Book of Heroes

Guild power

It could be. This can be easily confirmed by checking power before & after a raid, and recording total RPP for the Guild.

I will do this for our next raid after the 11am Update.

Lady_Katy

Site AdminThu Jul 5, 2012 10:54 am
We talk about it a little bit in the FAQ: FAQ
What is the difference between Guild Power and Guild Prestige?
Guild power and prestige are ways to show who the most powerful guilds are. Guild Prestige is earned by completing Guild Challenges. The overall Might of the guild members is also factored into Guild Prestige.
Guild Power shows the guild that is currently the most successful raiding guild. The more a guild raids, the higher their Power. Power decays over time, so if a guild stops raiding, they will start to fall down the Power leaderboard.
There has been much discussion in our Guild about how Guild Power rankings are calculated.

We think that they are derived purely from Raiding, and that they increase from completed raids. We know they diminish over time, at midnight EDT. We wonder if a failed raid or cancelling a raid damages the rating.

Here's my suggested model for how it works. I don't know the exact mechanism, this is just for illustration.

ILLUSTRATIVE THEORY 1 - 50% dropoff Daily
Our example Guild raids twice a day, adding exactly 5,000 points to our power for each raid. Each day at midnight we lose 50% of our accumulated raid points.

Day 1 11:59pm Power ranking = 10,000
Day 2 00:01am Power ranking = 5,000
Day 2 11:59pm Power ranking = 15,000
Day 3 00:01am Power ranking = 7,500
Day 3 11:59pm Power ranking = 17,500
Day 4 00:01am Power ranking = 8,750
Day 4 11:59pm Power ranking = 18,750

And so it goes. After 16 days of constant raiding success, our rating at 11:59pm is 20,000. As long as we continue at 2x 5,000 raids a day, we can never break that 20,000 point barrier. BUT On day 17 we fail a raid. Curses! Tragedy!

Day 17: 00:01am Power ranking = 10,000
Day 17 11:59pm Power ranking = 15,000
Day 18 00:01am Power ranking = 7,500

That one failure just took us back to our day 3 Power Rating! Triple Curses! But it wasn't that we had points subtracted for the failed (or cancelled) raid, just that we didn't accrue the necessary points that day to maintain our rating.

OK, we grind on at 2 x 5,000 a day and on day 31, we finally restore our 11:59 score to 20,000

New month, new raid. Now our raids score 7,500 power points each.

Day 32: 11:59pm Power ranking = 25,000
Day 33: 00:01am Power ranking = 12,500
Day 33: 11:59pm Power ranking = 27,500
Day 34: 00:01am Power ranking = 13,750

And so it goes. We grind on until Day 46 when our rating tops out at 30,000 at 11:59pm. Again we've hit a ceiling which we cannot break through, unless we add more raids, or higher level raids.


ILLUSTRATIVE THEORY 2 - 25% dropoff Daily
OK, that was a very simple spreadsheet calculation, and we don't seem to see such a huge drop in ratings every day, so let's assume that we lose 1/4 of our accumulated rating every day.

Day 1 11:59pm Power ranking = 10,000
Day 2 00:01am Power ranking = 7,500
Day 2 11:59pm Power ranking = 17,500
Day 3 00:01am Power ranking = 13,125
Day 3 11:59pm Power ranking = 23,125
Day 4 00:01am Power ranking = 17,344
Day 4 11:59pm Power ranking = 27,344

In this scenario, our rating tops out at 60,000 points after 68 days grinding the same 10,000 points every day. Again, we can't bust that ceiling until we up the number or power of our raids.

Now we haven't had 60 days since the Guild system was introduced (May 23rd 2012), in fact we're on day 43. At 10,000 points a day and a 1/4 rating dropoff every night, we've only reached a total of 59,363 by midnight Day 43, so we're still climbing a little every day even with the same basic 2x 5,000 raids.

I don't think the dropoff are calculated as simply as this, though they might be. More likely the %age drop varies for how old the scored points are. We also don't do just two 5,000 point raids a day, and we can't possibly do the same raids for exactly the same points every day.

How raids score points is another issue for another post, but I think my theory show that you don't have to be penalised for failing a raid to see a drop in your total Power points, you just have to not score positive points.
Thannks Lady Katy, that isn't quite the question Zypher is asking if I understand correctly.

The question is, "if our Guild score a total of 50,000 RPP between us in a raid, does that add 50,000 to our Power Rating?"

A raid finished faster almost always results in slightly higher RPP (because people were burning Gold and didn't have to do the 100, 105, 110 etc progression so often). If it was just a larger number of people involved, it can still finish fast but the RPP total will be about the same.

e.g. Guild A do a raid with 50 rounds. 50 people complete 1 round each. Total RPP scores = 5,000
Guild B do a raid with 50 rounds. One player fights all 50 rounds (he's doing some serious GS burn). Total RPP = 7225

Thus Guild B get a higher boost to their power rating for completing the same raid, by 44.5%

If this is correct, then people dropping in and scoring less than 1375 RPP are actually hurting their guild's power ranking, assuming the raid would have succeded anyway, because they have taken 150 RPP scores off other toons and replaced them with a build up RPP score of between 100 and 145 RPP.

The RPP/round buildup and GS burn accounts for the variation in total RPP scores for the same raid. e.g. I have logged 'Attack at dawn' raids with accumulated Guild RPP between 48,385 and 61,160. The difference is that the second raid had one particularly high scorer who was burning GS like crazy.

Lord_Venan

Site AdminThu Jul 5, 2012 10:01 pm
I think we've mentioned this elsewhere, but I'll summarize how power works (which should be clearer now via the raid reports).

1. Power earned from a raid is based on completion time and the specified power rating we assign each raid. Harder raids = more power. Longer raids = more power.
2. RPP has no correlation to power earned.
3. Power decay is based on a 30 day window. The day of the raid, all of the power earned goes to your guild power amount. Each day afterwards, the value from that day decays and after 30 days will no longer contribute to your rating. The precise numbers will not be mentioned by us and may be changed, but if you care to reverse engineer, we won't stop you :)

The gist is that when we start getting several guilds in the end-game scenario, all doing the hardest raids, those that are able to do those raids the fastest will be deemed the most powerful. That being said, this is subject to change based on our own observations and everyone's wonderful feedback :)
Nice assumptions, gj. But I know it doesn't work like that because one day we lost more power than earned during the day.
Hai5 wrote:Nice assumptions, gj. But I know it doesn't work like that because one day we lost more power than earned during the day.

We noticed! :(
Guild Power shows the guild that is currently the most successful raiding guild. The more a guild raids, the higher their Power. Power decays over time, so if a guild stops raiding, they will start to fall down the Power leaderboard.

I think that's BS. We haven't stopped raiding and the decay is about as much power as we earn in a given day. And god help us if we actually want a weekend as players. I suspect that somewhere in the equation is the guild's level because as soon as we hit lvl6 our power ranking stopped moving up. If that's true then once we hit lvl7 our power ranking will start to drop in spite of us successfully clearing 2x Vallus, 2x CK and throwing Zuur in periodically to help out people that still need SV for Vallus per day.