Book of Heroes

Nerf Shadow Walkers

Shadow Walkers are terribly overpowered in PvP. If you are a mage and matched up against a SW you are gonna have a bad time. I think you should nerf them a bit.
How about a couple suggestions how?

It isn't as easy as just lowering damage output.
I don't know really. After being beaten by SW after SW I just felt I had to do some passively aggressively whining. ;)
Cacher wrote:Instead,maybe ask eric to guide you to be stronger

Honestly, I can't speak at lower mights since I don't have characters there that pvp. But 22-25k onwards, I've faced a few competent warmages that know what they are doing, and they do exceptionally well.

It's doable, but the cost to respec makes it difficult for wms to experiment. That's the real issue going on. Additionally, cookie cutter shadow warriors are easiest to play in my opinion. Honestly, if your record vs. shadow warriors is significantly worse than your record vs. justis/wms, you're doing something wrong and/or just following the cookie cutter strategy that everyone uses.

I feel like pvp is a long-term commitment. I like to think I have the best SW pvp build in the game, or close to it, but its utterly terrible for both VG and KFS (average 2-4 waves using my pvp build, compared to 12+ without elixir using kfs build), and mage pvp builds are likewise equally bad. End-game, once pvp builds become viable, there will be no reason to nerf swers. Issue is, since its' day 3 since beta, the default SW raid build is way more competent than the default WM raid build.

As bad as it sounds, my advice would be to hold off pvping until you either can save up 100 gs for the dual spec or buy it outright. It's expensive, yes, but no less than a sigil. There needs to be a mindset shift. Kind of like a sigil can increase your energy (and make you raid viable) from 12 to 22 for 180 gs, dual spec makes you pvp viable for 100 gs. It's expensive for a beta, sure... but its also optional. We pay to get the chance to test the beta. Else, we don't, and don't take part.

/End ramble.
Fizz_Eric wrote:It's expensive for a beta, sure... but its also optional. We pay to get the chance to test the beta. Else, we don't, and don't take part.

/End ramble.


That's the problem though this is a beta, typically betas are free to users. The users get to try out new content and in return the company gets free bug testing. I shouldn't have to pay 100GS to test a beta. When the final product is released charged what ever you want. While in beta you should be giving us a sandbox environment to fully stress test the system. that's my 2cents.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Jul 25, 2013 7:54 am
Honestly, I can't speak at lower mights since I don't have characters there that pvp. But 22-25k onwards, I've faced a few competent warmages that know what they are doing, and they do exceptionally well.

It's doable, but the cost to respec makes it difficult for wms to experiment. That's the real issue going on. Additionally, cookie cutter shadow warriors are easiest to play in my opinion. Honestly, if your record vs. shadow warriors is significantly worse than your record vs. justis/wms, you're doing something wrong and/or just following the cookie cutter strategy that everyone uses.

I feel like pvp is a long-term commitment. I like to think I have the best SW pvp build in the game, or close to it, but its utterly terrible for both VG and KFS (average 2-4 waves using my pvp build, compared to 12+ without elixir using kfs build), and mage pvp builds are likewise equally bad. End-game, once pvp builds become viable, there will be no reason to nerf swers. Issue is, since its' day 3 since beta, the default SW raid build is way more competent than the default WM raid build.

As bad as it sounds, my advice would be to hold off pvping until you either can save up 100 gs for the dual spec or buy it outright. It's expensive, yes, but no less than a sigil. There needs to be a mindset shift. Kind of like a sigil can increase your energy (and make you raid viable) from 12 to 22 for 180 gs, dual spec makes you pvp viable for 100 gs. It's expensive for a beta, sure... but its also optional. We pay to get the chance to test the beta. Else, we don't, and don't take part.

95% agree Eric. But why are we paying to test a beta? Or even paying to access the second spec at all? It's becoming quite clear that most toons will have to respec in order to PvP effectively. Some people will do well with a default build (i.e. one they never change) in PvP but will fall away as those who can afford the spec fine-tune it.

In my opinion, if they are going to constantly make changes and tweaks as we test the system we should not be paying to access any of it.
SW's dont need a nerf in abilities; They could use some tweaking in how to be played.
The SW's i now face all have Calltrops, Ensnare, Smokebomb and Urgency. Mixed and matched with either a poison or a physical build and 2 1handers with lower hp for a faster kills or a tankie-build with a shield and 27k hp for a slower kill give little to no room for errors for a wm. Justi's do it a bit better against a phys build (ofcourse with plate) but still have a very hard time against the poisonbuild.

IMHO SW's should either have the control while being vulnerable or being tanky-like without the control. For the latter; SW's are the wow-like rogues so should be the first.
We're already terrible in Raids and now we should be terrible in PvP too....no.

Here's my suggestion for PvP. There should be a subset of skills and abilities dedicated for PvP purposes only. This type of system has already been implemented across many MOBAs and I think if we give all classes exclusive abilities for PvP in it's own "Talent Tree", it would make the gameplay more balanced instead of just "who can stun first?"
Ok, so I've been doing some thinking. What about making caltrops break the stun? All that happens now is that the SW stuns, caltrops und so weiter.