Book of Heroes

Justicars in PvP- Knockback High Dodge Bug?

Penth_chief_among_sinners

Mon Aug 19, 2013 10:50 pm
I know that everyone is going to think that their class is unfairly disadvantaged in PvP. However, I would like to know if any other justicars have had a similar experience. Since 1.7.2 dropped, it seems that the dodge rates of my opponents, especially against seismic slash and brutal strike, have increased dramatically. I haven't kept precise records, but over my last 20-30 matches, I would say SS is landing only about 1/3 of the time.

Has anyone else noticed this, or is the RNG just hating on me the last week or so?

japster

ModeratorTue Aug 20, 2013 1:09 am
PvP forums is the other way 8-) But I am sure BJ_DWR is gonna do something about this.

Anyway, my opinion is that it could be a combination of both selective bias (you just think they are dodging more often because of a bad losing streak) + people are given more time now to learn and gear for PvP and may have obtained dodge gems, dodge hero training and using defend more properly.

Penth_chief_among_sinners

Tue Aug 20, 2013 1:32 am
I wondered about selection bias, as well, and began tracking dodge rates. Over my last several matches, seismic slash has landed just 30% of the time on non-defending targets. This is well above the dodge rates I observed for all other attacks. If it were just a matter of increased dodge ability in my opponents, then the dodge rates would be comparable across the board.

I'm not saying that SS has been nerfed necessarily, just that the numbers are playing out in odd ways. Unfortunately, this has really begun to take the fun out of pvp for me.

Penth_chief_among_sinners

Tue Aug 20, 2013 6:37 am
Another 10 matches in the books. Seismic Slash hit rate on non-defending targets hovering consistently around 30%.

I would appreciate someone from Venan replying in this thread to clarify whether this is normal and something justicars can continue to expect or whether something is indeed off in the game mechanics.

Thank you.
I have noticed it , they do seem to get blocked or dodged more than not. I was even curious about the sw smoke bomb.. Since I could never dodge or block it... Which is a great advantage for sw. I have lost most to sw using sb.
Oh yeah, Seismic gets dodged/resisted/blocked about 70% of the time if not more. It's the only power move that Justis have and it hardly ever works. I often have both Seismics resisted during fights, it's ridiculous.

All the while SWs continue having every OP move in the game happen for them.

(and mages are weak as.... I feel your pain, mages)
I don't see the problem, seriously, the majority of PvPers are 1H Justicars running stacked haste stunlock/knockback rotation builds so most of the time the "negative" effect of this is equally applied to both opponents in a fight. Fighting a non Justi it would be a nerf to the already underpowered War Mage and anyone running a 2H build (all 3 of us).
My experience with seismic slash most of the time is like this :

Justicar with vengeance 3 + stagger , seismic slash incoming so I defend, I dodge, then BAM backswing 5K crit ( in to defend ). Imagine if I didn't use defend button, it would be 10k crit, and if I have 0 defense enchantment, it would be 20k crit.... Ohh yea only justicar baby :)