Book of Heroes

Mega Topic: Trade for Things between Characters · page 12

Bimbosigliere wrote:I'm just barely hanging on to playing this game as it is. With 2.0 still two months away (if not longer) I'd really rather the devs focus on new content

Hmmm... I think I have said that before every 2013 release. :(
I personally like the idea of trading. Look at the trading/ economic standpoint of Team Fortress 2. Without it that game would be lack luster from my pov. People seem to say only new players are for trading, but all the vets just seem to be dead set against it only for selfish reasons. The time spent to level up is almost impossible to do in a timely manner unless you are otherwise unemployed. I'm level 25 and am close to un installing just because I'm feeling stuck at current might level instead of purchasing gs. The game isn't really free per say in this instance where they strong arm you into in-game purchasing.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Nov 18, 2013 12:41 pm
Why would you feel stuck at your might level? I suggest your keep raiding and finish your questline if you haven't already. It's been explained many times now why such a system would be unfair. Don't compare BoH to other games that have different systems.

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Nov 18, 2013 1:48 pm
Welcome Emjay,
SO I am going to echo some of Daigons sentiments, so bear with me.
Emjay505 wrote:I personally like the idea of trading. Look at the trading/ economic standpoint of Team Fortress 2. Without it that game would be lack luster from my pov.

TF2 is completely a different style game, and character development, besides crafting strange items and collecting unique gear pieces, is non-existent. BoH, on the otherhand, is a game completely built around the RPG concept of character development. You can not compare the two at all.
Emjay505 wrote:
People seem to say only new players are for trading, but all the vets just seem to be dead set against it only for selfish reasons.

The only real selfish reason is we want the integrity of the game to remain intact. Yes it would upset us if new toons come in and do in 2 weeks what has taken many of us several months and, in many cases a year or more to accomplish. However most of our selfish reasons are that we simply want the game to be what it is and has been, and do not want to see the idea of working hard for your toon completely wiped out with a trading system that would eliminate any need for work or toon development in the early game...it would also eliminate much of the rich content in the lower tier raids as everyone would skip those raids. Why do you need to collect KV from raids such as CK and Vallus and WoF when you can simply acquire through trade all the gems and gear needed to go straight to VG and KFS.

Simply put, a trading system would completely eliminate the need for any valor below CV, and thus eliminate any lower tiered raids. Ruining the majority of the game.
Emjay505 wrote:
The time spent to level up is almost impossible to do in a timely manner unless you are otherwise unemployed. I'm level 25 and am close to un installing just because I'm feeling stuck at current might level instead of purchasing gs. The game isn't really free per say in this instance where they strong arm you into in-game purchasing.

Emjay, one of the beauties of this game is you can not sit down and beat the whole thing in a few hours or even a few days...nor can you max your toon in a few weeks, even if you spent a ton of money on GS. It is all about the long haul...now for many of us veterans, the grind near the end has become tedious because their is very little too work towards (please hurry up 2.0! :) )...but, we have all been playing a long time...but if you are just starting out, you have months of potential game play ahead of you, with lots of opportunity for toon improvement.

The real issue here is your definition of "timely manner", timely manner to me is several months, at least 6, of daily casual play to get a decent solid toon...if you spend a lot of money you can have a relatively maxed toon in 2 months with heavy daily raiding. But you are not forced to spend money unless you really want to speed it up. There are several free players with very high might toons, I point you to Carlos or Fero as prime examples. But they are patient and steady players.

But if your definition of timely manner is "I want to load my diablo 3 and beat all the levels in 12 hrs of game play"...yeah that is not going to happen. And we do not want a Trading system that can allow that to happen. It will ruin the game.

I work roughly 60-80hr a week, and I have far too many children to take care of, so I play between meetings, on airflights, during layovers and early morning or late at night when I have time to veg...I play this instead of watching TV, I chat on the forums while I read my new articles for the day...actually I don't watch any TV to be honest, so that is my game time. And I have been doing so for over a year and a half. You can build an amazing toon, but it requires steady dedicated patience... what I love about BoH is it provides me the opportunity to play a wonderfully well written long term RPG from anywhere, in as little at 5 minute increments if its all I have...without needing to sit at a PC or console for hours at a time..such as with TF2 or Skyrim, both of which I love btw, but rarely get to play...

If you want a flash in the pan game to beat in a few days and then move on to the next game...it is not BoH...and we do not want a trading system to turn this game into such.
To expand on Mith's points, let's take the two extremes of high might. First, we have Zaja. The guy maxed out in a couple of weeks. He only did enough KV to get the signet (sp?) and he bought hero tokens like crazy. Really nice guy, but he was a flash in the pan. Barely lasted two months.

On the opposite extreme, you got me and Fero (as Mith pointed out). I have spent ZERO dollars on this game. At one point, I had 3 top 40 toons. I have worked full-time. I have slowed down and also quit enchanting (due to the upcoming transfer costs) so I've dropped out the top 100. An additional factor is more cash players came in and paid their way up (not complaining). Meanwhile, Fero is ranked 69th overall.

I do think the hero token grind of the game is too much but trading would undermine the integrity of the game.

Emjay, if you are stuck at level 25 and your might at that point, I think you are doing something wrong - possibly running the wrong set of raids. A common mistake is always running the highest raid. You can often build might faster by running SV raids (Zuur/Helion) over running CK. At that point, I run CK to upgrade equipment, but SV to upgrade gems (much cheaper for the might gain). Once you are up in the 8-9K range, then you can drop the SV raids. This is a very grindy game. However, Puzzle and Dragons is much worse and that company is making millions (from what I've heard).
Mith I'm glad you look at forums...you always explain things in detail so I don't have to...I can just agree lol...so with that +1000 to what mith said...
Maintain level requirements nullify enchantments and only trade between your own toons
I am absolutely for it,even if it can be done among your guild players or with your smaller toons! Everyone now has more than 1 toon!!! It would be such a great thing if it happens!
I think allowing trade/auction among a gud would be fair enough. It gives another reason to be in a guild.

BUT WAIT!!!!!

If you can trade for items, it means less people will buy GS to burn to work for those items.

NOT GONNA HAPPEN. Sorry, but this games first priority is to make money from GS purchases. Anything that will decrease GS purchasing isn't going to be taken seriously.
It would be so much better to have it in the game even if it's among your guild or even with your smaller toons,so much easier to raise and for the ones that only have 1 toon will gladly make more imo! Definitely should consider this option in the feature!