h+shield for Justicar causing 75% more dmg for next attack is causing them to hit harder than anything else especially stacking with Vengeance. That's 105% more dmg, doubling the attack. Been getting hit by 5k brutal strikes not even at max level.

Eighth, Icy Shield is proccing way more often than the 30% tooltip says. It procs around 70% of the time when I hit the target/cast something at it, see it pop way too often I fight a warmage that uses it almost 75% reduced dmg all game. Also noticing people that arn't even Shadow Walkers dodging very often while not in defend.

I'll add anything else I can think of that is actually related to the balance for PvP, and hopefully this will be the thread to post likewise suggestions and what people think of it.
My suggestion goes in a different direction. Instead of matching up on might, why not use a ladder approach, similar to a chess ladder. So we would all have a pvp rating, and would be matched up with other players with a similar rating. If we started to win lots of battles, our rating would go up, and we would be fighting harder opponents, conversely if we were always losing, we would start to battle against easier opponents. That way everyone gets wins and losses.

As you win against higher rated players, the rewards would increase. I would handle the inequalities of the match up through the reward, and through the change to pvp rating. I can only assume that the intent is to have some real rewards, not just 500 silver.

A lot of us play a game that we like as it exists, prior to modifications. Any modifications potentially make the game more appealing to non-players and less appealing to existing players. You could count me as one of the existing players that is tired of having his War Mage nerfed, so I'm getting tired of all the change this change that as it spills into the raiding experience.

Having heavily stacked haste and magic on my War Mage in the past, my experience is that the diminishing returns is working. I noticed significant benefit to putting a bit (not a lot) of crit on my toon, and even a little dodge. I think what you're seeing is the combined effect of abilities and stats where they can add up to quite a lot.

Clearly, a few players are winning more often, and as a result I'm sure they are really enjoying the pvp experience, and playing it quite a lot. A larger number of players appear to be losing more than winning, are deciding that pvp is not for them, and don't play it much - this was to be expected. I've found that I struggle against, justicars and to a lesser extent shadow warriors. Others have complained about ice mages. Venan will have excellent data about which classes are winning more than their share, hopefully they are guided by that, and make only as many tweaks as necessary to balance the game. Personally, I want my Icy Grasp back.
I really like the idea of a ladder system to match people up. Currently there is a super wide range of players that I get matched with - everything from a guy just starting PvP to the top of the leader board. I would much rather have consistent matches. Everyone once in a while I get a solid match that goes back and forth, but too often it is completely lopsided.

The other thing I'd like to see is the ability to challenge people directly, maybe limited to friends/guild mates. If there is a ladder system, these matches likely shouldn't be counted towards standings, but I would much rather fight with someone I know (and can talk trash with after) than a stream of random people. I always have more fun when a guild mate pops up randomly. This could be added as an option when you click on their name, or in the arena itself as a button that pulls up a list of characters you can challenge (showing just who is online).