Book of Heroes

Remove the bar that shows players moves

I suggest that the bar showing the players next move be remove.
This way it will be more challenging for all players as we won't know what to expect.

In a way the game will be more balance.

HoUK_Member_Mackey

Thu Jul 25, 2013 12:29 pm
I think this would remove all stratagy from pvp, you would be just button mashing and hoping for a win.

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Jul 25, 2013 1:13 pm
RSA_Officer_Mackey wrote:I think this would remove all stratagy from pvp, you would be just button mashing and hoping for a win.

Completely agreed!!! The whole strategy involved in PvP is watching what your opponent is doing, has done and what options he/she has left to them and then choosing/timing your attacks to counter them.

japster

ModeratorThu Jul 25, 2013 2:59 pm
I disagree that it will become challenging.

It becomes even MORE random and MORE luck based, since you don't even know what's coming next. You have ZERO control over the enemy. At least in the current system, you can do your best to outwit the opponent by making the right choices, then sit back and allow the probability game to takeover (determine dodge/block/resist/skill procs etc).

Right now, people are already complaining about the "randomness" and "luck" factor, due to the way BoH mechanics work. Putting a "blind system" in place like this will only make even more people yell and removes any need for intelligent play.

In my opinion, the cross between the tactical (timer, haste, cooldown) and probability (all the blocks, resists, dodges, skill procs etc) based combat system of BoH makes the game interesting since technically, any character stands a chance against another, and no two fights between two identical players of identical might will ever be the same.

On the other hand, if all randomness is removed, then PvP would be DEAD BORING. You would have absolutely no hope of winning anybody who has gear that is mathematically superior to you. Trust me, you wouldn't want that kind of combat system since it literally ensures that the player who spends the most $$$ for the best gear will always win. Right now, I've heard of plenty of freak losses where geared players lose to relatively ungeared players due to a series of dodges, blocks, resists etc.

Now that makes PvP fun (for me at least), since you can always try your best to outwit and outplay by making the best tactical decisions based on timers and cooldown, and hope the stars align in your favor for the dice rolls, so that you may win even if you aren't as geared.

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Jul 25, 2013 3:50 pm
Following up Japsters, I would just like to point out that yes, you may lose or win a few battles to the randomness of dodge, block, resist, etc. that occurs, however the reality is that skill can overcome that randomness over time...not every battle, but it all averages out.

Venan has done a good job making the probabilities have an impact on play, as well as keeping it fresh and entertaining, while yet allowing for the fact that average wins and losses overtime will be dominantly dependent on skill with your toon.

japster

ModeratorThu Jul 25, 2013 3:56 pm
Mithrid wrote:Following up Japsters, I would just like to point out that yes, you may lose or win a few battles to the randomness of dodge, block, resist, etc. that occurs, however the reality is that skill can overcome that randomness over time...not every battle, but it all averages out.

Amen. That's the crux about probability right there. It needs a large pool of battles to show. :lol: