I know many of us have only one main character so it's easy to biased towards the one that you play. I admit that I don't know exactly how WM's work and what they need to win if luck is not a factor (which it is big time in this game). That been said, all those skills mentioned above would be good counters to Ice Shield except for two things:
a) The Ice Shield can proc multiple times in a row. This of course is a matter of luck, but it often prevents tactical removal of the shield with other skills.
b) SW can't always use Reflexive Strike, Caltrops, Ensnare or Smoke Bomb to remove the shield because of the necessary rotations and long cool downs on Ensnare and Smoke Bomb. If, for example, I use Reflexive Strike just to remove Ice Shield, I often don't have the window to land Piercing Strike anymore (during stuns for example) without risking a heavy damage or cc on myself. Sometimes it is just not possible to use those skills or you otherwise gimp yourself out of win. And you may not even remove the shield 'cause it can proc again.
Anyway, if you guys feel like WM is at a bad place atm., I believe you. What I was pointing out is that it is pretty frustrating to manage your rotation for a big skill opening, only to be blocked by Ice Shield, often multiple times in a match (and on top of that there's your usual block or dodge chance).
I can't really agree with Kiabellas suggestion to make Ice Shield even stronger because it is already a heavily luck based passive. I personally would not want to win because of pure luck or one really strong skill. I also don't symphatise very much with her because I think she has something like 70-80% win ratio on her WM
- Sonnet