Book of Heroes

pvp balance- statistics only

we can debate long about which class is better in pvp, who needs nerfing etc.
but in the bottom line whats show balance is statistics.

heres my maxed might justicar loss ratios over 250 fights atm:
21% sw
14% justie
1% wm


can be interesting to hear other ppl with relatively large record say 100+ fights. especially maxed or near maxed might.
so specify ur class ur might pure or hybrid build and loss ratios against each other class
My 11k wm is 72-69. I made most of my losses when I was using fire build, but ever since I use ice I can stand toe to toe to almost every opponent.
16-24 vs justs
23-26 vs sw
33-19 vs mages
Although I disagree with most people that wm is underpowered. Imo it's just that justs' knockback skills are overpowered and deserve a nerf along with the smoke bomb.
25k might Pure Magic SW

Justicars (43-3) 6.5%
Shadow Warriors (28-4) 12.5%
Warmages (29-3) 9.4%

Not sure how much that helps. Probably need a couple hundred more fights to get a good statistic.

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Jul 29, 2013 6:41 pm
john12345 wrote:
heres my maxed might justicar loss ratios over 250 fights atm:
21% sw
14% justie
1% wm

Does that mean John I'm the only WM to have beaten you? :D :D :D


I'm not tracking my wins, but I have ~32 losses out of 300 fights.

Ive lost three times to a WM, once when I was using a 2H PvE build as an experiment...I don't really count that.
The other time because my battery dies when he was at 4k health and I was at 12k....I missed the end but apparently he won.
The final was to a legitimate 2H WM fight, but there were a lot of lucky roles on his end that battle.

so 10% to a WM, the majority of the rest are Justis (~19) and the final 10 to SW.
Mithrid wrote: Does that mean John I'm the only WM to have beaten you? :D :D :D
Before the patch I was at 17-1 against mages, and you were the only one having beaten me.

Stats would me a bit more useful if they could only include encounters since the patch though, and we would be able to see changes in balance.

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Jul 29, 2013 11:00 pm
Romain wrote:
Mithrid wrote: Does that mean John I'm the only WM to have beaten you? :D :D :D
Before the patch I was at 17-1 against mages, and you were the only one having beaten me.

Stats would me a bit more useful if they could only include encounters since the patch though, and we would be able to see changes in balance.

1.7 prepatch was very tough for WM's...post-patch it still is Romain, I imagine you've been beaten very few times by a WM.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Jul 30, 2013 6:20 am
My Melee hybrid SWs ratios. 100 fights, 19k might.

10% Justicars
21% SWs
14% Mages
Mithrid wrote:
john12345 wrote:
Does that mean John I'm the only WM to have beaten you? :D :D :D
I improved a few vs sw justie since post despite my justie still is weakest against sw and strongest against mages.
now it's
11 justie
15 sw
1 wm

and no mith I was beaten by 8 mages so far u anechi and japster (two In row with two handed staff!!! I was pissed and added resist gem until tiffy beat me twice in row so protection came back;)) maybe one mage more but Dont remember.

actually the post purpose was to see which class is strong vs other but I can't see it clearly from above results. maybe only justie strong vs mage

Possessed_Mithrid

Fri Aug 2, 2013 6:40 pm
john12345 wrote:
Mithrid wrote:
john12345 wrote:
actually the post purpose was to see which class is strong vs other but I can't see it clearly from above results. maybe only justie strong vs mage

To this point you are correct John...I was expecting more of an obvious lopsided ratio between the classes, but apart from WM definitely being slightly less successful (its not a complete blow-out)..there is a pretty even keel to the win-loss ratios being posted.