Book of Heroes

Shadow Walker physical vs magic path

Hi there,
I've recently started playing this game as a Shadow Walker and I am enjoying it so far. I've decided to go on the magic path so all my red gems are magic and I am raising magic with tomes.
What bothers me is pvp. It's really hard to win with magic path because most of the skills there are multiple target oriented slow skill. So I guess physical path with quick single target skills will be better. I am still not high level but I am wondering if I want to do both endgame pvp and pve which path will be better.
I think that if you try to do both you will fail because you will end up with mediocre magic and might so it's better to just stick with physical or magic damage and not mix them.
Can I have some high level Shadow Walkers input :)

Thanks in advance.
Mine's a Hybrid built geared for KFS and CoC.
For PvP, I use pure melee built and removed anything that has to do with magic.
Abraxius wrote:Hi there,
I've recently started playing this game as a Shadow Walker and I am enjoying it so far. I've decided to go on the magic path so all my red gems are magic and I am raising magic with tomes.
What bothers me is pvp. It's really hard to win with magic path because most of the skills there are multiple target oriented slow skill. So I guess physical path with quick single target skills will be better. I am still not high level but I am wondering if I want to do both endgame pvp and pve which path will be better.
I think that if you try to do both you will fail because you will end up with mediocre magic and might so it's better to just stick with physical or magic damage and not mix them.
Can I have some high level Shadow Walkers input :)

Thanks in advance.

I have a 28k poison SW and a 27k melee at the moment. Here are my thoughts.

PVP - Both are pvp viable, honestly, I think poison is slightly better, though a tad more confusing to use. Only reason being that it provides a bit more variety in timings (since both poison cloud and acid spray have different timers from toxic/reflexive). That said, the pvp difference is very slight, and really could go either way (Monkey is 2-0 against me and he's pure melee).

PVE - Poison is slower in real time, but has the potential to do more damage. Melee is unnaturally fast in real time, but honestly, it doesn't do as much damage and gets boring spamming the same two attacks all day. (Max hit poison is 25-26k for me, Melee is ~18k). That said... if you aim to be a speed VGer or a speed KFSer, and be the fastest player in your guild... go melee. If you don't really care, and are interested in poison, go poison.

Personally, I don't think hybrids work until extremely high might. My "Poison" build has piercing strike and critical eye... but only because my melee ht is nearly maxed, so I can actually do 10-11k damage despite not having any gems in it.


For KFS - in terms of RPP... all three are pretty even... I can average around 2400 a round with melee/magic/hybrid. Only real difference is speed imo. Magic slows down with all the popups and dots.
Fizz_Eric wrote:
I have a 28k poison SW and a 27k melee at the moment. Here are my thoughts.

PVP - Both are pvp viable, honestly, I think poison is slightly better, though a tad more confusing to use. Only reason being that it provides a bit more variety in timings (since both poison cloud and acid spray have different timers from toxic/reflexive). That said, the pvp difference is very slight, and really could go either way (Monkey is 2-0 against me and he's pure melee).

PVE - Poison is slower in real time, but has the potential to do more damage. Melee is unnaturally fast in real time, but honestly, it doesn't do as much damage and gets boring spamming the same two attacks all day. (Max hit poison is 25-26k for me, Melee is ~18k). That said... if you aim to be a speed VGer or a speed KFSer, and be the fastest player in your guild... go melee. If you don't really care, and are interested in poison, go poison.

Personally, I don't think hybrids work until extremely high might. My "Poison" build has piercing strike and critical eye... but only because my melee ht is nearly maxed, so I can actually do 10-11k damage despite not having any gems in it.


For KFS - in terms of RPP... all three are pretty even... I can average around 2400 a round with melee/magic/hybrid. Only real difference is speed imo. Magic slows down with all the popups and dots.

Thanks for the detailed input :)
I've decided to go with the physical path. I guess I just like more the real rogue feel :)
Can you also help me decide what weapon to use, axe or sword with physical shadow walker. I am also wandering on which tomes to focus first. Definitely melee, haste and crit rate and power but do I also need dodge as much as physical shadow walker?

Thanks again.
Abraxius wrote:
Thanks for the detailed input :)
I've decided to go with the physical path. I guess I just like more the real rogue feel :)
Can you also help me decide what weapon to use, axe or sword with physical shadow walker. I am also wandering on which tomes to focus first. Definitely melee, haste and crit rate and power but do I also need dodge as much as physical shadow walker?

Thanks again.


Sure thing. Regarding weapons, I've really heard its personal preference. When it came to Tier 14 (the highest tier of weapons currently available), I purchased both the sword and the axe.

Mainly because - my goal as a melee SW was pure speed. I wanted to tear through my e in 4-5 min in VG raids, and on the off day went i used gs, I wanted to hit first for the mvp bonuses. That said, sword is obviously faster, so if you can one hit kill enemies with the sword, by all means use it. However, I initially got the axe when i was 13-18kish might for the damage boost. Even if it was slightly slower,it allowed me just enough more damage per strike to finish enemies off quicker. Once my might went up (and corresponding damage stats), I've been able to switch to the sword and have similar results. But again, the difference is all personal preference. With a SW, its a 10% speed/damage difference in weapons which is slight enough to not make too too much of an impact.

Regarding Hero Training Tomes - Haste should be your main focus. In this game, whatever your class, getting haste increased is a MUST, atleast in the current version. The higher your haste, the faster you hit, and the quicker you can get hits in before your enemies. Especially for end-game bosses, 37%+ haste is a must. After that, I'd say melee, then crit, then crit power. Dodge really isn't super useful to spend huge amounts of ht on until you run out of the first four, since damage output really is key in the game and anything that helps you hit harder or faster takes precedence.

I trained my ht like this:

Got everything to ~200 stat --> then got haste to 1200 stat (1200 is the current cap)
Got everything to ~400 stat --> then got magic to 1200 stat (here, you'd do melee instead)
Got everything to ~600 stat --> then got melee to 1200 stat (here, you'd do crit instead)

Couple variations on this - Some people disregard the skills they don't need completely (in your case, never training resists or magic). Other times people like to train a bit more evenly (like haste/melee together -> then crit/crit power). All in all its personal pref, as long as haste, magic, crit, crit power all get up there perferably in that order. Once that's done, go dodge.