Jofisduboyou wrote:I was thinking it would be way better for everyone if instead of selling your old armor after upgrading for low prices in the shop. Couldn't we be able to give our stuff to say a guildmate in need or a friend who's struggling to bring his might up? A friend/guild gift system would not only help newer people to the game but it also encourages them to be more active within their guild and friend communities.
And for those who don't take well to the idea of giving their stuff to "noobs" for free. An auction house would provide a place for them to get rid of unwanted gears and valuables and would allow people to bid on them for silver and gold shields.
Please post your feedback and comments and let me and the staff know if you think this is a good idea 
User: Jofisduboyou(JSleezy)
Might: about 4200
Guild: Dragons Dawning
Brought up before ad nauseum....the chief problem with this suggestion is it would allow whole scale abuse of the toon building system...you'd have level 1 toons walking around with T12 gear (ignoring level limits here for a sec).... sure you could put limits of restrictions on it but I believe this is one of the reasons it would require a lot of development time...they would have to ensure that whatever system went in place didn't completely break the current toon development timeline.
Personally, I Have A Few Ideas, that Venan should take into account for the Future Book of Heroes Versions.
I Was with my friend and I Had just purchased Some New Armor with the Silver I Earned from Plaguerider's Pass, and As a gift I Wanted to give her my old armors

, But I Realized I Didn't have the Ability to Send Items, and I Think It would be useful to All BOH Fans to be able to. IF YOU HAVE ANY IDEAS, POST THEM HERE!

I Have often wondered if this was possible. Trading Items between players like energy potions, weapon and armor. What I think would work is a hub of some sort to trade items between players. A special area of some sort you know? Honestly I think this would work. Not only would increase playability levels but also make raids and PvP easier. What do you think? Leave a reply to what your thoughts are on this subject. If you like it or not and reason why or why not.
Several threads on this idea in the requested features board... General thinking is that the work required to make this work and be abuse-proof would be prohibitive, so it sits on the devs "someday" shelf.
Heroes! I have desided to throw up a petition to bring trade to Book of Heroes! I understand that this not a new subject but many a player has suggest such and I think we should how much the world would like trade or an auction house to be put up on Book of Heroes. Now Venan said that it would take up too much resources or it would upset the balance of the system of the game or it might make others upset. BUT! I insist on putting up a call to those that think it would be a good idea. Leave a reply if you think bringing trade or an auction house would be a great idea! I think if this post gets about say...70 notes, we just might be able to pull this off!
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT!
I don't see the need for trade...sure it may be nice but I see how it would far too easily be abused. Ergo...I'm voting it down in favor of Venan devoting resources to content such as 2.0 instead of another feature that may very well break balance in the game and offer nothing of value in return.
The only reason for trade is to cut the time it takes building a toon by leveraging the time/efforts of older toons...there is no value in this as too many of us are already maxed and waiting for new content...what would be the point of allowing newer players an easier path to building their toons without investing the effort older players have. It would just mean more players, with less effort, arriving to the finish line to await new content.
Nay.
This would require an enormous* amount of resource to design, build, test and maintain, with potentially catastrophic consequences for not getting it right.
Those resources would be (imo) better put to developing new content and working on fixing the stuff that currently needs attention (eg PvP matching).
* When I say "enormous", what I actually mean is "megagargantuansupersizedcolossal". But that's probably not a real word. Even though it should be.
Say what you will I still stand by my idea to bring trade or auction to Book of Heroes. That is what I believe in and I won't back down!
That's cool and all, but you've not yet demonstrated any benefit to introducing this feature. There are lots of features that people would like, but there must be a benefit to the players, the game as a whole, and the developers (revenue return on investment).
Trading would be a massive investment on Venan's part to introduce. We're talking multiple developers for months, project design, QA testing and additional hardware. That's all expensive.
Venan's main revenue stream comes from people trying to advance their toons - they buy GS to buy items, directly (buying gems with GS) or indirectly (buying e refills to get more Valour for better gear).
Introducing a trading system which would remove the need to buy with GS / Valour, or reduce it, would directly impact on that revenue.
So, this would be a huge investment, the result of which would be reduced revenue. That doesn't make sense for any company.
The most requested thing on BoH by players is new content. Putting resource to a development of this nature would slow new content. Developers, designers, and QA staff working on this would not be working on content.
Trading would see a surge upwards in toon capability. The low end, the story, the lower might raids, would become a wasteland that new players whizz through in a week thanks to upper level gear, which does a disservice to the work that went into it, and reduces player attachment to their toons. Games where you progress too quickly and easily see a higher player turnover - people get bored and quit more quickly.
I agree that trading would be cool. I'd love to pass old gear from my 28k Justi to my 13k babytoon. But I'd rather see new content, and keep the game free to play (most games with trading systems are subs-based, so trading doesn't affect revenue in the same way as it does here).
These are initial reactions. They are also opinion only. I'm a software dev by trade, so have a reasonable idea of the amount of work that would be needed for something like this, and it is HUGE. It's not something that can be tossed together in a few weeks or months because it'd be a "nice to have" - it's something that would need to have a very clear cost/benefit demonstrated, additional resources allocated, and commitment from playerbase as a whole. It's not like PvP beta where you can choose to take part or not, because as soon as it goes live, impact on the game as a whole would be immediate and hard-hitting.
Have a think round some of these issues. If you can come up with clear counters to them, you never know, you might be in with a shot.
+1 to miths opinion. Work for it like the rest of us did
