Book of Heroes

Is the raid mechanic at all well designed?

I don't think it is. At all.

Winning a raid is about only one thing: Having a sufficient number of guild members online. And making sure they are ready to (log on again and) resume raiding as soon as their Energy has fully recharged.

There is no challenge, whether to character skill or to player skill. It's just a total grind, and it is dangerously difficult to lose even a low level raid, for high level guild members, in the sense that you put in a lot of effort but ultimately get no reward. Last night I earned a bit over 8000 RPP in a Lockbolt raid, with my level 19 character (20 Energy max, later 22), and I was clearly the #1 performer in that raid, but I ended up getting no reward at all because my guild wasn't able to complete the raid. And that's not the fault of my guild, but rather bad game design!

I have to admit, I've never tried a World of Warcraft raid, because while I did play it for some time, I never reached a high enough level to participate in raids. But I'm pretty sure that in WoW, raiding involves actual character skill, in the sense that the statistics of the character matters, and also the players' choices as to which skills to use when. And I am also pretty sure that in WoW raids, there is real risk of character death, this being the criterion for failure: If too many characters in the team die during the raid, the team cannot complete all raid objectives.

Also, WoW raiders know in advance how many guild members they need in order to have a reasonable chance of completing the raid. If they can muster 10, or 20, or whatever in-advance-known number, and all are sufficiently competent (chracter level and gear score), then they know it makes sense to commit to the time a raid takes.

And raiding in WoW is a continous and engaging process.

Whereas in BoH it's absolutely routine. At level 19 I can one-hit kill almost any non-boss foe in the Lockbolt raid, and probably do the same in the Overseer raid, if my guild ever is lucky enough to be able to unlock that one. I log on, and then I burn through my energy really fast, spending maybe 15 seconds per "raid" event, then I log off and do some ral life stuff until my iPhone tells me my Energy has fully recharged again.

It's boring, it's total routine, it's a grind, and it annoys me greatly that whether or not the raid succeeds ultimately has very little to do with anything that is under my control.

And isn't the new trailer for BoH promising the exact opposite of a mindless grind? Isn't it promising interactivity and excitement?

I think the raiding model, the shape of raids, in BoH is fundamentally and incurably flawed. I'll continue to play for some time, but I may end up not being enthusiastic about raids, which means I leave my guild or get booted out of it. And once I ding 25, if I even continue to play for that long, I'm likely to stop playing until Venan re-thinks raids so that they actually constitute good game design.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorSat Jun 2, 2012 8:52 pm
Raiding does involve player allocation of skills (eg the proper gems supplementing each characters strengths). The lower level raids are just that...lower level raids... Wait till you reach kraken, zuur and hellion and you will see what I'm talking about. I'm level 25 and was basically squashing everything in my path until I encountered those higher level bosses and was forced to change some skills ang gems to be more efficient.

Lady_Katy

Site AdminSat Jun 2, 2012 10:46 pm
I'm sorry you aren't happy with your experience regarding the raids. One thing to remember is that the raids are spread out for all levels of players. The first several raids (Skar, Lockbolt, Overseer) are meant as introductory raid experiences for new or lower level players. We felt that it wouldn't be fair to people below level 25 to have no chance of experiencing raids. As the raids progress, they will get harder, and more "player skill" will be involved.

Raids reward Valor when a raid is completed. The decision was made so that players have to work together as a team to defeat a boss. We want raids to be a social experience and build a sense of community. If we offered Valor even if the raid didn't finish, we'd have a whole lot of (as Little Mike likes to say) "Armies of One", and that wouldn't line up with our end-goal of having a community-building feature.

The idea to have listed somewhere on the raid screen the number of characters the raid is "tuned" for is a good idea. It will help organization and communication between players.

Stick out raiding for a little bit longer :) There's a good chance you'll like the content that's designed for your level!

Little_Mike

Site AdminSat Jun 2, 2012 11:34 pm
Thank you for your continued feedback to make Book of Heroes a better game. Raids as they are now is not final. There are several more features we want to add which we didn't have time for the first iteration. Raids (and the game in general) will continue to evolve as time goes on from player feedback, our own experiences when playing, and analyzing telemetry.
The problem is that the one thing you need - the only thing you need - to complete a raid, as a guild, is to have enough members online.

That creates serious time zone issues.

It's also boring that you have to log on, and then burn your Energy, then do something else for 30-75 minutes while you regain your 12-30 Energy, then raid again, then wait to regain, then raid again.

The guild membership cap of 60 is also part of the problem. If guilds could be bigger, the danger of committing time to a raid but ultimately getting no reward becomes smaller. But if you allow guilds to be too big, it becomes trivially easy to win a raid, of course, and each player would only have to log on and burn his Energy once per raid.

I still maintain that the entire raid concept needs to be re-thought. Scrapped, and then re-designed from the fundamentals up.