Book of Heroes

Update 1.7.2 - August 15, 2013 · page 6

japster

ModeratorTue Aug 13, 2013 4:38 pm
john12345 wrote:

one more thing which ppl will probably bash me for it:)
I would like to see some functional bonus on pvp weapon in addition to cool look. not talking about twice damage, but something small. idk like 100 silver additional drop after fight. or 1 essence. or minor chance of some useful effect triggering after strike. or after fight.
of course I prefer this bonus tied to look so I could transfer it to other weapon together with transferring look. something like another layer of enchanting

Oh yes you'll get bashed for this one lol. While I wouldn't mind such an addition, I can imagine loads of pro-PvE-only folks are gonna scream bloody murder that this is forcing PvP onto players if they want to complete their PvE experience.

I think it's best if rewards for PvP do not interfere with PvE gameplay.

Little_Mike

Site AdminTue Aug 13, 2013 5:17 pm
Update:

There will be a server maintenance period on Thursday, August 15 at 11 AM EDT/3 PM GMT. This maintenance is expected to last up to 4 hours. This maintenance will be used to deploy game update 1.7.2!
Keep being paired against Matues with his 45k HP. Have no chance against his Jus when I manage to dodge his attacks, his backswing still hit me for heavy damage and the bleeds keep adding up. Justicar is overpowering with heroic will, seismic slash then brutal, ... Followed by stun etc...

I challenge DarkHorse as a wm to go against Matues and tell me how frustrating the fight against a Justicar is. The skill abilities are unbalanced between a Justicar and a wm.
Darkhorse wrote:
These kinds of posts are of the most frustrating kind to read as a game developer. How did you come to this conclusion?

Just because there are no War Mage changes this patch doesn't mean that we aren't working on something or that we think balance is perfect. Where did we say that PVP is working exactly as we intend or where we want it to end up? If it was, why would we leave it in beta? We know there is a LOT we need to do to improve PVP, that's why it's in beta. Just for starters, we aren't overly happy with the matchmaking currently or the game balance at extremely high mights. These are things we are working on, but we don't have any announcements for THIS particular patch.
First off, just to be clear and I am not angry or frustrated.

Now as to how I drew upon my conclusion is as follows:
- I am not asking for 'must have changes' in the patch, but just for news, the word, updates, some form of discussion. The only word so far in regards to War Mages was essentially your first posting. Since then there has been rather a disappointing lack of words. Thus I'm making the assumption that the War Mage does work, just not being played correctly... or in other words, User Error. That is quite possible, but seeing the reviews by others, does not seem to be the case.

- Yes this is Beta... but more of a Release than a Beta due to purchasing of a Respec. Had this been a true test, some means would be allowed to conduct a test without financial loss. For example one or three free Respecs to give it a try, provide feedback and after a certain time, those freebies are removed. But to pay to test and knowing that the War Mage is broken, will lead to frustrating play; which does not make since... pay to get mad; I rather pay to have fun.

- Since this is considered to be testing, feedback must be done in both directions to be effective. My typing of a "I quit post" should have not been needed to provoke this response. Unfortunately I did this though because one other person had mentioned of being disappointed with no news for War Mages (the first reply of this thread); of which there was no reply by a developer addressing it, completely ignored. Since there has been no feedback provided to us with regards to War Mages, then assumptions have to be made. I make mine based on other past experiences with other developers. Unfortunately in this matter, Venan is following the same playbook (make change, people start complaining, developer says things work, more people complain and prove otherwise, developer goes silent... which eventually leads to as it is "working as intended", nerfs or long delay but keep playing and paying while waiting).
I know not all posts can be replied to, but is possible to address them in a generalized manner. (I don't even expect my thoughts to be correct as for lacking information of game mechanics and such; but is a form of brainstorming which may lead to someone else coming up with a good idea.)
However, following a Policy of Silence is frustrating to a customer.

- My request to you as developers is to keep the community engaged, during good times and not so good times.
Such as for starters, what is the consensus with War Mages in PvP? Working as intended and users need some helpful tactic guidelines, needing tweaks, a major overhaul, etc...

Darkhorse

Site AdminTue Aug 13, 2013 8:51 pm
Mystic18 wrote:Keep being paired against Matues with his 45k HP. Have no chance against his Jus when I manage to dodge his attacks, his backswing still hit me for heavy damage and the bleeds keep adding up. Justicar is overpowering with heroic will, seismic slash then brutal, ... Followed by stun etc...

I challenge DarkHorse as a wm to go against Matues and tell me how frustrating the fight against a Justicar is. The skill abilities are unbalanced between a Justicar and a wm.

As it happens I HAVE actually faced Matues on my War Mage (I play a mage as my main) and fought a very close match that I lost by about 1,600 health. I'm not saying that means the classes are balanced, just sharing my match result :).

That being said I think people are assuming that we "don't know" the current balance or simply don't care. In fact, we have a very good idea of what classes are winning, what specs are winning, the might people are at when they win (and the might of who they faced), and what type of gear they are wearing. We are well aware of the current balance.

If you want a definitive answer on how I PERSONALLY feel about the balance? Right now I feel that War Mages are lagging a bit behind the other two classes (especially at lower mights). I think that any class using a 2H weapon is lagging behind at all mights. Physical SW are a bit ahead of the curve when compared to other builds (especially at very high mights). Our numbers would back up these conclusions as well (although the win/loss rate is much closer than people might believe from class to class).

So what are we going to do about it? We're working on changes. We have a plan. You'll be hearing our plans very soon. But these changes are not for this patch. I know that's not the answer everyone wants, but unfortunately it's the best I can give right now.

Darkhorse

Site AdminTue Aug 13, 2013 8:59 pm
Hamilton wrote:
Darkhorse wrote:
These kinds of posts are of the most frustrating kind to read as a game developer. How did you come to this conclusion?

Just because there are no War Mage changes this patch doesn't mean that we aren't working on something or that we think balance is perfect. Where did we say that PVP is working exactly as we intend or where we want it to end up? If it was, why would we leave it in beta? We know there is a LOT we need to do to improve PVP, that's why it's in beta. Just for starters, we aren't overly happy with the matchmaking currently or the game balance at extremely high mights. These are things we are working on, but we don't have any announcements for THIS particular patch.
First off, just to be clear and I am not angry or frustrated.

Now as to how I drew upon my conclusion is as follows:
- I am not asking for 'must have changes' in the patch, but just for news, the word, updates, some form of discussion. The only word so far in regards to War Mages was essentially your first posting. Since then there has been rather a disappointing lack of words. Thus I'm making the assumption that the War Mage does work, just not being played correctly... or in other words, User Error. That is quite possible, but seeing the reviews by others, does not seem to be the case.

- Yes this is Beta... but more of a Release than a Beta due to purchasing of a Respec. Had this been a true test, some means would be allowed to conduct a test without financial loss. For example one or three free Respecs to give it a try, provide feedback and after a certain time, those freebies are removed. But to pay to test and knowing that the War Mage is broken, will lead to frustrating play; which does not make since... pay to get mad; I rather pay to have fun.

- Since this is considered to be testing, feedback must be done in both directions to be effective. My typing of a "I quit post" should have not been needed to provoke this response. Unfortunately I did this though because one other person had mentioned of being disappointed with no news for War Mages (the first reply of this thread); of which there was no reply by a developer addressing it, completely ignored. Since there has been no feedback provided to us with regards to War Mages, then assumptions have to be made. I make mine based on other past experiences with other developers. Unfortunately in this matter, Venan is following the same playbook (make change, people start complaining, developer says things work, more people complain and prove otherwise, developer goes silent... which eventually leads to as it is "working as intended", nerfs or long delay but keep playing and paying while waiting).
I know not all posts can be replied to, but is possible to address them in a generalized manner. (I don't even expect my thoughts to be correct as for lacking information of game mechanics and such; but is a form of brainstorming which may lead to someone else coming up with a good idea.)
However, following a Policy of Silence is frustrating to a customer.

- My request to you as developers is to keep the community engaged, during good times and not so good times.
Such as for starters, what is the consensus with War Mages in PvP? Working as intended and users need some helpful tactic guidelines, needing tweaks, a major overhaul, etc...

I understand what you are saying. One of the reasons I was brought onto the Venan team was to try to engage the community a bit more. I feel that we're slowly meeting these goals, but there's obviously always more we could do.

If you want my feeling on where I think things are balance wise (and where our numbers are at) see my post just above. For obvious reasons I can't go into supreme details, but it should be enough for an executive summary. That being said, if you find me or any other dev to be silent, there is generally intent behind it. While sometimes it means "working as intended" or "not the direction the product is going on" more often than not it means "can't comment right now since it's in a state of design/testing/implementation etc." or "there isn't anything constructive I can add right now".

As much as I'd love to tell you all the things were working on as far as balance is concerned, sometimes I simply cannot expound on the topic at length yet.

I know you might not believe it, but excluding guild recruitment and off-topic conversations, I typically read every single post on this forum (I make heavy use of the "read unread" functionality). I'm not the only one either, I can't speak for every developer at Venan but I know that many (Beekeo, Little_Mike, Dave to name a few) also read the majority of posts on these forums. Again I want to re-iterate, a lot of times you may be getting silence, but it doesn't mean your posts aren't read and heard.
Darkhorse wrote:
Hamilton wrote:Well looks like I fold.
With no news of War Mages and PvP considered to be working as intended. The game seems to no longer be for a casual gamer, or at least for me.
But I did enjoy the time and the money invested, so this is not in spite.
It was real and fun.

These kinds of posts are of the most frustrating kind to read as a game developer. How did you come to this conclusion?

Just because there are no War Mage changes this patch doesn't mean that we aren't working on something or that we think balance is perfect. Where did we say that PVP is working exactly as we intend or where we want it to end up? If it was, why would we leave it in beta? We know there is a LOT we need to do to improve PVP, that's why it's in beta. Just for starters, we aren't overly happy with the matchmaking currently or the game balance at extremely high mights. These are things we are working on, but we don't have any announcements for THIS particular patch.

Chill lol

Haha lol just ignore these kind of comments
Ok my main ( clumsy maybe ) question is :

Is thier gonna be unknown hero tommorow ?

Haha lol ;)
Mystic18 wrote:Keep being paired against Matues with his 45k HP. Have no chance against his Jus when I manage to dodge his attacks, his backswing still hit me for heavy damage and the bleeds keep adding up. Justicar is overpowering with heroic will, seismic slash then brutal, ... Followed by stun etc...

I challenge DarkHorse as a wm to go against Matues and tell me how frustrating the fight against a Justicar is. The skill abilities are unbalanced between a Justicar and a wm.

Rofl
Thanks Mike for the response. I currently need much more cv and ht to have the ideal build to compete against Matues. In the meantime, I guess I will just avoid pvp until I don't keep being paired against Matues. I look forward to see the tweaks you guys have in mind.