Book of Heroes

PvP: Lost Money and Time or AFK Players

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSun Sep 8, 2013 6:39 am
Subject
PvP- Lost Money and Time or AFK Players

Overview
Server Time costs Venan Real World Money,
Players have limited time online,
AFK players waste Venan's money and player's time,
If losing a Bout, you can just hit Basic Attack repeatedly, no need for AFK,
PvP Season 1+ will add unique PvP Gear and PvP Consumables,
AFK players would earn PvP Consumables for zero money and zero time,
AFK players need to be detected, and dealt with.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
Amazon does not give Server Time to Venan for free. I have limited time to play BoH. If Venan is spending money, and I am spending 5- 15 minutes in a Bout earning my PvP Currency, why should an AFK player get PvP Currency for spending none of their money and none of their time in PvP Bouts?

My War Mage and Justicar are struggling in PvP. They are high enough Might to need a PvP set of Gear, Gems, and Enchants, but still have Tier 12 Gear and Tier 4 Gems. They are going to get better PvE gear before upgrading to PvP, so what do I do? I fight PvP. Yes, if the fight is going particularly bad, I hit Basic Attack every single time. If I really want to be creative, I use Defend when I can. But I am still present in the PvP Bout, and I am still earning my PvP Currency, and I am still justifying whatever rate Venan is paying for Server Time. My AFK opponent is investing no money, and no time and still using up my limited play time and spending Venan's money.

One AFK player had 2,200 Bouts last time we fought. My best PvP character is only up to 600, my other two characters are less. This AFK player probably has more PvP Currency than all my characters combined.

When Venan implements an anti-AFK player Server Fix, it will reduce paid Server Time spent on AFK players, it will reduce my time spent defeating AFK players, it will improve PvP. Depending on the fix they eventually decide works best, I may lose my easy wins, but it will level the PvP Currency playing field before AFK players can spend their PvP Currency on the PvP equivalent of Valentine's Bracers, an Elixir of Speed or a Major Spirit Rune.
Maybe Venan can introduce some kind of auto forfeit thing for people who use lets say 3 auto attacks in a row.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Sep 9, 2013 2:23 pm
Subject
Detecting AFK Players
Spriher wrote:Maybe Venan can introduce some kind of auto forfeit thing for people who use lets say 3 auto attacks in a row.

Spriher, thank you for your suggestion.

I would love to have access to Venan's PvP data to make this call, but I do not. I have had opponents AFK for half the Bout and still destroy me for the Win.

Perhaps a AFK stat like EAR ( Zombie Rating or Expiration/ Action Ratio ) to separate the chronic AFK from the occasional.

CodeMonkey

Site AdminMon Sep 9, 2013 4:23 pm
For now, we're going to make it so that if you fail to do anything at all for X turns (with X TBD, but currently looking like it may be 5), the server will auto forfeit and you will get a loss and no rewards.

We may tune this up or down and/or switch to a different method of detecting AFKers depending on how well it works.
Dave wrote:For now, we're going to make it so that if you fail to do anything at all for X turns (with X TBD, but currently looking like it may be 5), the server will auto forfeit and you will get a loss and no rewards.

We may tune this up or down and/or switch to a different method of detecting AFKers depending on how well it works.

Is this to be consecutive turns or throughout a match, Dave? I frequently lag out on raids for over a minute at a time, I could lose 3+ 'strikes' with one lag easily if I were pvping.

CodeMonkey

Site AdminMon Sep 9, 2013 4:57 pm
Consecutive. We aren't trying to ruin the game if you have a lag spike. The counter will reset as soon as you do something.
Dave wrote:Consecutive. We aren't trying to ruin the game if you have a lag spike. The counter will reset as soon as you do something.

Not really going to stop AFK:ing. I can sit and play Diablo 3 while PvP-sing in Book of Heroes and just make a move once in a while or just watch the health bar and make one last move to reset the counter.

CodeMonkey

Site AdminMon Sep 9, 2013 5:33 pm
We also have logs of how often people fail to act and how long on average it takes them to select a move. If the problem continues we will use other metrics and potentially ban some accounts from PvP.
You do realize you are going to run into false positives with those methods, and thus catch innocent players, right?

This reminds me a lot of DRM, which studios put into their games supposedly to combat piracy. But DRM only harms the legit players, as the pirates simply get cracks and continue playing the game.

In your rush to solve a very small, almost non-problem, be very careful that you don't step on players and thus drive them away from the game.

And as mentioned, you will shrink the pool of pvp players, and thus increase queue times for everyone. There will be a cascade domino effect... war mages who can't win any other way, will simply stop pvp'ing. Other players who are moderately good, will see their win rate plummet as they get matched to better and better players. Thus, they'll stop playing, too.

And all you are left with is a small pool of good players who have to wait 10 minutes to fight each other. Beware the law of unintended consequences.
Saint_Kai wrote:

And all you are left with is a small pool of good players who have to wait 10 minutes to fight each other. Beware the law of unintended consequences.

"Prepare for unforesssseen consssssequencccessss [Mr. Freeman]."