Puzzle and Dragons seems to have such a system and it doesn't really encourage me to play more.
New Unlimited Levels based on your HERO SCORE. · page 2
I like it.. but the rewards would have to equal new abilities... my character learning is the thing that keeps me playing...
Tomski hit on something I think. Levels to infinity would probably not work I think. Not without the rest of the game supporting it. Higher raids, eq, etc. but something that toons learn very slowly so that there's always something to improve would be good. The t15 ring gave us something to do for a bit, but then it's done. Then nothing... Something on that level of difficulty, but that goes on for a while and is a tad more interesting. A skill of some sort that one becomes proficient at