Asandir wrote:.... So the sw can be even more badass?
Your tone suggests balancing should always be in favour of non-SWs.
Riposte is your action immediately completing. Immediately is now, as if there is 0.00 on an action timer. It should not give your opponent the opportunity to defend it, otherwise it's not a riposte as described. If so, then whenever Backswing procs the combat should immediately pause and allow you to defend in the same way.
Either make both of them the same in the way they are defended (or not), or change the description.