Book of Heroes

Offhand Upgrade? Tier 10 Dagger upgrade

TheAmazingGiovanni

Sat Aug 10, 2013 1:45 pm
30th level Shadow Walker. 11000 might. Currently using the Frying Pan and a Tier 10 offhand weapon. Build is moderately hybridized, attack rotation being caltrops 3, toxic blade 3, piercing strike 3, repeat as necessary. Haste is 27.55 percent Melee stat is 3500 or so.

I have been saving Captain Valor from gambling and can afford the Tier 14 offhand now. Does that upgrade make any sense, or keep saving for the main hand upgrade? I should be able to do Captain Valor Raids in a couple of weeks.

Thanks in advance for your thoughts.

The Amazing Giovanni
Personally, I'd upgrade the offhand for the greater gem bonus.

Upgrading the frying pan will give you an average damage boost of 125, but only +1 tier.

Upgrading the offhand will give you an average +120 damage (NB, offhand attacks only, does not affect abilitily damage such as caltrops, poison etc), but gives you +4 tiers to your gem bonuses.

If you're dual wielding, having a strong offhand is very useful in PvE, as you can take down 3 enemies with a standard attack (main hand, offhand, assassinate) much more easily, especially useful if you go do a CoC etc where speed counts.

Gem bonuses are calculated as gem bonus * item tier * item type = bonus.

A t3 Haste gem (+6 Haste) in an offhand weapon would give you:
T10: 6 x 10 x 2 = +120 Haste.
T13: 6 x 13 x 2 = +156 Haste.
T14: 6 x 14 x 2 = +168 Haste.

So upgrading t10 offhand to t14 would give you a much bigger boost per gem than upgrading t13 main to t14.

All the above is based on PvE. I can't comment on PvP as I haven't really played it much.

*waits for someone to completely disprove my theory*

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSun Aug 11, 2013 1:15 pm
Subject
Tier 14 Helm, Amulet or Ring for Might Rating
TheAmazingGiovanni wrote:
Currently using the Frying Pan and a Tier 10 offhand weapon.
. . .
I have been saving Captain Valor from gambling and can afford the Tier 14 offhand now. Does that upgrade make any sense, or keep saving for the main hand upgrade? I should be able to do Captain Valor Raids in a couple of weeks.

Short Answer:
Save for a Helm, Amulet or Ring.

Really, Really Long and Detailed Answer:
There are a lot of variables, but in this case, The Frying Pan is Tier 13. Unless you are upgrading to a Tier 14 Axe 1.1 Speed for RPP Racing/ Speed Raids, upgrading to a Tier 14 Sword will give you only a slightly better base damage (+16.7%) and Stats (Note 2) than upgrading to a Tier 14 Dagger (about +200 damage points to Toxic Blade rank 3, see Note 1), but both will be only a slight improvement in Augment Gems.

The most important thing, is that you cannot get into The Vile Gate Raid at 11000 Might Rating. The Vile Gate Raid pays the best Valor per Energy. So getting into that Raid, as soon as possible, is a good strategy. Personally i would save the Captain Valor and upgrade a Helm, Ring or Amulet to Tier 14.

Using a computer's web browser goto Enchant Material Costs- ARCHIVED to see an Tier 14 upgrade list based on Weapon Damage, Might Rating, and Enchant Slots.

Note 1)
Tier 14 Sword / Tier 13 Frying Pan
878/ 752= 1.167 average damage increase

Tier 14 Dagger - Tier 10 Dagger
(234+286)/2= 260
(126+155)/2= 140.5
260 - 140.5= 119.5
119.5 * 1.7 (Toxic Blade rank 3)= 203.15 points in average damage increase
Bj_DWR wrote:
A Shadow Walker with a Dagger equipped calculates base weapon damage by including the damage displayed at Majerio's Shop for the Main Hand Weapon and the Dagger plus an adjusted Bonus from Gems [Main Weapon Speed multiplies by Melee/ Magic Bonus Damage]. Base weapon damage is used to calculate all the damage from class abilities.

cont. Dagger & Attacks


Note 2)
This unpublished Draft compares swapping T14 Luck Gear (useful against Bosses with Treasure Chest) with T12 Poison Gear (useful for Poison Cloud against Mobs). The current conclusion is due to diminishing returns, not much difference between two sets of gear for main Stats, but a +9% Nature Bonus Damage (3* Nature Damage rank 3 Enchant). With this Gear, the character uses T12 Poison Gear versus Mobs, then switches for T14 Luck Gear just before combat with a Dungeon Boss. Either Manually switching 3 items, or using Spec 2.

Gems in T14 Amulet/ T12 Amulet
Crit
Haste
Magic
Phys Resist

Gems in T15 Ring/ T12 Ring
Crit
Dodge
Magic
Magic Resist

Gems in T14 Cloak/ T12 Cloak
Defense
Crit Power
Dodge
Haste
Melee

total Stat T14/ Stat 12 (difference in Stat)
Defense 22.16%/ 21.47% (-0.69%)
Crit 35.33%/ 34.61% (-0.72%)
Crit Power 179.37%/ 179.21% (-0.16%)
Dodge 48.61%/ 47.86% (-0.75%)
Haste 37.13%/ 36.71% (-0.58%)
Magic 847 Bonus/ 832 (-15)
Magic Resist 36.0% Mitigation/ 35.04% (-0.96%)
Melee 796 Bonus/ 793 (-3)
Phys Resist 28.99% Mitigation/ 27.94% (-1.05%)



Bj_DWR

In game FORUM button is poor. It is a mobile version with no search and limited lists. Good for reading Post #1 of Sticky and that is it.
OR
Desktop computer or laptop computer and login to full web version with multiple searches and SEARCH for your question (quest solutions, known bugs, temp bug fixes, class builds, etc) at https://Venan.com/boh_forum/search.php

:geek:

TheAmazingGiovanni

Tue Aug 13, 2013 11:56 pm
Thanks for the very detailed advice. More I went with my gut, knowing I would neglect the offhand weapon slot, as history has taught me nothing, I picked up the T14 offhand. Filled with T4 gems I am happy with the damage boost and am enjoying improved haste as well.

Thank you again for your time.

The Amazing Giovanni