Book of Heroes

Resigning - Why. · page 3

Every time my characters get nerfed, I die a little inside. I want my powers back.... :(
CarlosDanger wrote:

2. The ruination of the mercing system. The social aspect of this game was never the same after entrapment was implemented. I said more than once on this forum that statements by Venan staff showed that they didn't understand the mercing world and should therefore just leave it alone. Sure enough they effectively killed it. My game enjoyment has never been the same since.

Agree with you on all 3 reasons. But I could live with reason 1 & 3. The ruined player-created merc world and resulting stifling of making friends across guilds has been completely disheartening. It makes playing far less worthwhile for me.

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Aug 12, 2013 4:09 pm
Oda_Hummingcrow_Hitobashira wrote:
CarlosDanger wrote:

2. The ruination of the mercing system. The social aspect of this game was never the same after entrapment was implemented. I said more than once on this forum that statements by Venan staff showed that they didn't understand the mercing world and should therefore just leave it alone. Sure enough they effectively killed it. My game enjoyment has never been the same since.

Agree with you on all 3 reasons. But I could live with reason 1 & 3. The ruined player-created merc world and resulting stifling of making friends across guilds has been completely disheartening. It makes playing far less worthwhile for me.


Agreed...I really miss the social-freewheeling days of guild hoping from 1.5... I still hold out a little hope for a guild visitor channel where I can easily drop in and visit other guilds without needs to find a raid or ask them to create a dummy one so I can visit.
I hopped online to say hi to some friends in the guild, check the forums, and lo! 3 pages to this post.

A few flames, but heck, this is the internets, if it's not on fire you're doing it wrong. But mostly... Mostly it's people expressing distaste at aspects of this game which are making it less accessible to the average player.

First, to the poster who thought I was moaning at Venan, blaming them for my limited playtime. I don't have a limited playtime. I am a stay at home student, studying online. If I wished, I could spend 14, 15 hours a day here. But I don't wish to. Venan is not responsible for, or to blame for, my choosing to play this game casually. But as an average player (2 maybe 3 hours a day maximum) I was pointing out what Venan was doing to push my sense of achievement, my sense of accomplishment, further and further away.

There is a formula to a successful MMO. World of Warcraft has it. Everquest 2 has it. Eve Online has it in SPADES. The formula is simple - effort + incremental (random) reward + goal = money.

Let me break that down for you.
Lets say you're in Everquest 2. You want to earn a new character title, so you head to a zone where there is a meta-quest that gives you one. Along the way, you do minor quests that add to the meta story, earning limited rewards, some good, some vendor trash, some unique. You also get random loot from monsters (breakdown as above). And for your continued effort, you get the end reward, plus all the incrementals, plus all the random loot in between.

This venture takes you 3 weeks to complete. After factoring in preparation, aftermath and clean-up, and gloating for a few days on global chat about your new title, make that a month. Which for Sony, means another $9.99 lining their pocket.

Venan has limited scope to do the same. They have a much smaller quest pool, they have items accessible from the store (or occasionally from quests) and they have in-app currency to buy specials.

What they don't have, is incremental random reward. Silver drops at a fixed rate. Gold shields drop so randomly, and so scarcely, that they don't even register on the serotonin scale for reward. There's no incentive to keep grinding away. There's no "gamblers luck" providing a serotonin jolt to the brain (a key requirement to make a game addictive). Even the "lucky" enchantment doesn't provide enough reward to keep a player interested.

So what you essentially have is a game which is designed ONLY for those who play for 6 hours a day or more. Because only those players will see enough incremental random rewards to justify the play schedule.

And the problem only gets worse at 10k might and higher.

Enough from me, still quit.

EDIT:

To those who said: "Why quit, why not try and fix this?" I thought this point would be obvious. But clearly not, so let me help you with this.

I made this post as i want Venan to understand the key reasons why I have chosen not to engage in their game, or provide them with any funding. I do NOT want to see this game end, and I do not want to see this game continue on it's current path.

A game is only as good as the designers make it, after listening to their players. A breakdown in this communication has occurred somewhere along the lines - the devs have shifted from listening to the majority of players to listening to a key few who (I assume) pay the most. This is a critical failing, and one that should be (and I hope will be) rectified.

I am not calling Venan a bunch of fail-hards. I am saying to them to review their choices and consider the path they are taking this game down. I am telling them that I, a casual player, cannot play the game in its current state.

This is not defeatist, nor is it rude. It is hard-line, and if you see it that way then by all means call it as you see it. But thinking I'm just having a whine and rage-quitting is just derailing what is intended as a "please review your development strategy" plea to the devs.
I'm with Evo and saying goodbye to what started out as a really cool game and showed masses of potential.

1) 1.7 PVE class changes for PVP balance was a poorly considered change. Test PVP with the skills as are or implement different ones. Don't change the 100's of hours I've played just because PVP might not work as intended

2) PVP it's been done better in countless other arena's and the lessons learned their should have been used

3)Were-chef event changed timers. I got my Transfer plate but to listen to a handful of GM's complaining about reduced raid numbers during this week shows an utter lack of respect for your entire community. I'd be very angry if I missed out by 1 due to the new earlier finish time.

4) Customer service. Waiting over a week for a response from Darkhorse and Little_Mike on a money issue. Responses in the past have been within a day. But when it's not Venan taking your money and something else it seems you can forget about it.

So for me ciao and back to WoW

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed Aug 14, 2013 10:16 am
Subject
Eve Online
PIN_Evologist wrote:
There is a formula to a successful MMO. World of Warcraft has it. Everquest 2 has it. Eve Online has it in SPADES.

Are you referring to Eve Online by CCP Games?
CCP wrote:
In the event Pandemic didn’t go back for more, but they’d already got the attention of CCP.

“That's a lot of billions of ISK to lose,” the developers tweeted. “Somewhere [fictional in-game messiah] Sansha himself is shedding a tear.”
http://www.pcgamesn.com/eve/eve-online-ship-worth-309-billion-isk-goes-flames-comms-goes-wild
or
http://boingboing.net/2013/07/10/spies-clean-up-in-eve-online.html
or

Due to the game's focus on freedom, consequence, and autonomy, many behaviours that are considered griefing in most MMOs are allowed in Eve. This includes stealing from other players, extorting, and causing other players to be killed by large groups of NPCs
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eve_Online
I'm... I'm not really sure why you posted those links.

Eve is unique in it's effort-reward setup, as it's almost entirely player driven. That epic heist was the subject of much debate after it happened, but for the players who pulled off the ambush, I can bet they were all sleeping like babies 6 hours later when the dopamine rush faded.

Unless your intent was to reinforce the model, I'm really not sure where you were going there.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Aug 15, 2013 9:53 am
PIN_Evologist wrote:I'm... I'm not really sure why you posted those links.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
I am sorry if I was unclear, I was asking for clarification on the developer of the Game. I often need clarification on points before I can understand another's arguement.

From what I understand, you seemed to compare Eve Online's Reward model to Book of Heroes and imply that Eve Online was the most successful MMO Reward model (Note 1).

So I added links to Eve Online's Reward Model to clarify your point. As noted in the last link, Eve Online is unique even compared to Everquest 2 and World of Warcraft. From what my friends and the Internet claim, Eve Onlines Reward Model is "Pay CCP Games $130 per Year. Put in effort. Get random reward from small to medium. Reach Goal. Totally legal to have a random player wipe out your last 12 months of effort and that of hundreds of your Guild mates. Slowly rebuild your Guild while knowing you had Max Tier Gear destroyed and lost control of your Unique Guild Halls." Some of my friends love this model. Of course they always won Diplomacy (Note 3) and I always lost. I am just too transparent and trusting. So I stopped playing Diplomacy, and never joined them in Eve Online. They seem to be happy plaing both games.

Now in this response you seem to say "Eve is unique", "Eve is player driven" (Note 2).

Which still leaves Everquest 2 and World of Warcraft, both subscription MMOs.

Are you comparing BoH to Eve Online's unique subscription MMO, or to Everquest 2 and World of Warcraft's subscription MMOs?

Thank you for clarifying your argument in this Topic.

Note 1)
PIN_Evologist wrote:
There is a formula to a successful MMO. World of Warcraft has it. Everquest 2 has it. Eve Online has it in SPADES. The formula is simple - effort + incremental (random) reward + goal = money

Note 2)
PIN_Evologist wrote:
Eve is unique in it's effort-reward setup, as it's almost entirely player driven.

Note 3)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diplomacy_(game)
Bj.

What I am saying is that BoH LACKS this essential element. The comparison to the three most successful MMO's ever created (not opinion, voted as such) shows this clear disparity.

Yes, Eve differs from this rule in it's method of establishing the serotonin link, but it still has it, more so than the other two.

What I am saying is that BoH has nothing to "hook" the player once the level/gear grind is over. Although I have numerous reasons for boycotting the game, this to me is the most critical in need of repair.

Boredom sets in to every MMO player at max level. But this one has nothing past the level/gear grind to alleviate the drudgery. It becomes "ugh, login, tap tap tap, e gone, logout" repetitive boredom.

And by reducing the occurrence of interesting new and novel events, Venan made this problem far, FAR worse.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Aug 16, 2013 12:58 pm
Subject
BoH has to be like Eve Online? or Wow?

MY PERSONAL OPINION
So the "hook" is the serotonin rush of stealing all the currency from all members of a Guild like Warriors of the SPOON or Helmsman Jucuzzi and getting away with it? The "hook" is the serotonin rush of PvPing with Tiffy or Celestial_Cavalier and destroying all their Gear and Gems? Things that in most MMOs are considered Griefing. These are the type of things Eve Online is best known for having happen.

I ask because you seem to keep saying over, and over, that BoH has to be like Eve Online (Note 1) *and* World of Warcraft, but more like Eve Online. From what I understand that is like comparing going to Europe during World War II (Eve Online) and playing paintball or Dagorhir in the woods with my brother (World of Warcraft). Both have a serotonin link, but one situation can end in death or ruin if you trust the wrong person (you in WW2, character in Eve Online), while trusting the wrong person in the other situation could lead to a large bruise if you do not wear chainmail (you in paintball, character in World of Warcraft). It is possible in Eve Online to be Guild #1 one day, and Guild #3000 the next due to a single character or password hacked account.

I am trying to understand your arguement. Once a player has reached Level Cap, has all Max Tier Gear and Max Tier Gems, the only thing left is Hero Tokens. You seem to think Hero Tokens are not exciting enough (Note 2). So Venan should make earning Hero Tokens more exciting?

My friends say that World of Warcraft has mega-ultra rare drops which would not be as much a "rush" as stealing everything from SPOONS or Helmsman Jucuzzi , but are quite the excitement. Venan could simulate these drops. After every Raid, all classes are randomly sorted, and a character from each class is also randomly selected. Hero Tokens are then awarded as follows:


First Class, selected character gets 64% of Hero Token Pool.
First Class, remaining character of that class split 16% of Hero Token Pool.

Second Class, selected character gets 12% of Hero Token Pool.
Second Class, remaining characters of that class split 3% of Hero Token Pool.

Third Class, selected character gets 4% of Hero Token Pool.
Third Class, remaining characters of that class split 1% of Hero Token Pool.

Example: Second Class, selected charactere is Shadow Walker Tiffy. Tiffy gets 12% of Hero Token Pool and all remaining Shadow Walkers in the Raid split 3% of the Hero Token Pool.


In this Reward Model, if you earned 25% of the Raid's RPP, you would earn 25% of the Valor Pool, but if you were also randomly assigned Second Class, remaining characters of that class, along with 8 other characters of your class, then you would get 0.33% of the Hero Token Pool (3% / 9) in addition to your RPP based Valor.

A Merc who won 64% of the Hero Token Pool, during a Double Rewards Weekend, would consider himself quite lucky and full of serotonin.


Note 1)
PIN_Evologist wrote:
Yes, Eve differs from this rule in it's method of establishing the serotonin link, but it still has it, more so than the other two.

Note 2)
PIN_Evologist wrote:
What I am saying is that BoH has nothing to "hook" the player once the level/gear grind is over.