Book of Heroes

Can't crit on a blocked attack?

This doesn't seem right... Crits and blocks should be rolled separately. Just because an attack is mitigated to half damage should not determine whether it was critical damage or not. Correct me if I'm wrong but this appears to be how it's functioning, and seems to make shields too much of a no brainer.
Monkey006 wrote:This doesn't seem right... Crits and blocks should be rolled separately. Just because an attack is mitigated to half damage should not determine whether it was critical damage or not. Correct me if I'm wrong but this appears to be how it's functioning, and seems to make shields too much of a no brainer.

Think about it though. If the hit is being blocked it wouldn't be 'critical' it would just be a smack on a shield.

Now if your saying a Critical hit should override a block because it's a 'critical' hit I could agree with that.

But who's to say the critical hits you hit your opponent with aren't overriding their blocks?

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Oct 23, 2013 8:09 pm
The original RPG concept of a critical hit is that you got in a precise blow, you took advantage of a major opening of your opponents defense, your opponent exposed a critical weakness to your attack, etc..the idea being the hit was set for a very good landing.

By this RPG original theory.. if your opponent blocked the key, precise, well aimed hit...then it can't be a crit, it didn't land or strike. It has nothing to do with you were swinging extra hard and they blocked it..more that you had a sweet shot and they blocked it; In which case a block takes precedence.

That is how I view it in theory, and what I believe Venan implemented.

Of course, being a game...its all semantics anyway.