So when a justicar can hit you for about 14-16 hits without you being able to respond. All from a .4 second start how is that fair

Brutal strike, seismic shift and stun combined with heroic strength to shorten attack lengths creates an impossible combo. Just ridiculous in my opinion. Great for them. But come on, play fair
MarcusTheVegan wrote:So when a justicar can hit you for about 14-16 hits without you being able to respond. All from a .4 second start how is that fair 
Brutal strike, seismic shift and stun combined with heroic strength to shorten attack lengths creates an impossible combo. Just ridiculous in my opinion. Great for them. But come on, play fair
If you're a SW, just invest in riposte and dodge. This should literally never happen to you.
I haven't once been hit for the full combo. I either dodge one of the two or riposte nullifies the entire thing.
If you're a WM, your stun is the fastest in the game, and your slows should slow justicars down to a slightly more manageable pace before he can do anything. But either way, you're doing something wrong if you're being hit 14-16 times without a response.
That said, I do think justicars are outrageously strong, but for completely different reasons. I can't speak too much for WMs vs. Justis, but Justi's are inherently powerful vs. SWers.
They have higher base damage, higher base defense/block with a heavy shield (which has no downsides). Normally, this would be countered by a SWer's higher base attack speed and dodge. But those are negated due to vengeance/stagger and backswing. A swer specializes in chipping away at an enemy via reflexive strikes, and the then some variation of the smoke bomb - caltrops - stun combos. But when every one of those small poking attacks has a large chance to trigger vengeance/stagger, we're trading a couple hundred damage for a significant damage boost for the justis. And likewise, when I'm running 55%+ dodge... backswing does more damage to me than anything else.
So one would say... hey... maybe lower your dodge right? Sure, then I fall to the above mentioned knockback combo. The general competent SW fighting style is a battle of attrition as it is. Dodge/block/defend as much as possible until you can time a clean hit in between. Unless that clean hit is blocked, triggers stagger, and then hits 5-6k through your defend :p
As a War Mage, yeah, Justicar is nasty. I've managed to figure a few ways to combat them, but they do require a lot of work. First off, raise your dodge. This helps against not only Justicars, but Shadow Walkers, too. I can't count the number of times I got a lucky string of dodges. I got my dodge up to 25% via hero training and gems, and I plan to push it higher.
Next is your fight strategy. I normally go Icy Grasp > Defend > Frozen Shards > Fire Blast. If nothing is resisted, this puts them in a more manageable state. Of course, we all know that with a Justi's higher block rate due to heavy shields, it only takes a single bad instance of a block to ruin your opening, which is your best chance of making it through the fight. Lose the opening, and you're heavily screwed.
At this point, the Justicar normally attempts to do Stunning Blow or Seismic Slash when coming out of the stun. Pay attention to which they do. You want to defend the Seismic, but you want to take the Stunning Blow. So if they attempt to stun, cast something, anything. If you resist, good. If not, that's okay. If you attempt to defend Stunning Blow and succeed, they will seismic after, leaving you open to the combo. You want to try and leave your defend available for Seismic (or Brutal Strike).
As for the rest of the fight, once Stun and Seismic are on cooldown, it is a bit easier. Most of their stuff takes .60+ to do. If they attempt to wound or cleave, take it. Don't defend or Time Void it or Icy Grasp it. If you do, you take those options off the table and you need them for Seismic and Brutal Strike. Instead, if they started casting Wound, and it has .33 left to finish, then do Ice Lance or Incinerate. I usually do Ice Lance. After Wound lands, they attempt to block, and with a little luck, you push back their defend timer a bit. This allows you to go into Incinerate, which should land right after their defend wears off.
Above all else, try to time moves to land just after theirs. You need to make sure you have time enough to react to Brutal or Seismic. Heroic Will can mess this up, but with luck, they'll hold off a bit on using it, hoping to trigger it during a combo. Either way, if you can time your moves to land with a few tenths of a second from theirs, you will give yourself plenty of time to easily respond with defend or a stun. With a high enough dodge (and a shield to block with), you have to trust on luck that you can block or dodge part of the combo, and thus render it useless.
Remember, this is now coin flip pvp. It's all about luck, so go with that. Fully spec for deep freeze and snap cast. If luck goes your way, you'll get out far ahead enough to win a fight. Ice Shield procs help, too, but they don't do anything against a pushback.
One last thing: if you do get stagger, try to let them land a stunning blow or radiant light. You need to be hit to remove it, because while it is up, you're taking incredible damage from the Wound stack. Once you get comfortable enough with the tactics above, you can also learn to use Time Void or Icy grasp more freely to let a wound stack fall off, or leave an ice shield up for longer periods of time to absorb the wound damage.
Oh, and one very last thing: Stunning Blow has a 5 second cooldown, and Seismic Slash has a 6 second cooldown. Keep track of Stunning blow with Icy Grasp, as they both have a 5 second cooldown. And realize that Seismic takes a little longer than that. If you know those two moves are on cooldown, you can be more liberal in your cast times. However, Heroic Will reduces their cooldown by 3 seconds, so be mindful. If they've just used those two moves, though, then you have a couple of seconds to be safe. Many times I've purposefully left myself open after stunning blow and Seismic slash, so they pop Heroic Will and Brutal strike and hit me... but then realize their stun and Seismic are still on cooldown, so they've essentially wasted it.
But yeah, Justicar needs a speed penalty for heavy shields and armor. Perhaps a 1-5% slow for each piece of heavy armor or shield. Wound needs to be changed to only have a chance of proc'ing on a physical attack. No more Radiant Lights just to refresh/add a stack of wound. And perhaps make a pushback debuff; once you get hit with a pushback, you get the debuff, and can't be hit with another pushback until it wears off. This would limit the combo.
I've run into a few good Justicars who can win without the use of the combo, but they're rare. Most depend upon that combo, and your job is learning enough about it to make it's success less likely. Take that away, and they're more manageable pickings. Not easy, but at least more even.
yeah forget your defend button vs Justicars. Only defend Seismic and Brutal. Kinda bad game mechanic from the developers that defending is counterproductive.
Just happened again twice, I'm a WM. Already had full slow on him but wore off mid combo, so nothing I could do. Appreciate the comments above but I'd frozen him already, put full slow on then got hit for 20k without reply. Nothing you can do but standby and watch like a corpse.
MarcusTheVegan wrote:Just happened again twice, I'm a WM. Already had full slow on him but wore off mid combo, so nothing I could do. Appreciate the comments above but I'd frozen him already, put full slow on then got hit for 20k without reply. Nothing you can do but standby and watch like a corpse.
What enchants, if any, do you use? If it's the damage that's killing you, try the defense enchant.
I'm a WM and have high dodge, but end up dying to unblockable backswings. I feel like the only way I win is by pure luck.
Defense enchant means you go without status resist enchant. The latter is more valuable, as it can help resist the Wound and stagger debuffs.
Remember initial combo: Icy Grasp > Defend > Frozen Shards/Ice Storm > Fire Blast. Defend against Seismic Slash and Brutal Strike only (can also Time Void Brutal Strike, if you can fit in an Ice lance/Frozen Shards/Fire Blast first).
One other trick you can do, and this works against Shadow Walker, too. If you do Icy Grasp first, and they defend, and your Icy Grasp is resisted, don't despair! Start up an Ice Lance. Odds are you can time it land after the Defend is over, and pushback their next ability. Then fit in a Frozen Shards, and evaluate the situation from there.
And keep track of their timers! Don't get caught with more than .35 or .30 left on your cast, when they are choosing an ability. To do this, If they are doing something long like Wound, that has .40 left, then do an Ice Lance. It will land after the Wound, so they either get a pushback on their next ability, or if they defend, that gives you enough time to follow up with incinerate.
In other words, pick a big spell when they do a big move. Think about how much casting time you'll have left when their next move lands, and try to keep it under .30. That means you're safe enough to land the move before they can land seismic, and thus defend against it.
But yes, even with skill, you still need a lot of luck. Venan has made pvp mostly luck-based, so it really isn't a contest of skill so much. Just gear, enchants, gems, and luck.
Saint_Kai wrote:Defense enchant means you go without status resist enchant. The latter is more valuable, as it can help resist the Wound and stagger debuffs.
See, I'm torn on this. A part of me still feels like the less luck-based I can make fights, the better off I'll be, which is why I chose Defense over Stat Resist. I'd rather take the stun + attack, and mitigate 61% of the damage (to date, no justi has hit me for over 4-5k) than have a 27% chance of resisting. Especially with less health pools, put the other way, I'd rather take 39% damage with just defend as my resist than 66% damage w/ a 27% chance of resisting.
As to time void usage, mith has a great post on when and how to use it properly. Might be useful looking into that.
And Kiabella, as a SWer, justi backswings do terrifying amounts of damage to me (since I'm running 55% dodge). Unfortunately its part of the justi build.
I have three status resist @ level 5. Lol I'm not resetting to defence on the off chance it may help

I have 20% dodge too, bit as in all things sometimes they just don't come off. I'm no novice either 26k might and a 2:1 win ratio with knocking on 500 wins. Justi's against Wm's when they have high haste can just blow you away.