Book of Heroes

recipe drop rates- Chance of

I have been farming karnak gk and vg trying to get recipes and haven't gotten one emerald recipe for my sw. I'm trying to get the defense recipe . Anyway does anyone know the drop rate om these dungeons and is there something I can do to get these recipes as quickly as possible?
The only reliable way is to buy them from the Black Market. Took me about 200 Karnak kills to get the physical damage enchant.
They approximately range from like 0.5-3.0% but I can never manage to get a better estimate on them.