Why have one class with a passive skill that can completely change the outcome of a match? SW's are already the masters of timing with reflexive strike, caltrops and smoke bomb. Why should they have a passive ability that resets their timer on top of it? This skill in my opinion is the single most powerful move in PvP, and it's completely passive.
Riposte- OP, Resets SW Timers
Backswing renders riposte a liability most of the time. I cringe when I dodge versus a Justicar. Between bleed damage and the backswing, being a SW isn't a cakewalk.
Eliste wrote:Why have one class with a passive skill that can completely change the outcome of a match? SW's are already the masters of timing with reflexive strike, caltrops and smoke bomb. Why should they have a passive ability that resets their timer on top of it? This skill in my opinion is the single most powerful move in PvP, and it's completely passive.
How could this be the "most powerful move in PvP" when it can be defended every time? I got rid of it in my PvP build. Trust me, it's not all that powerful always being defended. The justi backswing on the other hand...If a Justi dodges you they don't get hit. You dodge a justi you get smacked up the backside with a powerful hit AND you can't defend it. It hits 99% of the time regardless what the devs say.
Backswing should be changed to allow it to be dodged or blocked, true. But with a Backswing, that means you dodged a Wound or Brutal Strike or a Seismic slash... all of which are considerably more damaging than a Backswing.
And Riposte doesn't trigger Backswing... dodge does. Dodge triggers both of them. So getting rid of Riposte doesn't stop Backswing... it just robs you of the chance to instantly finish your attack. Also, any good Shadow Walker can easily time defends to happen when a slow Justicar finally lands an attack... which means an increased chance of dodge, and thus you take half damage from the Backswing.
OP is right; a Shadow Walker with increased dodge and Riposte, is a monster who can output attacks with lightning speed.
And Riposte doesn't trigger Backswing... dodge does. Dodge triggers both of them. So getting rid of Riposte doesn't stop Backswing... it just robs you of the chance to instantly finish your attack. Also, any good Shadow Walker can easily time defends to happen when a slow Justicar finally lands an attack... which means an increased chance of dodge, and thus you take half damage from the Backswing.
OP is right; a Shadow Walker with increased dodge and Riposte, is a monster who can output attacks with lightning speed.
Saint_Kai wrote:Backswing should be changed to allow it to be dodged or blocked, true. But with a Backswing, that means you dodged a Wound or Brutal Strike or a Seismic slash... all of which are considerably more damaging than a Backswing.
And Riposte doesn't trigger Backswing... dodge does. Dodge triggers both of them. So getting rid of Riposte doesn't stop Backswing... it just robs you of the chance to instantly finish your attack. Also, any good Shadow Walker can easily time defends to happen when a slow Justicar finally lands an attack... which means an increased chance of dodge, and thus you take half damage from the Backswing.
OP is right; a Shadow Walker with increased dodge and Riposte, is a monster who can output attacks with lightning speed.
I've been hit by a 9k backswing after dodging wound and you're telling me it's half damage? Backswing can be more damaging then the actual skill that was casted. And riposte doesn't instantly finish my attack it just reduces my timer to 0.00 and allows you to chose an action before it completes. Riposte is not as OP as many people think.
Justi hit harder but slower while SW are faster but don't hit as hard. You just want to nerf SW so justi can be stronger and faster.
So, when your Piercing Strike goes from 0.80 to 0.00, you don't consider that OP? When you defend and take an attack at 0.46, and then Riposte to 0.00, you don't consider that OP? When it happens over and over? I have been in fights where, half the time, most of my stuff is dodged, which just makes the SW riposte. It's a form of mega haste that no other class can even begin to match. Perhaps if it were brought in line with Snap Cast, and be a 2/4/6% chance to proc on a dodge.
Your 9k backswing was probably a 2hander, who had specced fully for damage. It is brutal, and I would totally agree that backswing needs a nerf to just be a second attack, fully susceptible to dodges and blocks.
Your 9k backswing was probably a 2hander, who had specced fully for damage. It is brutal, and I would totally agree that backswing needs a nerf to just be a second attack, fully susceptible to dodges and blocks.
I can tell some of you defending the thread owner are noobs. Here are a few facts to consider about Riposte:
1) shadow walker has limited attacks and not letting our action fully complete can totally throw off his original strategy (I.e. forcing one to perform a basic attack instead of using the snare that was almost off cooldown)
2) backswing, if I'm not mistaken, has a higher chance of happening than riposte.
3) as someone mentioned above, you can easily defend if we are using a deadly attack. As a follow up for that statement, it is rare that you see a shadow walker ALLOWING the justicar to finish a deadly attack before his own.. I almost never get riposte on piercing, due to the fact that im usually defending or using reflex strike to see the next attack he will play.
Riposte is nice, but not even close to "the most OP ability".
1) shadow walker has limited attacks and not letting our action fully complete can totally throw off his original strategy (I.e. forcing one to perform a basic attack instead of using the snare that was almost off cooldown)
2) backswing, if I'm not mistaken, has a higher chance of happening than riposte.
3) as someone mentioned above, you can easily defend if we are using a deadly attack. As a follow up for that statement, it is rare that you see a shadow walker ALLOWING the justicar to finish a deadly attack before his own.. I almost never get riposte on piercing, due to the fact that im usually defending or using reflex strike to see the next attack he will play.
Riposte is nice, but not even close to "the most OP ability".
You're all talking about sw vs justi.
Justi has backswing as a very clear and true advantage over a sw.
What about reposte vs a war Mage? We have nothing to combat the timer and no counter to even help us, snap cast is a completely useless passive skill at 6% so that being used as an argument can b stopped right now.
Justi has backswing as a very clear and true advantage over a sw.
What about reposte vs a war Mage? We have nothing to combat the timer and no counter to even help us, snap cast is a completely useless passive skill at 6% so that being used as an argument can b stopped right now.
Riposte is a good ability in theory, but in reality it has drawbacks.
1. Riposte is a "double passive" ability
- meaning that you have to first trigger dodge to have a (60% if maxed) chance to riposte.
2. Riposte screws your timers
- this is the big one. while riposte allows you to finish your current action immediatly (or rather bring the cast bar to 0.00), it does nothing to the cool down timers. you can, and often will, end up in a situation where you are forced to use a long casting, or another not desired, ability after riposte because none of your cd's have had time to finish, leaving you fully open to your opponents combos and cc.
I have won games due to riposte triggering at a right time. I have lost games due to riposte messing with timers. While the positive effect of riposte is better than the negative, it's is by no means a passive ability that is completely safe and always good for SW. That's is also why I think that pvp-wise it is well designed, risk and reward and all that.
I don't know how it works later in the game at higher might ratings though. I just hit lvl 30 and have been actively pvp'ing since lvl 24 (547 matches so far).
- Sonnet
1. Riposte is a "double passive" ability
- meaning that you have to first trigger dodge to have a (60% if maxed) chance to riposte.
2. Riposte screws your timers
- this is the big one. while riposte allows you to finish your current action immediatly (or rather bring the cast bar to 0.00), it does nothing to the cool down timers. you can, and often will, end up in a situation where you are forced to use a long casting, or another not desired, ability after riposte because none of your cd's have had time to finish, leaving you fully open to your opponents combos and cc.
I have won games due to riposte triggering at a right time. I have lost games due to riposte messing with timers. While the positive effect of riposte is better than the negative, it's is by no means a passive ability that is completely safe and always good for SW. That's is also why I think that pvp-wise it is well designed, risk and reward and all that.
I don't know how it works later in the game at higher might ratings though. I just hit lvl 30 and have been actively pvp'ing since lvl 24 (547 matches so far).
- Sonnet
Okay I gathered the info from these post ,
First of all Back swing does not hit 99% of time , as some one said in previous post (CrzyHopper)
I'm a justi and back swing , with seismic slash hardly hit as the %Chance says 75% back swing and mine don't even strike and when it does it's not a over exaggerated number of 9k+ . It usually hits 800-4k dmg
Example I was in a match SW dodged 4x and only 1 back swing landed
And if you read back swing if dodges a physical attack 75% proc to trigger so it won't work against wm spell attacks.
Riposte in the other hand triggers if it dodges anything . Yeah I see the negative of not being able to cool down but a SW base attack is also a hard hit especially if it's a pure Melee build , and with caltrops activated I'm sure most SW are not scared of being hit any time soon. So cool down not a issue for SW reflex strike CD fast enough to be ready
From my experience riposte triggers more than my backswing hits
First of all Back swing does not hit 99% of time , as some one said in previous post (CrzyHopper)
I'm a justi and back swing , with seismic slash hardly hit as the %Chance says 75% back swing and mine don't even strike and when it does it's not a over exaggerated number of 9k+ . It usually hits 800-4k dmg
Example I was in a match SW dodged 4x and only 1 back swing landed
And if you read back swing if dodges a physical attack 75% proc to trigger so it won't work against wm spell attacks.
Riposte in the other hand triggers if it dodges anything . Yeah I see the negative of not being able to cool down but a SW base attack is also a hard hit especially if it's a pure Melee build , and with caltrops activated I'm sure most SW are not scared of being hit any time soon. So cool down not a issue for SW reflex strike CD fast enough to be ready
From my experience riposte triggers more than my backswing hits