Book of Heroes

Adjust your attitude

Before crying, "Nerf (class)" or "Buff (Class)," you need to revise your expectations of what pvp is all about. Your opponent is smarter, and you can't expect to play the same way as in pve. I hope to address some of the reasons that people feel shadow walkers are "op" as well as a few tricks that will help anybody in pvp

The first and biggest misconception is that people are all ready to perform well in pvp using the same gear setup as pve. Part of the reason SW's are considered OP is because their pvp and pve specs are closer. When a warmage or justicar wants to kill mobs, s/he loads up the slowest, smashiest weapon they can and wipes out entire packs with one cleave or plaming pyre. SW's don't have that option, so they're already using fast weapons. Stop complaining that shadow walkers are faster than you are when you're using a 1.3 or 1.4 speed weapon. You have the option of using a sword too, and your main attacks are just as fast as a shadow walker's.

People undervalue the power of knockbacks. Shadow walkers have a 1s knockback that deals no damage, but has a .5s cast and 6s cooldown. Against a Shadow walker, you get 5s of actions for every 6s of combat, because you 'waste' 1s making up for smoke bomb.
A War Mage's ice lance has a 1.0s cast and 2.0s cooldown, and deals damage. That's two casts every 6 seconds for (on Wednesday) 1.0 s of knockback, identical to a Shadow walker.
Justicars, however, are insane. Seismic slash has 1.25s of knock back .5s cast and 5s cooldown (and does damage), Brutal strike has .45s knockback on a 1.0s cooldown (and does damage). A seismic and three brutal strikes in 6s results in a whopping 2.6s of knockback time. All of these abilities deal damage to boot. Very good damage, in the case of brutal strike. And to top it all off, Heroic WIll takes a full 3s off of all of a justi's cooldowns, and gives an attack speed buff.
That means a second seismic slash in those six seconds, along with another brutal strike, for a grand total of 4.3 seconds of knockback. In 6s of combat, a Justicar's opponent gets to perform 1.7s of actions. THAT"S broken.

In terms of utility, a war mage has time void. It's a .1s cast (that scales down with haste) that, when used properly, throws your opponents last 1 second of combat out the window. Ice Lance - (fire blast or frozen shard) -time void and your opponent has effectively sat there thumb up ass for 1.5s.

I'd also like to address stuns. There is NO reason to give war mages a faster stun, nor SW's a slower one.
Firstly, I love seeing my opponent open the match with their stun. The real value of a stun is to cast it towards the end of the opponent's timer, wasting as much of their cast time as possible, like the time void example above. By giving each class the same cast time on their stun, you level the playing field on this score.
The real problem is that WM and Justi stun cast times are affected by weapon speed, and SW is not. On Wednesday, a War mage with a STAFF will have a base stun cast time of .39s. That's faster than anyone else with a 1h! Even currently, before the SW nerf. A war mage with a 1h and 40% haste will have a .18s cast time for their stun. If your goal is to make staves viable for war mages in pvp, then the answer is to unlink stun cast times from weapon speed, not give mages a second time void.

My $.02, I look forward to reading yours
I agree with pretty much everything you said. My issue is that the casual player, like myself, will have to spend a significant amount of time to switch out gear to optimize themselves for pvp. I posted about this in a thread I just finished. It will cost me about 17K cv and a fortune in essence and flux to get everything switched out. To some, thats not a big deal, but I dont have the time to burn pots each raid or in portals to accomplish this.
Completely agree with everything you said. Very well said, and mirror some of our thoughts completely. Definitely a little worried about balance after maintenance tomorrow ;)
The problem is, you're both fortunate enough to have played a build that isnt the most common build for each of your classes. You're 2 of the top 3 in performance at the moment, so naturally you would love the system. But if it was really so evenly matched, would either of your win percentages be as good as they are? Im not saying it wouldnt be even if everyone could completely reset and rebuild themselves exactly how they would like, but that isnt feasible.

PS: was referring to mithrid, not original poster, who also has mentioned liking the current system
Sokpuppet wrote:The problem is, you're both fortunate enough to have played a build that isnt the most common build for each of your classes. You're 2 of the top 3 in performance at the moment, so naturally you would love the system. But if it was really so evenly matched, would either of your win percentages be as good as they are? Im not saying it wouldnt be even if everyone could completely reset and rebuild themselves exactly how they would like, but that isnt feasible.

Let me let you in on a little secret. Two weeks ago, when I heard pvp was coming out, I decided to make a spreadsheet. Wrote down my stats in columns (might, magic, defense, haste, etc.), including the numbers.

Had four potential options. Dual Wield Melee SW. 1h+shield Melee SW. Dual Wield Magic SW. Dual Wield Melee SW. Inputted the stat curves into the formula, so that I can edit my magic rating... say from 4000 to 8000, and it would automatically spit out the +damage bonus. Likewise for all skills.

Then, I calculated the expected damage of all four builds.
Expected Damage = (Total Damage*(1-Crit%)+Total Damage*CritPower%*Crit%)

Then I calculated my expected DPS (Damage per Second).
DPS = Expected Damage/(1/(1-Haste%))

Next was my Damage Mitigation.
Damage Mitigation = 1-(((1-Defense%)*(1-Resists%)))*(1-Dodge%)

Finally was my Expected Damage Taken.
Expected Damage Taken = 1-Damage Mitigation

Then I calculated a "Goldfish" stat.
Goldfish = (Expected DPS)/(Expected Damage Taken)

This number was ~8000. Probably similar to most of the complainers right now.

Basically, I stuck every stat into one equation, and as I edited those stats (subtracting magic to add dodge, etc), it increased or decreased that Goldfish number. I then simply optimized these numbers to provide me with an ideal build. Goldfish jumped from 8000 to 22000, which corresponds roughly to a 4-16x higher win:lose ratio factoring in my hp (won't go into specifics) against opponents who were roughly around my previous build through opponents who were relatively optimized.

That finished, I spent the past two weeks grabbing the respective gems I needed. I'm still at like 8 t3s and 8 t4s, since I'm still lacking valor, and had to drop from 28k to 25k might.

But how did I do? Almost exactly how I expected. I went something like 54-3 against unoptimized opponents (was expecting 16:1 ratio) and 12-3 against decently optimized ones (4:1). Once people are optimized, they'll do as well as me if not better since I don't have the valor to afford better gems.

TL:DR;

But point in all this is... I came out knowing what I wanted and how to do it. I ran practice simulations against LoB (Justi) and Karnak (Mage) to make sure I had my skill order and ability set down. And it worked like a charm.

I'll probably be passed up as time goes on, but point is.... it wasn't good luck or fortune. It was coming in prepared. Today alone, I've seen a giant improvement in those I've faced. Every rematch has done significantly better. And it'll continue to improve. The real issue was the 100gs cost to buy a second spec combined with wms needed to do a complete overhaul.

~Cheers ;)

And now that I've pretty much given everything away, here's the missing part:

Magic- 4966
Crit- 1584
Crit Power- 2208
Dodge- 4408
Resists- 1663
Haste - 4030
Defense- 0.4998
HP- 6045
Eric, I'm definitely not trying to slight you in any way. Doing all the math to optimize your character was definitely a way to get a good leg up on people who are only realizing now that theyre going to need to adjust their builds. And everyone will start to gravitate in the same direction as you. However, my issue is with the amount of time it will require a casual player to reach the build that they need for pvp. Hardcore players who have time to burn in raids/portals wont have an issue but people like me who don't have time to burn that often are going to take awhile before they can become competitive. I mentioned in a previous post that it will most likely take about a month for me to reach a build that I feel is capable of being competitive.

PS: As someone who has a weird obsession with mathematics/statistics, I love looking at the formula you used to help optimize yourself. I'm about to start breaking it all down for myself now :) Thx for the info!
Sokpuppet wrote:Eric, I'm definitely not trying to slight you in any way. Doing all the math to optimize your character was definitely a way to get a good leg up on people who are only realizing now that theyre going to need to adjust their builds. And everyone will start to gravitate in the same direction as you. However, my issue is with the amount of time it will require a casual player to reach the build that they need for pvp. Hardcore players who have time to burn in raids/portals wont have an issue but people like me who don't have time to burn that often are going to take awhile before they can become competitive. I mentioned in a previous post that it will most likely take about a month for me to reach a build that I feel is capable of being competitive.

PS: As someone who has a weird obsession with mathematics/statistics, I love looking at the formula you used to help optimize yourself. I'm about to start breaking it all down for myself now :) Thx for the info!

Haha, no worries, I couldn't agree more. I'm stuck in the same bind. I don't play enough to be able to afford the valor needed to fully optimize. Granted, if I spent the time I spent calculating the math into actually raiding, I may have been more ready lol. But I completely agree - for a casual player... pvp really isn't playable in its' current state unless they come in expecting to lose. Not sure how the matchmaking is done, but at 60-3, I was matched up against a 4-24 or some such... I felt bad. It wasn't a fair fight on any standard.

And yeah, no problem with the stats... might be a few errors in there since I don't have the spreadsheet on me so I went off memory, but that's the general strategy I used. Have fun ;)

I usually don't like posting right away just because if everyone copycats the same build, and its nerfed... everyone gets screwed, so always good to have a variety. But that's the one I found to work best.
Mya you assume we all care about PvP. I personally have no interest in that aspect of the game. What gets me is that Venan has (AGAIN) changed class abilities/times and as a result forced many to adjust their game play and possibly their build.
I get it that PvP is Beta and Venan has admitted they expect much more work to be done. But the classes are NOT in beta. They should not be tweaked so violently to adjust for one very new aspect of the game with complete disregard for the rest of the game that we've all come to know and love.
Well at least someone posted this.

PVP is a more difficult game. No more hand holding. If you want to compete you have to know how to play and gear and spec and enchant better than your opponent because your opponent doesn't care how casual you are or aren't, they just want to kill you.
I totally agree Rabid_old_lady...PvP is extremely stupid and has ruined the game for me if I have to continually switch specs over and over. The developers should have taken my money and spent it on things that we want, like gear, leveling, at least 10 times the content and our favority thing raiding. Instead theyve added a feature to be more like "other" crappy wanna be games! I know of three consistant money spenders that have given poor raitings to the game and left for good. I hope 1.7 was worth the crappy beta garbage!!!