Book of Heroes

PvP: Lack of Balance costing Venan Money

New Subject
PvP: Lack of Balance costing Venan Money

OLD Subject
PvP: Lost Money and Time or AFK Players

You know what costs Venan even more money? Players who come into pvp, see it horribly unbalanced, and tell their friends not to play, and then quit themselves soon after. Especially when they realize they need to spend tons of real world money to be competitive.

In other words, Venan depends on players recommending the game to others. That only happens if players find it fun... or at least can find ways to put up with the more painful aspects. This means unbalanced pvp. And right now, because of the matchingmaking system and class inequalities, many players have only one option to earn tokens: afk-fighting. It makes the pvp bearable. Take that away, and they may decide to quit, and stop recommending the game to others. And if a few quit, their friends soon follow. What keeps a player in a social game, long past the game mechanics, is their friends. I've seen many a WoW guild implode because first a few left, and then their friends did, and then more friends did, etc. It's a chain reaction.

Tell me something... if the 20 second wait between attacks is so bad... what about a player who spends that 20 seconds carefully analyzing their options each time it is their turn to select an attack? You still end up with the same amount of time lost. Do you want to punish those players who are actually considering their options?

Not to mention that this is a web game, and not all connections are equal. There are several times where the pvp server lagged, or I had difficult establishing a connection in the middle of a match, and I auto-attacked 3-4 times. Under the rules above, I would be kicked with a loss. Some of those times, I did manage a comeback, because I got lucky with misses, blocks and dodges while I was unable to respond.

In short, afk players are NOT a problem. Or at least, compared to other problems, this is the bottom of the barrel. They earn Venan money, and they make the game bearable/usable for a lot of players. Considering the cost of a second spec, and the cost of gear/gems/build to make a pvp-worthy character, it is just not worth it for a lot of people. At the very least, it is too time-consuming to expect everyone to be able to instantly shift to having a competitive player in pvp.

Not to mention, there are actually very, very few players who auto-afk fight. I encounter maybe 1 in 10, at most (and most are war mages who barely stand a chance anyway). So the complaining here comes off as sour grapes. Boohoo, I lost an extra minute or two when pvp'ing. I don't see what the issue is: you're limited by your resolve anyway. So even if you finish up matches faster, you still can't do matches faster than anyone else (unless you're spending real world money to do so).

And really, would it really make you feel better to cream a war mage who tries to fight and yet has no chance, rather than if he afk fought? In both cases, you get an easy win. The only difference is ego and an inflated sense of self-importance. Someone thinking their time is more valuable than everyone else's.
Saint_Kai wrote:I've seen many a WoW guild implode because first a few left, and then their friends did, and then more friends did, etc. It's a chain reaction.

Quoting this for truth.

I remember a long time ago when I played World of Warcraft in a somewhat successful raiding guild. Two of the guild leaders were not too fond of each other and started arguing more and more with each other in Voice Chat until the more popular one of them decided he had had enough fighting and left the guild. Soon another player followed, and then another one and withing a few hours there had been a mass emigration. Bam, the end of that guild.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Sep 9, 2013 1:15 pm
Saint_Kai wrote:
right now, because of the matchingmaking system and class inequalities, many players have only one option to earn tokens: afk-fighting. It makes the pvp bearable.

No.

As I have stated many times, my Justicar and War Mage are struggling. If a match is going poorly, I just Basic Attack until the Bout is over.

You do not earn Valor in Raids for just sitting there. You have to press buttons. You do not earn Gem Shards in Dungeons by just sitting there. You have to press buttons.
Kai, you bring up a point that made me consider something. Is part of the reason all this clamor about pvp exists (2nd spec costing so much, huge requirements to respec, etc.) because pvp rewards just aren't worth it? All this respeccing and gs spending is for nothing more than another way to gain cv gems and different looking equipment?

What I mean is... hypothetically, if pvp rewarded T17 equip and it was only found in pvp (not saying this should happen), would that suddenly make pvp's cost fair? People would focus more time/energy to build up a pvp build, grab that second spec much as they currently focus time/energy to build up a pve build and gain energy sigils?

PVE - E sigils to increase raid output from 12e to 42e
PVP - 2nd spec to increase win % to competitive levels without being forced to choose.
Bj_DWR wrote:
Saint_Kai wrote:
right now, because of the matchingmaking system and class inequalities, many players have only one option to earn tokens: afk-fighting. It makes the pvp bearable.

No.

As I have stated many times, my Justicar and War Mage are struggling. If a match is going poorly, I just Basic Attack until the Bout is over.

You do not earn Valor in Raids for just sitting there. You have to press buttons. You do not earn Gem Shards in Dungeons by just sitting there. You have to press buttons.


I totally disagree with the Raids / Dungeons comparison. PVP design is that AFK is possible, and gives rewards. Raid / Dungeon design is not.

Whatever 'moral' arguments either side wishes to bring to the table, the simple fact is that pvp rewards AFK play, although to a lesser extent than non-AFK. It is not against any published rules - at least any that I can find, and I have looked. It is, therefore, a valid play style at this time, just like de-Mighting in PvP to face lower-ability opponents, or 'skunking' raids. All of these are complained about, and de-Mighting / skunking are items I see complained about more.

It may be unpopular amongst the 'serious' PvPers, but I've spoken to a lot of others who like the existence of zombies, as it gives them an easier win.
If Venan decide to make AFK impossible, then some of those players will simply stop PvP. No zombies will mean that others who can generally only beat zombies will stop PvP. Some of both of these groups may stop the game entirely. All of this reduces the already-small PvP playerbase (when compared to the playerbase as a whole). Reducing the PvP playerbase means matching may take longer and have greater variance than currently, which is already a factor many are unhappy with. All of this makes PvP itself less viable.

For the record, I don't PvP, AFK or otherwise. I would like to see PvP offer something that would make me inclined to take part, and I would like it to succeed as an additional feature to the game. There is quite a lot that would need to change in order to get me in. Focussing on removing AFK players is low on the list.
Bj_DWR wrote:No.

As I have stated many times, my Justicar and War Mage are struggling. If a match is going poorly, I just Basic Attack until the Bout is over.

You do not earn Valor in Raids for just sitting there. You have to press buttons. You do not earn Gem Shards in Dungeons by just sitting there. You have to press buttons.

And apparently, the devs are going to use a new system where you will be kicked out for simply auto-attacking every time and earn no rewards. Is this what you want?
Fizz_Eric wrote:Kai, you bring up a point that made me consider something. Is part of the reason all this clamor about pvp exists (2nd spec costing so much, huge requirements to respec, etc.) because pvp rewards just aren't worth it? All this respeccing and gs spending is for nothing more than another way to gain cv gems and different looking equipment?

What I mean is... hypothetically, if pvp rewarded T17 equip and it was only found in pvp (not saying this should happen), would that suddenly make pvp's cost fair? People would focus more time/energy to build up a pvp build, grab that second spec much as they currently focus time/energy to build up a pve build and gain energy sigils?

PVE - E sigils to increase raid output from 12e to 42e
PVP - 2nd spec to increase win % to competitive levels without being forced to choose.

It is incredibly difficult to balance pvp with pve in any game. The successful ones choose which they want to be, and make the other just something fun with no practical rewards. PvP currently has practical rewards in the T5 gems. That is why you have auto-attack and afk players... they are trying to earn t5 gems with their resolve while their energy is down, in order to boost their character for pve play.

Remove the gems from pvp, and only ever have fun rewards like the backgrounds. Remove the weapons and armor, too. The moment you put useful stuff for pve players in there, you will see players attempting to do the minimum to earn them. Make PvP about fun. That is the only surefire way

WoW did have pvp and pve gear with different bonuses on them for different builds, ie, as a paladin, you'd have a damage pvp set and a healing pvp set. But they were geared for pvp, so pve players didn't feel compelled to get it; their pve gear was better for pve. Venan can't go this route with the gear system it has chosen.