Book of Heroes

Mis-matched Mights

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue Jul 23, 2013 2:58 pm
Venan,
You guys need to add to the PvP screen...the current mights of the players in battle. The reason I say this is I have seen many complaints from people about being matched up against more powerful toons...I think what is really happening is higher level toons are removing gear to get to lower levels to find challengers...so when they get matched their mights are the same.

However then their opponent goes and inspects the character from a leaderboard or chat, and sees a might much higher than theirs, and begins to think they were unfairly matched, when in reality the opposing player may have just added back on his higher might gear.

To avoid this confusion, put current mights posted on the opponents information card...so there is no confusion about what the might is of the person you were matched against.
Mithrid wrote:Venan,
You guys need to add to the PvP screen...the current mights of the players in battle. The reason I say this is I have seen many complaints from people about being matched up against more powerful toons...I think what is really happening is higher level toons are removing gear to get to lower levels to find challengers...so when they get matched their mights are the same.

However then their opponent goes and inspects the character from a leaderboard or chat, and sees a might much higher than theirs, and begins to think they were unfairly matched, when in reality the opposing player may have just added back on his higher might gear.

To avoid this confusion, put current mights posted on the opponents information card...so there is no confusion about what the might is of the person you were matched against.

Sometimes mith. Other times, its a legitimate mismatch. Fought Anechi today. I was 25.5k, she was 32.5k lol. We were both thrilled that a warmage barely beat me until we saw the might difference lol.

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue Jul 23, 2013 4:21 pm
Fizz_Eric wrote:

Sometimes mith. Other times, its a legitimate mismatch. Fought Anechi today. I was 25.5k, she was 32.5k lol. We were both thrilled that a warmage barely beat me until we saw the might difference lol.


Maybe they are matching more than might....hmmm.....or if it takes too long to find someone in the range of your might. I know Ive downgraded...been fight at 27-29k most of the day.
Mithrid wrote:
Fizz_Eric wrote:

Sometimes mith. Other times, its a legitimate mismatch. Fought Anechi today. I was 25.5k, she was 32.5k lol. We were both thrilled that a warmage barely beat me until we saw the might difference lol.


Maybe they are matching more than might....hmmm.....or if it takes too long to find someone in the range of your might. I know Ive downgraded...been fight at 27-29k most of the day.

Yeah, that's what someone said. The longer it takes, the larger the range goes. My only issue is... Well, at 25k might, I don't mind facing 32ks... It isn't terribly unbalanced. But imagine the other way. 25k vs. 18k is almost always a total slaughter. I don't know if that's happened, but if it has, sorry to all who faced me.
Matchmaking is pretty broken in general. Might isn't even as important as the player's enchants/spec/etc. Someone with 33451 might who isn't set up for PvP isn't going to do that well. Using Elo ratings would work a lot better.
Well I fought against Mithrid yesterday and understood why he is the only war mage in the top PvP players... 33k might, that's more than 50% above my toon (not saying you didn't deserve it, you use defense better than any other opponent I faced).
Assuming he did not try to cheat with his gear since he's the one posting here, that means I can potentially encounter opponents from 14.5k might to 33.5k. The gap is way too large. Someone posted in the suggestion thread that not only your might should be taken into account but also your win/loss record. That'd help balance things up.
Romain wrote:Well I fought against Mithrid yesterday and understood why he is the only war mage in the top PvP players... 33k might, that's more than 50% above my toon (not saying you didn't deserve it, you use defense better than any other opponent I faced).
Assuming he did not try to cheat with his gear since he's the one posting here, that means I can potentially encounter opponents from 14.5k might to 33.5k. The gap is way too large. Someone posted in the suggestion thread that not only your might should be taken into account but also your win/loss record. That'd help balance things up.


This is exactly what we were talking about. He isn't fighting at 33k might. Just because he's fully maxed doesn't mean his pvp build has the same. I fought him at around 25-28k (don't remember exactly).

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue Jul 23, 2013 9:43 pm
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Romain wrote:Well I fought against Mithrid yesterday and understood why he is the only war mage in the top PvP players... 33k might, that's more than 50% above my toon (not saying you didn't deserve it, you use defense better than any other opponent I faced).
Assuming he did not try to cheat with his gear since he's the one posting here, that means I can potentially encounter opponents from 14.5k might to 33.5k. The gap is way too large. Someone posted in the suggestion thread that not only your might should be taken into account but also your win/loss record. That'd help balance things up.


This is exactly what we were talking about. He isn't fighting at 33k might. Just because he's fully maxed doesn't mean his pvp build has the same. I fought him at around 25-28k (don't remember exactly).

When I fought you Eric I was at 27k...in fact Ive been there most of today trying for that rematch! :D

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue Jul 23, 2013 9:44 pm
Anathem wrote:Matchmaking is pretty broken in general. Might isn't even as important as the player's enchants/spec/etc. Someone with 33451 might who isn't set up for PvP isn't going to do that well. Using Elo ratings would work a lot better.

That is part of the challenge for PvP Anthem, finding the right build.
Mithrid wrote:
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Romain wrote:Well I fought against Mithrid yesterday and understood why he is the only war mage in the top PvP players... 33k might, that's more than 50% above my toon (not saying you didn't deserve it, you use defense better than any other opponent I faced).
Assuming he did not try to cheat with his gear since he's the one posting here, that means I can potentially encounter opponents from 14.5k might to 33.5k. The gap is way too large. Someone posted in the suggestion thread that not only your might should be taken into account but also your win/loss record. That'd help balance things up.


This is exactly what we were talking about. He isn't fighting at 33k might. Just because he's fully maxed doesn't mean his pvp build has the same. I fought him at around 25-28k (don't remember exactly).

When I fought you Eric I was at 27k...in fact Ive been there most of today trying for that rematch! :D

Likewise mith. Seem to have fought everyone from fero to anechi but can't seem to run into you :p I hear you've gotten better lol.