Book of Heroes

Challenges for 2H Mages---Can it be fixed?

Possessed_Mithrid

Fri Jul 26, 2013 4:16 pm
So I have been debating with several friends about how to make a 2H Mage a viable character in PvP.

Right now I don't see it. I personally have pretty much slaughtered every 2H mage with my 1H mage that I have encountered with the exception of one fight. That one fight was an anomaly in that my opponent got several lucky rolls (resisted both my stuns, I fell to both his, as well as 2 of his 6 ice attacks deep froze me. He also got several crits. I got none that fight...it happens, but this makes that loss an exception to the rule that a 1H mages will almost always beat a 2H'er.

That being said I haven't seen too many 2H mages with very good W-L.

Some of the problems I see with them:

They are too slow...everyone beats them to the punch. now it could be said they are no slower than Justis, but... ...the Justis do have Heroic will, and two very severe knockbacks, that definitely can help compensate for the slowness of their big attacks, especially if your caught in the siesmic/brutal rotations) the 2H Mage has nothing like to compensate for their slow attacks.

The damage gain for going from a 1H to a 2H is not enough to compensate for this. I know I tried very early on with my 2H Mage, I lost 5 in a row to both Justi and SW, that was when I switch to 1H...note I may better understand PvP now but I have no idea how to make a 2H Mage work.

You could enchant resists, but then all your counting on is a small luck % to get you to survive the onslaught of stuns, knockbacks and blows till you can actually Land a powerful counter. Even then your crit % are not great, and we have no damage boosters such as Vengeance or Stagger that Justis get.

Currently I have no good ideas on how you could fix this...because if we tried to adjust these deficiencies directly, you would just over-power the 1H mage.

You almost need something like a massive damage increase for the 2H staff (But then PvE would definitely be easier for Mage) or add abilities that affected 2H weapons only (This would not be easy to do).

I just thought I'd see what thoughts others have had....
Since the update, I have clawed my 22.7k might two-hand staff fire mage to 77-77. I have little hope against chars with higher might, but my crits following icy grasp can halve the hit points of similar might SWs. Lots of dodge and status resist makes it hard for SWs to do lots of damage to me to catch up... I do a lot of defending :)
Update... 78-77... just beat a 27k health SW with this exact strategy, two 9k incinerate crits following two icy grasps, and otherwise defending, fire bursting, and frozen sharding... plus a very creative use for time void 1 I'm keeping secret... I've not seen any other toon use it as I do, which gives me my best chance.
Mithrid I agree with you completely. Venan will definitely be challenged to make 2H WM competitive in PVP without overpowering it in PvE. Although I don't hear the NPC complaining so I'd rather Venan erred on the side of making the only character I play competitive.
I know people say "just don't play PvP". But that means I have an incessant reminder of my WM inadequacies both in my quest screen and on my Feats list. I'd like to have a chance to complete those Feats. Getting 'Top 3' in raids 500 times might be difficult, but I knew I could get it if only I put forth the effort. I'm not even going to look at the Feats that come up for PvP because quite frankly I don't stand a snowball's chance.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Jul 30, 2013 6:55 am
Playing devil's advocate slightly here:

Think about it this way...most toons that can use 2H weapons in PvE, do. The massive damage benefit tends to outweigh defensive concerns, since we have access to both healing and cleansing.

In PvP this is flipped. With no access to potions and fighting enemies that are just as fast or faster, you must take defence into account. Not only does the 1H weapon up your haste, the shield adds to your defence. There are almost no toons that use this type of build in PvE. Just standing there and tanking until we unleash our massive attacks like we do in PvE just doesn't work. Your damage output will not make up for the 1H Justicar hitting you 3 times while you power up an attack.

I think expecting your PvE tactic to work in PvP to work is part of the problem. It doesn't mean they need to 'fix' 2H mages...you are electing to use a very slow weapon. I'm seeing fewer and fewer 2H Justicars, why is it any different for mages? My little mage is the only toon I respecced and the difference is huge.

I don't mind if these differences remain long-term or not, it's just how it is right now. On the flip side, I'd like it if PvP became a more varied place build-wise rather than everyone using the sword-and-board combo, but I don't have much hope for that. At the moment I think the broken part of PvP is the matching system, but that's another issue.