Before crying, "Nerf (class)" or "Buff (Class)," you need to revise your expectations of what pvp is all about. Your opponent is smarter, and you can't expect to play the same way as in pve. I hope to address some of the reasons that people feel shadow walkers are "op" as well as a few tricks that will help anybody in pvp
The first and biggest misconception is that people are all ready to perform well in pvp using the same gear setup as pve. Part of the reason SW's are considered OP is because their pvp and pve specs are closer. When a warmage or justicar wants to kill mobs, s/he loads up the slowest, smashiest weapon they can and wipes out entire packs with one cleave or plaming pyre. SW's don't have that option, so they're already using fast weapons. Stop complaining that shadow walkers are faster than you are when you're using a 1.3 or 1.4 speed weapon. You have the option of using a sword too, and your main attacks are just as fast as a shadow walker's.
People undervalue the power of knockbacks. Shadow walkers have a 1s knockback that deals no damage, but has a .5s cast and 6s cooldown. Against a Shadow walker, you get 5s of actions for every 6s of combat, because you 'waste' 1s making up for smoke bomb.
A War Mage's ice lance has a 1.0s cast and 2.0s cooldown, and deals damage. That's two casts every 6 seconds for (on Wednesday) 1.0 s of knockback, identical to a Shadow walker.
Justicars, however, are insane. Seismic slash has 1.25s of knock back .5s cast and 5s cooldown (and does damage), Brutal strike has .45s knockback on a 1.0s cooldown (and does damage). A seismic and three brutal strikes in 6s results in a whopping 2.6s of knockback time. All of these abilities deal damage to boot. Very good damage, in the case of brutal strike. And to top it all off, Heroic WIll takes a full 3s off of all of a justi's cooldowns, and gives an attack speed buff.
That means a second seismic slash in those six seconds, along with another brutal strike, for a grand total of 4.3 seconds of knockback. In 6s of combat, a Justicar's opponent gets to perform 1.7s of actions. THAT"S broken.
In terms of utility, a war mage has time void. It's a .1s cast (that scales down with haste) that, when used properly, throws your opponents last 1 second of combat out the window. Ice Lance - (fire blast or frozen shard) -time void and your opponent has effectively sat there thumb up ass for 1.5s.
I'd also like to address stuns. There is NO reason to give war mages a faster stun, nor SW's a slower one.
Firstly, I love seeing my opponent open the match with their stun. The real value of a stun is to cast it towards the end of the opponent's timer, wasting as much of their cast time as possible, like the time void example above. By giving each class the same cast time on their stun, you level the playing field on this score.
The real problem is that WM and Justi stun cast times are affected by weapon speed, and SW is not. On Wednesday, a War mage with a STAFF will have a base stun cast time of .39s. That's faster than anyone else with a 1h! Even currently, before the SW nerf. A war mage with a 1h and 40% haste will have a .18s cast time for their stun. If your goal is to make staves viable for war mages in pvp, then the answer is to unlink stun cast times from weapon speed, not give mages a second time void.
My $.02, I look forward to reading yours
The first and biggest misconception is that people are all ready to perform well in pvp using the same gear setup as pve. Part of the reason SW's are considered OP is because their pvp and pve specs are closer. When a warmage or justicar wants to kill mobs, s/he loads up the slowest, smashiest weapon they can and wipes out entire packs with one cleave or plaming pyre. SW's don't have that option, so they're already using fast weapons. Stop complaining that shadow walkers are faster than you are when you're using a 1.3 or 1.4 speed weapon. You have the option of using a sword too, and your main attacks are just as fast as a shadow walker's.
People undervalue the power of knockbacks. Shadow walkers have a 1s knockback that deals no damage, but has a .5s cast and 6s cooldown. Against a Shadow walker, you get 5s of actions for every 6s of combat, because you 'waste' 1s making up for smoke bomb.
A War Mage's ice lance has a 1.0s cast and 2.0s cooldown, and deals damage. That's two casts every 6 seconds for (on Wednesday) 1.0 s of knockback, identical to a Shadow walker.
Justicars, however, are insane. Seismic slash has 1.25s of knock back .5s cast and 5s cooldown (and does damage), Brutal strike has .45s knockback on a 1.0s cooldown (and does damage). A seismic and three brutal strikes in 6s results in a whopping 2.6s of knockback time. All of these abilities deal damage to boot. Very good damage, in the case of brutal strike. And to top it all off, Heroic WIll takes a full 3s off of all of a justi's cooldowns, and gives an attack speed buff.
That means a second seismic slash in those six seconds, along with another brutal strike, for a grand total of 4.3 seconds of knockback. In 6s of combat, a Justicar's opponent gets to perform 1.7s of actions. THAT"S broken.
In terms of utility, a war mage has time void. It's a .1s cast (that scales down with haste) that, when used properly, throws your opponents last 1 second of combat out the window. Ice Lance - (fire blast or frozen shard) -time void and your opponent has effectively sat there thumb up ass for 1.5s.
I'd also like to address stuns. There is NO reason to give war mages a faster stun, nor SW's a slower one.
Firstly, I love seeing my opponent open the match with their stun. The real value of a stun is to cast it towards the end of the opponent's timer, wasting as much of their cast time as possible, like the time void example above. By giving each class the same cast time on their stun, you level the playing field on this score.
The real problem is that WM and Justi stun cast times are affected by weapon speed, and SW is not. On Wednesday, a War mage with a STAFF will have a base stun cast time of .39s. That's faster than anyone else with a 1h! Even currently, before the SW nerf. A war mage with a 1h and 40% haste will have a .18s cast time for their stun. If your goal is to make staves viable for war mages in pvp, then the answer is to unlink stun cast times from weapon speed, not give mages a second time void.
My $.02, I look forward to reading yours