Book of Heroes

Raid sign up sheet

I think it would help guilds to organize raids if they knew how many to expect that will come. The idea is simple.

First some who is capable chooses a time in near future to run a raid (say within 24h). Once this happens, somewhere in guild menu u have a notification of an upcoming raid. U can select it to see more details. U also would have the option to press a button to sign up for that raid... or unsign if ur plans change. Whoever started that event, or perhaps anyone who can start these events, sees how many ppl are promising to show up. That way he know who they are, their might, and so on... so he knows what raid to run to suit this group.
Most guilds send a guild mail, players respond saying they will make it and maybe 1/2 who responded actually show up. Either way you do it, real life happens and it never works out as planned. Best way to do it is make a schedule and stick to it. If members can't seem to make it then adjust. If your still having issues it's time to start recruiting.

The success of a guild relies a lot on the GM maintaining and managing the guild. That means you gotta kick inactive players/alts to make room for new active members. You can't wait too long or your active members will move on.

This is a constant revolving door that takes great management for a guild to succeed.
one of my guilds sometimes makes a trick to simulate sign up.
they say in guild chat that raid say vg estimated in x server time or when enough participants.
some 20-30 mins before x they starting other raid say plague rider. each toon intending to participate in vg making one hit in plague rider as sign up.
after enough in-vg starting.
this trick especially useful for preparation to speed run when participation is vital.
CrzyHopper.. while u make some valid points, the mail feature is very limited and not equipped to deal with this. Why have whisper if u can mail? The differences r subtle but significant. The sign up has the effect that the more ppl sign up and others see who signs up, the more other ppl are likely to want to participate.