Peter34 wrote:I think auction houses work because some games contain a huge variety of items. Venan have reduced the variety with 1.3, introducing configurable gear via the Gem slot mechanic.
An in-game auction house would still work, after a fashion, but it would function more like an early "stock exchange", a "boeurs", where you sell stuff to a broker, and he re-sells it to people who want it for a higher price, earning a percentage profit.
With only a limited variety of items in the game, you'll see a lot of players put up the same kind of item for action, e.g. the tier 8 Justicar's Axe weapon, or a Gem +4 Health or a Gem +6 Haste. So there'sll be intense competition, and that will drive prices down, which means that players must be able to adjust their demand price, after they've put an item up for auction. Otherwise it may not sell at all, as it is continually underbid.
Also, I think it would be very desirable to also enable players to put in Buy Orders, similar to how it works in EVE Online. In fact a Want-to-Buy model may work better than a Want-to-Sell auction-style model, because if there is a Buy Order then you know there is demand, and potential buyers can keep overbidding each other, until someone finally comes by and sells to them.
Sadly I was not here for the variety version, and maybe it's just my opinion, but I like to find randomly generated power items, instead of the, buy tier 2, then 3, then 4, then 5, etc. Even if they had a random amount between 1-4 that they could be socketed. (Like no white slot, no red, etc)
Now to get back on the post. My thoughts on an auction house are mixed. If implemented with the idea above, then it'd have a point. BUT! Then would still feature the farm for currency to buy the best stuff, which would be fine. If not, well the auction house would have no point. I myself would like to be a merchant, its fun. Items could be put on auction for Silver, GS, or Valor. GS would then increase the GS bought, due to items being wanted. Majerio would have to be changed of course though.
Idea 1 :
To sell items for silver on the auction house, you would need to buy a beginner's pass from Majerio for around 1-10 GS. Then an intermediate pass would be unlocked, allowing to sell items for squire valor (cost 10,000-40,000 silver). Then an expert's verification, which allows shield sells (cost 500 squire valor). Then a merchant's oath, which allows soldier valor sells (1-30 GS). Finally, a Grand Merchant's Recognition, which either drops from Vallus/Trask with a low chance, or you could buy it for (10-100 GS) and allows you to sell items for KV.
Idea 2 : Ignore Idea 1.
Idea 3 : (My idea of auction house) An item is put up for a price, and is shown for 24 hours before it can be bought. The item is up for 72 hours, unless (READ NEXT PARA) it is accepted and bought. People must offer at LEAST the set price, and can offer more for obvious reasons. The top offer is shown near the "Buy/Offer" button.
Each person who hits "Buy/Offer" sends a thing of mail to the owner of the item stating (NAME) would like to buy your (ITEM NAME) for (OFFER). At the bottom is Accept or Delete. When deleted the sender gets a reply (Offer Declined). When accepted the owner gets the offer amount, and loses the item (given to the offerer). This can either use idea 2 or idea 1.