Book of Heroes

Allow multiple consecutive defends

If Venan doesn't want infinite defends in order to throw fights that's fine. But I like to hit someone with an ensnare and then defend twice. That way my ensnare cd is a little farther along and I still have time to get an attack off before the stun ends. I don't know if I'm the only one that does this, but this restriction seems silly and it bothers me that it affects my rotation.
...but that's the point. That's broken. You shouldn't be able to ensnare/icy grasp, and then sit and defend all day to lower the CDs back.

Honestly, I feel like defending after ensnare really doesn't make a huge difference long-term, but multiple defends in a row would be a very bad thing. If you ask the people I've fought... they would not want me defending even back to back ;)

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Jul 24, 2013 9:58 pm
If you allowed consecutive defends...it would ruin some of the great strategy in the current PvP.
Honestly learning to properly time defends has become quite entertaining.

Leave defend as it is.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Sat Aug 3, 2013 11:14 pm
I think defend is good for strategy. However, I think it is way overused, especially by SWs who can defend almost every major attack from a justicar, while sneaking in 4-6 attacks of their own. My simple solution would be to extend, possibly even double the cooldown on defend for all classes. Make this an offensive battle, not a defensive battle. This would also address the issue of battles dragging out way too long, making for boring conflicts. And as an added bonus for venan, it will allow us to burn through our resolve quicker, and buy more resolve potions, making more money for venan.
Defend is good as it is.

Knowing when to attack and defend is an important part of any battle and if you wanna just attack without worrying about defence then stick to PvE.
Defending after a stun is a silly concept. They should just create the ability to be inactive for a predetermined period of time.

Also, pvp is going to be dominated solely by people willing to spend hundreds of dollars to spec and respec their toons for a long time to come. The 100 GS 2nd spec cost clearly demonstrates Venan is not interested in implementing versatility for the sake of strategy.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Aug 5, 2013 11:28 am
Defending after a stun reduces the cooldown on the stun. If you don't find that useful, fine, but lots of people do. Don't see how that's broken, everyone can do it. Plus defend also has a CD so you can't just defend repeatedly.

Also agree that knowing when to defend is vital. Reducing the usefulness of defend would just make PvP too much like PvE. It would become all about who has the biggest/fastest damage output with little heed to defence. You usually see people complaining about effective strategies, and defending the bigger attacks is good sense if you can't get one of your own in.
I'm not complaining about the art of attrition per se, just the Implementation. Hitting a button labelled "defend" while your opponent is stunned seems kind of silly. If we're going to accept that time management will be a major component of every match then I think we should allow players the chance to just be inactive for a predetermined period of time. I may just be nit picking here but the mechanic does seem goofy and an unintended byproduct.
What about unlimited defend, but have defend break a stun. It seems silly that a char cannot continue to defend indefinitely if that char chooses ("well, I defended, now I have no choice but to attack"), but defending while an opponent is stunned should give the stunned char the opportunity to break the stun.