Book of Heroes

Ability/attack damages- High Crit PS, BS, & TB

So, been running just shy of 400 matches now and I seem to take some insanely big hits quite often.
I'd think that within a reasonable might-range our attacks shouldnt differ soo much. Example,

Often see a piercing strike hitting for 7k, poison blade for 8-9k (3 stacks)
Brutal strike for 6-8k

Running with almost 40% phys resist.

Attacks like brutal, incinerate/icelance and PS are somewhat "the equal" attack considering the time it takes to cast it.
Although I have yet to ser any of the WM attacks land for over 5.8k.

PS often hits harder through my defend than I can crit my spell on a undefended opponent.

So, whats the difference on these attacks "behind the scenes"? Does physical have some multiplier that not magic have? Is the melee/magic "capped at a simular damagecurve?
How does armour apply vs melee/magic.

Cheers
Linch :)

Ps, whats up with matchmaking giving me 10-11k higher might opponents ;))
piercing brutal r physical attacks which can be dodged and nullified dmg. ALL wm attacks r magical meaning even if dodged deal half dmg. I think this might be a reason
for less dmg.
toxic is actually spell so also doing half dmg if dodged, but poison sw build anyway isn't strongest compared to melee so it shouldntt make big difference.